Abstract:This paper develops new insights into quantitative methods for the validation of computational model prediction. Four types of methods are investigated, namely classical and Bayesian hypothesis testing, a reliability-based method, and an area metric-based method. Traditional Bayesian hypothesis testing is extended based on interval hypotheses on distribution parameters and equality hypotheses on probability distributions, in order to validate models with deterministic/stochastic output for given inputs. Formulations and implementation details are outlined for both equality and interval hypotheses. Two types of validation experiments are considered—fully characterized (all the model/experimental inputs are measured and reported as point values) and partially characterized (some of the model/experimental inputs are not measured or are reported as intervals). Bayesian hypothesis testing can minimize the risk in model selection by properly choosing the model acceptance threshold, and its results can be used in model averaging to avoid Type I /II errors. It is shown that Bayesian interval hypothesis testing, the reliability-based method, and the area metric-based method can account for the existence of directional bias, where the mean predictions of a numerical model may be consistently below or above the corresponding experimental observations. It is also found that under some specific conditions, the Bayes factor metric in Bayesian equality hypothesis testing and the reliability-based metric can both be mathematically related to the p-value metric in classical hypothesis testing. Numerical studies are conducted to apply the above validation methods to gas damping prediction for radio frequency (RF) micro-electro-mechanical-system (MEMS) switches. The model of interest is a general polynomial chaos (gPC) surrogate model constructed based on expensive runs of a physics-based simulation model, and validation data are collected from fully characterized experiments.

The validation of models in an imaging infrared simulation

An Image Synthesis Model for Object Infrared Signature Based on Infrared Physics and Heat Transfer

Model Validation for Vision Systems via Graphics Simulation

Analysis of the Simulation Model Based on Remote Sensing Imaging under Vibration

Model Validation Via Uncertainty Propagation and Data Transformations

A Realistic Image Synthesis Model For Infrared Scene

Simulations for Validation of Vision Systems

An Infrared Image Synthesis Model

An Infrared Image Synthesis Model For Large-Scale Complex Urban Scene

A Global Infrared Image Synthesis Model for Large-Scale Complex Urban Scene

Validation of image systems simulation technology using a Cornell Box

An Infrared Image Synthesis Model Based on Infrared Physics and Heat Transfer

The Validation of A Microscopic Simulation Model: A Methodological Case Study

A New Validation Metric for Models with Correlated Responses Using Limited Experimental and Simulation Data

An Infrared Image Synthesis Model for High-Speed Targets

On (in)validating environmental models. 1. Principles for formulating a Turing‐like Test for determining when a model is fit‐for purpose

A Multi-Layered Approach for Measuring the Simulation-to-Reality Gap of Radar Perception for Autonomous Driving

A Soft Calibration Technique for Infrared Imaging Based on Physical Model of Thermal Radiation and Variational Bayesian Inference from Small Dataset

Assessment Criteria for Computational Fluid Dynamics Model Validation Experiments

Quantitative model validation techniques: New insights