Abstract:The two most common types of electoral systems (ES) used in electing national legislatures are proportional representation and plurality voting. When they are evaluated, most often the arguments come from social choice theory and political sciences. The former overall uses an axiomatic approach including a list of mathematical criteria a system should fulfill. The latter predominantly focuses on the trade-off between proportionality of apportionment and governability. However, there is no consensus on the best ES, nor on the set of indexes and measures that would be the most important in such assessment. Moreover, the ongoing debate about the fairness of national elections neglects the study of their vulnerabilities. Here we address this research gap with a framework that can measure electoral systems' vulnerability to different means of influence. Using in silico analysis we show that plurality voting systems are less stable than proportional representation. They are also more susceptible to political agitators and media propaganda. A review of real-world ES reveals possible improvements in their design leading to lower susceptibility. Additionally, our simulation framework allows computation of popular indexes, as the Gallagher index or the effective number of parties, in different scenarios. Our work provides a new tool for dealing with modern threats to democracy that could destabilize voting processes. Furthermore, our results add an important argument in a long-standing discussion on evaluation of ES.

Electoral systems and international trade policy

Trade Protectionism and Electoral Competition: An Empirical Investigation

Electoral Competiton and Optimal Tariffs

Electoral Competition and Optimal Tariffs

Electoral Systems, Legislative Process, and Income Taxation

Trade Politics: A Heckscher-Ohlin-Downs Framework

International R&D Collaboration and Strategic Trade Policy

Trade wars and trade disputes: The role of equity and political support

Vulnerability of democratic electoral systems

Voters and the trade-off between policy stability and responsiveness

The politics of tariff cooperation in the presence of trade costs

Trading with the Opponent:A State-Society Analysis Framework

Political competition and bilateral direct investments

Trade, Democracy, and the Gravity Equation

Does Trade Liberalization with China Influence U.S. Elections?

On the Robustness of Democratic Electoral Processes to Computational Propaganda

Who votes for free trade and when? Geopolitics as the source of legislative preferences on free trade agreements

Beyond coercion: Weaker states' domestic political motivations for political clauses in preferential trade agreements

EL E C T O R A L SY S T E M S ,L E GI S L A TI V E PR O C E S S, A N D IN C CO O M E TA X A AT TI O N

Elections As a Conflict Processing Mechanism

Bilateral Tariffs Under International Competition