Will Hospitals Finally Listen to Nurses?
Olga Yakusheva,Katie Boston-Leary
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.4104
2024-04-10
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:While the US health care system is beginning to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic, hospitals are still operating with many unfilled nursing positions. The nurse vacancy rate has jumped from 8% prepandemic to 16% to 17% by 2022 and remains there. Even though overall hospital employment numbers may have bounced back to prepandemic levels, they are yet to reach their prepandemic growth trend. 1 According to the American Nurses Association (ANA), more than one-half of hospital-employed nurses feel their administration is not doing enough to retain and attract staff. Becker's Hospital Review reports nursing and other healthcare worker strikes increased from approximately10 per year during the 2017 to 2021 period to 18 strikes in 2022, further rising to an unprecedented 27 strikes in 2023. 2 Two new studies from the University of Pennsylvania 3 ,4 focus on the challenges with recruitment and retention of registered nurses. Led by Dr Jane Muir, PhD, RN, FNP-BC, the studies 3 ,4 draw on data from the RN4CAST survey conducted in New York and Illinois between 2018 and 2021. Complementing each other, one of the studies 3 examines responses from nurses who recently ended health care employment, while the other includes emergency department (ED) nurses who are currently employed but may not consider their organization a good place to work. 4 In both studies, 3 ,4 not having enough staff was the key concern driving nurses away or causing dissatisfaction. Nurses who have left also cited burnout and family responsibilities, 3 while those still employed in the ED also pointed to workplace violence, safety concerns, and a lack of appreciation and job satisfaction as major issues. 4 Together, these studies send a strong message that increasing staff numbers, easing burnout, making the workplace safer, and balancing the demands of work and home life are essential actions employers can take to keep nurses working and attract new ones. Muir and her team's work 3 ,4 adds to the substantial evidence of the critical importance of adequate nurse staffing levels and a positive work environment for nurse retention and recruitment. In its 2021 letter to Secretary Xavier Becerra of the Department of Health and Human Services, the ANA declared a national nurse staffing crisis and called for immediate action to develop and implement solutions. The 2022 Nurse Staffing Task Force, a collaborative initiative by the ANA and other prominent national nursing and health care organizations, has developed and widely disseminated a set of recommendations for hospitals focusing on investing in nurse staffing, safe and supportive work environments, and competitive wages. Yet hospitals have been reluctant to implement the recommendations, instead advocating for increasing the supply of new nursing school graduates and immigrant nurses. A consistent influx of new nurses is undoubtedly needed to grow the nursing workforce, yet without correcting the issues nurses face at the bedside and improving retention, it may not provide a long-term solution. Let us not forget that nursing turnover and retention is not a new problem. According to the ANA, a whopping 20% of new nurses have been leaving the profession in their first employment year for almost a decade prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. 5 Why are hospitals not listening to the voices of nurses? Why does it seem that the scales are tipped more toward profit than patient care? The answer may lie in the market dynamics driving the US health care system. In health care, like in any market-led industry, expenditure must be justified by corresponding revenue in reimbursements. In plain terms, for hospitals to rationalize financial investment in nursing, each additional dollar allocated to nursing must be offset by a commensurate increase in revenue. Conversely, every dollar saved on nursing staff appears, from a fiscal standpoint, as a dollar gained. Underpinning this economic equation is the existing value-based hospital reimbursement model, where a maximum of 6% percent of a hospital's revenue is linked to the quality of care through various hospital pay-for-performance programs, with the remaining 94% is largely determined by patient admission numbers. 6 Consequently, unless nursing shortages reach a critical point where they lead to bed closures and impede revenue from the volume of hospital admissions, the monetary returns to expenditures on the quality aspect of nursing care remain marginal at best. Importantly, the crux of the problem is not necessarily that hospitals lack financial resources to invest in nursing, it is just that doing so is not always in their best immediate financial interest. One might expect that industry regulations or nurse-to-patient ratios could mandate improved nurse sta -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal