Evolutionary stability strategies of tacit collusion in supervised container terminals

Zongtuan Liu,Gang Dong,Shaopeng Shang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40747-023-01334-7

IF: 6.7

2024-01-29

Complex & Intelligent Systems

Abstract:Abstract To investigate the long-term effects of the Port Authority’s supervision strategies on the container terminal’s collusion strategies, this study constructs a two-sided evolutionary game model consists of the Port Authority and a container terminal based on evolutionary game theory which usually examine a game’s long-term trends. Under the premise that the container terminal’s net profits from collusion strategy are greater than those from non-collusion strategy, the stability analysis demonstrates that the container terminal tend to choose collusion strategy, and the Port Authority tends to choose lax supervision strategy when the fine received by the container terminal is less than the Port Authority’s cost; the container terminal tends to choose collusion strategy, and the Port Authority tends to choose strict supervision strategy when the fine received by the container terminal is greater than the Port Authority’s cost and the sum of the fine and subsidy is less than the difference in the container terminal’s profits from collusion strategies. Finally, the numerical simulation results confirm the robustness of the stability analysis. These results can guide and benefit relevant stakeholders in the sustainable development of the container shipping supply chain.

computer science, artificial intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how the supervision strategies of port authorities influence the collusion strategies of container terminals in the long-term development of container terminals. Specifically, the study constructs a bilateral evolutionary game model based on evolutionary game theory to explore the optimal evolutionary stable strategies (ESS) between container terminals and port authorities under different scenarios. The study mainly focuses on the following three questions:

1. What are the long-term optimal evolutionary stable strategies for container terminals and port authorities under different scenarios?
2. How to adopt the long-term optimal strategies for container terminals and port authorities?
3. Can social welfare be improved after implementing the optimal strategies?

By introducing the evolutionary game model, verifying the robustness of the analysis, and conducting numerical simulations, the study aims to provide guidance for relevant stakeholders to promote the sustainable development of the container shipping supply chain.