Emergy analysis of three industrial reverse osmosis concentrate zero liquid discharge processes: Technical, economic and environmental comparison

Shida Li,Zhongya Fan,Shaokui Zheng,Fantang Zeng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.140777
IF: 11.1
2024-01-01
Journal of Cleaner Production
Abstract:Reverse osmosis (RO) technology has been widely applied for advanced treatment of industrial wastewater, but it inevitably produces RO concentrate (ROC) containing high levels of toxic refractory organics and salinity. Evaporation crystallization processes are widely used to achieve zero liquid discharge (ZLD) of industrial ROC, but they have the potential to negatively impact the surrounding environment and economy due to their high energy requirements. It is of significance to evaluate the technical, economic and environmental benefits of ROC ZLD processes to provide a foundation for the extensive uses of ROC ZLD procedures. This work conducted an emergy-based analysis to evaluate the comprehensive benefits of three alternative ROC ZLD processes (scenario A: multiple-effect evaporation (MED); scenario B: ozonation + RO + MED; scenario C: continuous-flow electrolytic system with a front buffer tank (CFS–C) + RO + MED). Compared with scenario A, the resource inputs required for per m3 ROC disposal of scenarios B and C were decreased by 31% and 34% respectively; the emergy investment ratios of scenarios B and C were decreased by 30% and 33% respectively while the emergy yield ratios were both increased by 21%; the environmental loading ratios of scenarios B and C were decreased by 25% and 29% respectively while the environmental sustainability indexes were increased by 58% and 71% respectively. The results showed that scenarios B and C outperformed scenario A in terms of technical, economic, and environmental benefits; additionally, the technical advantages of scenario C outweighed scenario B, and scenario C was finally recommended for future implementation.
environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?