Abstract:The structural demographic theory for industrialized societies generates three testable predictions. The first prediction is that labor oversupply leads to declining (relative) wages. The second prediction is that labor oversupply leads to elite overproduction: as relative wages fall, elite incomes display a hump-shaped pattern while elite numbers increase. The third prediction is that elite overproduction leads to political instability. I test these predictions on US data by combining evidence from existing studies with empirical proxies for elite numbers and elite income. The predictions are not supported by the data. First, labor oversupply cannot explain the polarization of wages and the decline in relative wages. The largest share in wage variance is explained by automation. Second, the data shows that as relative wages fall, elite incomes increase, in contrast to the hump-shaped pattern displayed by the model. Third, elite overproduction did not predict political instability in the last decades. Political instability is modelled by the Political Stress Index (PSI). The reviewed evidence shows that the increase in the model based PSI in the last decades is driven by the increase in inequality. The rise in inequality was caused by technological change, globalisation and to a lesser extent by the erosion of labor market institutions. Attributing the rise in inequality and the resulting increase in political instability to labor oversupply rather than to the lost race between education and technology may weaken incentives to design effective policies addressing the inefficiencies in the US education system.

Structured Inequality, Conflict, and Control: A Cross-National Test of the Threat Hypothesis

The Threat of Communism during the Cold War: A Constraint to Income Inequality?

Inequality, concentrated disadvantage, and homicide: towards a multi-level theory of economic inequality and crime

Preferences for group dominance track and mediate the effects of macro-level social inequality and violence across societies

How Social Class Shapes Attitudes on Economic Inequality: The Competing Forces of Self-Interest and Legitimation

The structural-demographic theory revisited: An empirical test for industrialized societies

Do Rights to Resistance Discipline the Elites? An Experiment on the Threat of Overthrow

How does economic inequality shape conspiracy theories? Empirical evidence from China

Upholding the Social Hierarchy

The Influence of Inequality on Welfare Generosity

Success of economic sanctions threats: coercion, information and commitment

Exponential Structure of Income Inequality: Evidence from 67 Countries

Tax the élites! The role of economic inequality and conspiracy beliefs on attitudes towards taxes and redistribution intentions

Neural Responses to Sanction Threats in Two-Party Economic Exchange

Economic Inequality and Belief in Meritocracy in the United States

Justifying Social Inequalities: The Role of Social Darwinism

Income Inequality and Social Dysfunction

Structural adjustment, alienation, and mass protest

Minority Threat, Worker Power, and Discriminatory Complaints: State-level Effects on Racial Income Inequality among Men

Economic Inequality and Unfairness Evaluations of Income Distribution Negatively Predict Political and Social Trust: Evidence From Latin America Over 23 Years

Revisiting the Income Inequality-Crime Puzzle