Abstract:Individuals often continue to rely on misinformation in their reasoning and decision making even after it has been corrected. This is known as the continued influence effect, and one of its presumed drivers is misinformation familiarity. As continued influence can promote misguided or unsafe behaviours, it is important to find ways to minimize the effect by designing more effective corrections. It has been argued that correction effectiveness is reduced if the correction repeats the to-be-debunked misinformation, thereby boosting its familiarity. Some have even suggested that this familiarity boost may cause a correction to inadvertently increase subsequent misinformation reliance; a phenomenon termed the familiarity backfire effect. A study by Pluviano et al. (2017) found evidence for this phenomenon using vaccine-related stimuli. The authors found that repeating vaccine "myths" and contrasting them with corresponding facts backfired relative to a control condition, ironically increasing false vaccine beliefs. The present study sought to replicate and extend this study. We included four conditions from the original Pluviano et al. study: the myths vs. facts, a visual infographic, a fear appeal, and a control condition. The present study also added a "myths-only" condition, which simply repeated false claims and labelled them as false; theoretically, this condition should be most likely to produce familiarity backfire. Participants received vaccine-myth corrections and were tested immediately post-correction, and again after a seven-day delay. We found that the myths vs. facts condition reduced vaccine misconceptions. None of the conditions increased vaccine misconceptions relative to control at either timepoint, or relative to a pre-intervention baseline; thus, no backfire effects were observed. This failure to replicate adds to the mounting evidence against familiarity backfire effects and has implications for vaccination communications and the design of debunking interventions.

Correcting vaccine misinformation on social media: the inadvertent effects of repeating misinformation within such corrections on COVID-19 vaccine misperceptions

Correcting vaccine misinformation: A failure to replicate familiarity or fear-driven backfire effects

One Dose Is Not Enough: The Beneficial Effect of Corrective COVID-19 Information Is Diminished If Followed by Misinformation

Correction Experiences on Social Media During COVID-19

A meta-analysis of correction effects in science-relevant misinformation

Listening to misinformation while driving: Cognitive load and the effectiveness of (repeated) corrections.

Why Do People Believe in Vaccine Misinformation? The Roles of Perceived Familiarity and Evidence Type

Exploring the impact of automated correction of misinformation in social media

Feeling angry: the effects of vaccine misinformation and refutational messages on negative emotions and vaccination attitude

Enhancing misinformation correction: New variants and a combination of awareness training and counter-speech to mitigate belief perseverance bias

Does explaining the origins of misinformation improve the effectiveness of a given correction?

How Misinformation and Rebuttals in Online Comments Affect People’s Intention to Receive COVID-19 Vaccines: The Roles of Psychological Reactance and Misperceptions

The impact of confirmation bias awareness on mitigating susceptibility to misinformation

One Year of COVID-19 Vaccine Misinformation on Twitter: Longitudinal Study

Correcting statistical misinformation about scientific findings in the media: Causation versus correlation.

(Mis)perceptions and Engagement on Twitter: COVID-19 Vaccine Rumors on Efficacy and Mass Immunization Effort

How social media users become misinformed: The roles of news-finds-me perception and misinformation exposure in COVID-19 misperception

Fighting COVID-19 Misinformation on Social Media: Experimental Evidence for a Scalable Accuracy-Nudge Intervention

Misinformation interventions decay rapidly without an immediate posttest

Debriefing works: Successful retraction of misinformation following a fake news study

Marketplaces of Misinformation: A Study of How Vaccine Misinformation Is Legitimized on Social Media