Abstract:When it comes to evaluating the causal effect of public policies on corporate performance, most studies tend to focus exclusively on targeted firms, as if these firms have no relationship to the rest of the economy. Yet, public policies are highly likely to influence non-targeted firms indirectly due to the relationships they have with targeted firms. This paper aims to fill this gap by evaluating the indirect causal effect of a new French cluster-innovation policy on the financial and employment outcomes of non-targeted companies. To do so, it focuses on French Technological Research Institutes, which are science-industry collaborations based on technology platforms that bring together SMEs, large companies, universities, and public research bodies with the goal of accelerating the transfer of knowledge towards firms and generating spillovers (indirect effects) inside and outside the scheme. Based on the literature on spillover effects and agglomeration economies, it can be assumed that industry-specific spillovers tend to be spatially concentrated. By comparing a non-targeted firm located in the NUTS-3 regions within which the policy was implemented (referred to as "treated regions"), to a non-targeted firm outside of these "treated regions", using a difference-in-differences method with fixed effects applied to panel data (2008–2016) combined with a double matching at the NUTS-3 region and firm level, we find that non-targeted firms located in the "treated regions" significantly improve their financial performance (turnover, financial autonomy) compared to control firms located in the NUTS-3 control regions. The dynamics of employment outcomes are ambiguous. A negative significant effect is observed on the proportion of managers at the beginning of the policy and a positive significant effect is noted later, at the end of the period of observation. An analysis of the dynamics of the effects indicates that performance does not improve immediately after the policy, but later in time.

The Labor Market Effects of Loan Guarantee Programs

How does government-backed finance affect SMEs' crisis predictors?

Long-term effects of hiring subsidies for low-educated unemployed youths

Public Credit Guarantee Schemes and SMEs’ Profitability: Evidence from Italy

Macroeconomic Effects of Active Labour Market Policies: A Novel Instrumental Variables Approach

Solving the Gordian knot: dealing with Spain's unemployment crisis with a job guarantee program

The Heterogeneous Effects of Active Labour Market Policies in Switzerland

Labor Market Policies in High- and Low-Interest Rate Environments: Evidence from the Euro Area

Can direct innovation subsidies relax SMEs’ financial constraints?

The hazards of delivering a public loan guarantee scheme: An analysis of borrower and lender characteristics

Public Credit Guarantees and Financial Additionalities Across SME Risk Classes

Assessing Causal Effects in a Longitudinal Observational Study With “Truncated” Outcomes Due to Unemployment and Nonignorable Missing Data

Economy-wide consequences of credit subsidies to targeted firms

Monetary Policy, Labor Income Redistribution and the Credit Channel: Evidence from Matched Employer-Employee and Credit Registers

Government Guarantees and Bank Liquidity Creation Around the World

Did the paycheck protection program hit the target?

The Impact on Job-Quality of Firm-Level Support to Innovation: Evidence from Natural Experiment Conditions and Linked Employer-Employee Data in Portugal

Financial constraints in search equilibrium: Mortensen Pissarides meet Holmstrom and Tirole

Identifying Treatment Effects of Active Labour Market Programmes for Norwegian Adults

Evaluating the indirect effects of cluster-based innovation policies: the case of the Technological Research Institutes in France