Labor Market Policies in High- and Low-Interest Rate Environments: Evidence from the Euro Area

Povilas Lastauskas,Julius Stakėnas

2024-10-16

Abstract:Do labor market policies initiated in periods of loose monetary policy yield different outcomes from those introduced when monetary tightening prevails? Using data from 11 euro-area members up to 2010 -- and extending to 17 countries up to 2020 -- we analyze three labor market policies: replacement rates, spending on active labor market policies (ALMPs), and employment protection. We find that these policies deliver different macroeconomic outcomes in low- and high-interest rate environments. In particular, ALMPs reduce unemployment if implemented under a loose monetary policy but not otherwise, whereas higher employment protection delivers expansionary effects under a tight monetary policy. These findings highlight that the effectiveness of labor market policies is significantly influenced by the monetary policy environment, emphasizing the need for coordinated policy design. Methodologically, we contribute by proposing to average local projections using Mallow's $C_{p}$ criterion, allowing for inferences that are robust to mis-specification and accommodate non-linearities.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: Are there differences in the macroeconomic effects of labor market policies under accommodative and tight monetary policy environments? Specifically, the author explores the macroeconomic impact of three labor market policies (unemployment benefit replacement rate, active labor market policy spending, and employment protection) in different interest rate environments by analyzing data from 11 Eurozone member countries (later expanded to 17 countries).

### Main Issues:
1. **Does the effectiveness of labor market policies depend on the monetary policy environment?**
- The author examines whether there are significant differences in the impact of labor market policies on unemployment and other macroeconomic variables in low and high interest rate environments.

2. **How do specific labor market policies perform under different monetary policy environments?**
- For example, can active labor market policies (ALMPs) effectively reduce unemployment under accommodative monetary policy, while being ineffective under tight monetary policy?
- Do employment protection measures have an expansionary effect under tight monetary policy?

### Research Background:
- **Existing Literature**: Most studies on labor market policies focus on the micro level, with relatively few macro-level evaluations. Even when macro evaluations exist, they are often limited to low-frequency data (such as annual panel data).
- **Research Motivation**: The author aims to explore the short-term effects of changes in labor market policies and their interaction with monetary policy through dynamic path analysis using quarterly data frequency.

### Methodological Contribution:
- **Method Innovation**: A method based on Mallows' Cp criterion for averaging local projections is proposed to ensure robustness of inference results to model misspecification and non-linear relationships.
- **Empirical Challenges**: The study addresses uncertainties, non-linearities, and expectation effects in the interaction between labor market policies and monetary policy.

### Main Findings:
- **Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs)**: Effectively reduce unemployment under accommodative monetary policy, but are less effective under tight monetary policy.
- **Employment Protection Measures**: Have an expansionary effect under tight monetary policy, but not under accommodative monetary policy.
- **Unemployment Benefit Replacement Rate**: Its effects also vary significantly under different monetary policy environments.

### Conclusion:
- The effectiveness of labor market policies is significantly influenced by the monetary policy environment, highlighting the need for coordinated policy design.
- The proposed methodology can be applied to other contexts requiring the evaluation of dynamic policy effects.

This paper reveals the varying effects of labor market policies under different monetary policy environments through detailed analysis of data from Eurozone countries, providing important insights for policymakers.