The History of Odor Measurement in Japan and Triangle Odor Bag Method

Y. Iwasaki

Abstract:An outline of the history of odor measurement methods in Japan is mentioned in this paper. The syringe method was widely used about 30 years ago. This method, however, had the several disadvantages. In order to eliminate these disadvantages,the syringe was replaced by a plastic bag (polyester film) with a 3 liter volume and any preconception of the panel was removed by adopting a triangle test. This new method (Triangle Odor Bag Method) was published for the first 1972 by the author. The outline, procedure and precision of this method were printed in this paper. 1. History of odor measurement in Japan For odor measurement, there have been instrumental methods which use instruments such as gas chromatograph to determine the odorous gas concentration in ppm and olfactory sensory methods which use the human sense of smell. The results of the olfactory sensory methods are represented by odor intensity, allowable limit (or acceptability), and odor concentration. Particularly, the last one has widely been used in Japan and foreign countries such as the European countries and the United State of America with high reliability. Odor concentration is indicated by the dilution ratio,that is,pure air volume required to dilute odorous air to an odor threshold point (odor free point). In Japan, the A.S.T.M. syringe method that was published in 1960 by N.A.Huey, had been widely used as a means of measuring odor concentrations until about 30 years ago.This method, however, had the following several disadvantages . (1) Small volume of syringe (100ml). (2) Adsorption of odor on syringe surface. (3) Long preparation time of highly diluted sample. (4) Occurrence of unnatural feeling when sniffing odor from the syringe into nose. (5) Influence of preconception of panel members. Our data obtained by the A.S.T.M. syringe method at that time was very scattered. In order to eliminate these disadvantages,the syringe was replaced by a plastic bag (polyester film) with a 3 liter volume and any preconception of the panel was removed by adopting a triangle test. This new method (Triangle Odor Bag Method) was published for the first time at the The History of Odor Measurement in Japan and Triangle Odor Bag Method -38annual meeting of the Japan Society for Atmospheric Environment in 1972 by the author. The details (sampling, procedure, calculation, etc.) of this method will be explained later. Next, I will explain the odor measurement methods, except for the Triangle Odor Bag Method. From the late 1970s, we imported the Scentometer from The BarnebeyCheney Company located in the United States of America and investigated the credibility of this method such as dilution accuracy, repeatability and so on. As a result, the Scentometer was scarcely fit for use. In the early 1970s, some institutions in Japan made a respective Olfactometer similar to that used in European countries. Some instruments adopted the 2-step dilution method and some equipment adopted a triangle test. In 1973, a certain Japanese company placed the Olfactometer on the market. However, adsorption loss of odors on the inner surface of the gas line of the olfactometer in those days could not be disregarded. For this reason, the production of the olfactometer was stopped after the several years. We investigated the accuracy and availability of the various odor measurement method mentioned above from 1970 to 1990. After 1974, in Japan, many local governments such as Tokyo, Saitama, Niigata, Yamaguchi and so on adopted the Triangle Odor Bag Method for the measurement method for local odor regulations or ordinances. The national government adopted this method for the Odor Control Law in 1997. Now, the production of the bags has reached one million bags per year in Japan. The sample number measured by the Triangle Odor Bag Method may be over 10,000 samples. 2. Triangle odor bad method 2.

Environmental Science,History