Uncovering heterogeneity in mental health changes among first-year medical students

Sabine Polujanski,Ulrike Nett,Thomas Rotthoff,Melissa Oezsoy,Ann-Kathrin Schindler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10872981.2024.2317493
IF: 6
2024-02-24
Medical Education Online
Abstract:Introduction The initial year of medical school is linked to a decline in mental health. To assess mental health comprehensively, the dual-factor model posits the consideration of both psychopathology (e.g., depression) and positive mental health (e.g., well-being). Previous mental health research among medical students has primarily examined these two factors independently. This study uses the dual-factor approach for a deeper understanding of mental health changes during the first year of medical school.
education & educational research
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the mental health status of medical students changes during their first year of study, and to explore whether these changes are heterogeneous. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Identifying different mental health groups**: Based on the bifactor model of psychopathology (such as depression) and positive mental health (such as well - being), identify different mental health groups of medical students at the time of enrollment. 2. **Evaluating the change trajectories of mental health**: Analyze the change trajectories of these different mental health groups within the first year of medical students, especially examine whether the mental health status of these groups is stable and whether there is a tendency to shift from one group to another. ### Research Background Studies have shown that the first year in medical school is associated with a decline in mental health, including an increase in depressive symptoms and a decline in the level of positive mental health. However, previous studies usually examined psychopathology and positive mental health separately, ignoring the inter - relationship between them. The bifactor model believes that psychopathology and positive mental health are two independent but related dimensions, and a person can experience high levels of distress and high well - being simultaneously. ### Research Methods The researchers conducted three surveys on 450 first - year medical students in eight medical schools in Germany at the following time points: - T0: At the time of enrollment - T1: At the end of the first semester - T2: At the end of the second semester The measurement tools used include: - Depression (PHQ - 9) - Well - being (a sub - scale of FAHW - 12) - Overall life satisfaction (single - item scale L1) Different mental health groups were identified through Latent Profile Analysis (LPA), and the change trajectories of these groups within the first year were analyzed. ### Main Findings 1. **Five mental health groups were identified**: - Complete Mental Health: Low depression, high life satisfaction, and high well - being. - Moderately Mentally Healthy: Low depression, medium - to - high life satisfaction, and medium - to - high well - being. - Symptomatic but Content: High depression, medium life satisfaction, and low well - being. - Vulnerable: Medium - to - low depression, medium - to - low life satisfaction, and medium - to - low well - being. - Troubled: High depression, low life satisfaction, and low well - being. 2. **Change trajectories of mental health**: - Approximately 38% of students remained in the same mental health group throughout all three time points, most of whom were students in the Complete Mental Health and Moderately Mentally Healthy groups. - From T0 to T1, most students in the Complete Mental Health and Moderately Mentally Healthy groups remained unchanged, while students in other groups showed higher instability. - From T1 to T2, 75% of students in the Complete Mental Health group remained unchanged, while students in other groups showed more changes, including changes in a better direction (such as from Symptomatic but Content to Moderately Mentally Healthy) or a worse direction (such as from Complete Mental Health to Vulnerable). ### Conclusion This study reveals the diversity of mental health changes within the first year of medical students and emphasizes the importance of the initial mental health state. The research results indicate that personalized prevention strategies need to be developed for different mental health groups to better support the mental health of medical students.