Abstract:Thirty-one percent of the primary energy consumed in the United States comes from the burning of natural gas, 70−90% of which is composed of methane (CH4). 1 Natural gas is recovered from onshore and offshore natural gas and oil wells and from coal beds. Currently, the United States has enough supply of dry natural gas to sustain current consumption for 92 years. Meanwhile, California consumes 2.14 MMcf (43.2 million tons) of natural gas per year, over a quarter of which is used to generate electric power and which provides approximately 40% of the electrical energy in the state. Because an extensive nationwide storage and distribution network already exists for natural gas, the development of renewable CH4 could enable rapid and widespread distribution of zero-carbon energy services. Thus, for California to meet its renewable portfolio standard, that is, 60% renewable energy for electricity generation by 2030, and to conserve a limited resource, it is imperative to assess how to develop and deploy technologies for renewable generation of CH4 in the next decade. While an increasing number of power-to-gas (PtG) projects for CH4 generation or H2 generation are being planned globally, the largest source of renewable CH4 currently being produced in the United States comes from anaerobic digesters that convert cow manure into natural gas. There are currently over 250 such systems in operation with more under construction. In addition to generating CH4 renewably, these anaerobic digesters also prevent the release of CH4 one of the most potent greenhouse gasesinto the atmosphere. However, colocation of dairy farms and anaerobic digesters alone will not yield enough renewable methane to replace the current energy demand met by natural gas. For example, the residential natural gas demand in California is ∼25,000 ton/day, while an average dairy farm can produce only ∼5 ton/day of natural gas from anaerobic digesters. If all potential biogas in California was realized it could power 180,000 homes or 435,000 vehicles, which represents approximately 1.2% of all homes or 3% of all registered vehicles in the state. While these anaerobic digesters colocated with dairy farms may seem to have small production capacity, they are among the largest sources of renewable CH4 generation in the world. Therefore, it is important to evaluate other more readily scalable technology pathways for renewable generation of CH4. Here we outline multiple technology routes for renewable generation of CH4 from sunlight, water (H2O), and carbon dioxide (CO2) (Figures 1 and 2). We evaluate the technology readiness level (TRL), the demonstrated scale of these candidate technologies, the cost for CH4 generation, as well as the cost required to provide the necessary feedstocksH2O, CO2, and H2. We investigate and compare four main CO2 methanation pathways: thermochemical (via the Sabatier reaction), biochemical, photoelectrochemical, and electrochemical (Figure S1). By applying a standard discounted cash flow method to each technology, we assess the current status and future opportunities and compare different technology pathways side-by-side. The detailed assumptions for the technoeconomic analysis (TEA) of technologies evaluated in this study are included in the Supporting Information, and the database files used for arriving at detailed cost values are also included in the Supporting Information. The baseline CH4 production was assumed to be at a scale of 30 kton CH4/year (1,500 Mcf per year), or 81 ton CH4/day (4 Mcf/day). We calculate the CO2 capture, H2 production, and water generation rates needed to match this production rate, that is, H2 production rate of 40 ton/day, CO2 capture rate of 245 ton/day, and water generation rate of 365 ton/day. No carbon credits were accounted for in this study. The electricity price for all current systems was assumed to be $49/MWh based on the 2018 data from solar utility PV in California. The TRL is evaluated from 1 to 9, where TRL 1−2 corresponds to the observation of basic principles in the academic development, TRL 3−4 to proof-of-concept development at lab scale, TRL 5−6 to process development and system integration from lab to prepilot scale, TRL 7−8 to optimization and precommercialization scale, and TRL 8−9 to commercial operation at scale. The technological pathways considered in this study also included the traditional PtG routes, in which H2 is produced via electrolysis followed by CH4 synthesis. 12 In addition, while

System perspective on cleaner technologies for renewable methane production and utilisation towards carbon neutrality: Principles, techno-economics, and carbon footprints

Electrocatalytic Conversion of Methane: Recent Progress and Future Prospects

Sustainable Energy Resources for Driving Methane Conversion

Current Status of Research on Microbial Electrocatalytic CH4 Production for Biogas Upgrading and Challenges

A comprehensive review on biomethane production from biogas separation and its techno-economic assessments

Flexible and efficient renewable-power-to-methane concept enabled by liquid CO 2 energy storage: Optimization with power allocation and storage sizing

A comprehensive review on methane's dual role: effects in climate change and potential as a carbon-neutral energy source

Economic analysis of hydrogen production and refueling station via molten-medium-catalyzed pyrolysis of natural gas process

Continuous and flexible Renewable-Power-to-Methane via liquid CO2 energy storage: Revisiting the techno-economic potential

Comparative Technoeconomic Analysis of Renewable Generation of Methane Using Sunlight, Water, and Carbon Dioxide

Synthetic methane for closing the carbon loop: Comparative study of three carbon sources for remote carbon-neutral fuel synthetization

Technologies and perspectives for achieving carbon neutrality

Methane Pyrolysis for Zero-Emission Hydrogen Production: A Potential Bridge Technology from Fossil Fuels to a Renewable and Sustainable Hydrogen Economy

Methane up-carbonizing: A way towards clean hydrogen energy?

Review on dry reforming of methane, a potentially more environmentally-friendly approach to the increasing natural gas exploitation

Reducing Carbon Footprint in Cities: Natural Gas-Based Energy Generation with Zero CO2 Emission

Renewable Methanol from Industrial Carbon Emissions: A Dead End or Sustainable Way Forward?

A quantitative roadmap for China towards carbon neutrality in 2060 using methanol and ammonia as energy carriers

Reducing carbon footprint in cities: Natural gas-based energy generation with zero CO 2 emission

Boosting carbon utilization efficiency for sustainable methanol production from biomass: Techno-economic and environmental analysis