Arthroplasty with endoprosthesis after resection of tumors at the elbow
GUO Wei,TANG Xiao-dong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2013.01.010
2013-01-01
Abstract:Background The tumors at the elbow bone account for 1% of the bone tumors of the whole body. Lymphoma is the most common malignant tumor and osteoid osteomais is the most common benign tumor. In the past,the treatment of elbow malignant tumors is amputation,which results in loss of limb after surgery. With the development of surgery and the technology of radiation and chemotherapy,it is possible to partially excise the tumors and retain upper limbs. However,due to the important anatomical structures of elbow,partial excision of tumor leads to instability and poor function of the joint of elbow,wrist and hand. Before the total endoprosthesis of elbow appeared,there were only several reconstruction methods to rebuild stable functional elbow after tumor resection. Arthrodesis or excisional arthroplasty of the elbow has their respective disadvantage: arthrodesis results in limited elbow motion,and excisional arthroplasty results in joint instability. At present,there are rare literatures guiding the elbow reconstruction after the tumor resection. Therefore,This study presented our results of limb salvage surgery using custom-made prostheses for reconstruction of the elbow after tumor excision. The oncologic results,complications,and functional outcomes were further discussed. Methods( 1) General information: The elbow tumor surgery cases from June 1998 to June 2010 were retrospectively collected in Peking University People' s Hospital. The inclusion criteria were as follows: malignant tumor involving the proximal ulna and distal humerus or benign invasive tumor,tumor excision with prostheses for reconstruction of the elbow. The benign tumors, revision and complete humerus surgery patients should be ruled out. There are 24 patients in this study,14 men and 10 women,with a mean age of 42. 6 year-old. Pathological diagnosis of these cases were: 6 cases of osteosarcoma,4 cases of Ewing' s sarcoma,3 cases of malignant fibrous histiocytoma,2 cases of giant cell tumor,each 1 case of lymphoma,synovial sarcoma and bone of desmoid tumor,6 cases of metastatic carcinoma( 3 cases of lung cancer,and each 1 case of melanoma,ovarian cancer and rectal cancer). 12 tumors were in distal humerus,7 in proximal ulna,5 in humerus and 5 in ulna. Patients with osteosarcoma, Ewing' s sarcoma and malignant lymphoma received standard chemotherapy preoperatively and postoperatively. Malignant fibrous histiocytoma and lymphoma patients received radiotherapy postoperatively.( 2) Prosthesis design Patients underwent reconstruction of elbow joint with custom-made hinged type artificial elbow endoprosthetic( ChunLiZhengDa medical equipment company,Beijing,China). In order to increase the fixation effect of the bone cement,all prostheses were cement type and ulna prosthesis handles were screw type. In order to strengthen the stability,the surface of the prosthesis that contact with proximal humerus and distal ulna were coated by titanium paste or made of granular surface coating. Due to the smaller diameter of ulnar canal and curved shape,the ulnar prosthetic handle diameter was 6 to 7 mm,and length was about 6 to 8 cm.( 3) Surgical technique: The elbow posterior approach was commonly used. All of the patients underwent en-bloc resection,5 patients underwent the joint resection for their tumors were involved in the articular cavity,the remaining cases received intra-articular resection. Those patients with distal humerus tumors needed to reflect the triceps muscle. If possible,we tried to keep the ulna olecranon and triceps tendon attachment points. After removal of the tumor,we repaired to the greatest extent the forearm flexion and extension as well as pronation after spin muscle group attachment points. For cases of proximal ulna,we kept humerus medial condyle and lateral condyle as much as possible,embedding the humerus part of prosthesis into the fossa intercondyloidea. When installing the joints,humerus and ulna part of prosthesis were fixed in the medullary cavity with bone cement,respectively,and then the hinge was connected. The average operation time of the patients was about 120 min,the mean volume of blood loss was 400 ml,and the average time for the use of tourniquet was 80 min.( 4) Postoperative recovery and follow-up: Active hand movement was encouraged after operation. Elbow joint cannot be moved until the wound healed. Pathological analysis of the resection specimen was conducted to determine the surgical boundary. 15 cases received wide resection,and 9 cases received borderline resection. Regular follow-up was performed for all patients to record the situation of survival,metastasis,recurrence,function and implant complications. The scoring systems of Mayo elbow joint function( MEPS) and MSTS joint function were used to assess the patient' s postoperative function. Results One patient was lost to follow up,the rest 23 patients were followed up for at least one year or until to death( mean,37 months). During the follow-up,11 patients were tumor-free survivals. 4 with metastatic carcinoma,one with osteosarcoma and one with Ewing's sarcoma died within two years after the operation,respectively. Two cases of Ewing's sarcoma,one of malignant fibrous histiocytoma,one of osteosarcoma with lung metastasis,and two of metastatic tumor,survived with tumor. Among the 6 patients with osteosarcoma,one lost to follow up,one died and one survived with lung metastasis,the other three were tumor-free survivals. In the 4 cases of Ewing's sarcoma,one patient died of tumor metastasis,two survived with lung metastasis,and one was tumor-free survival. Tumors recurred locally in 3 cases( 13%). The incidence of complication was 26. 1%( 6 /23),including one patient with pull injury of radial nerve that recovered during the 6 months after operation. The wound was difficult to heal in 2 cases,and cured after debridement. Among 3 patients suffering implant complications,2 patients' prosthesis handle pricked the bone cortex and one patient' s prosthesis was aseptic loose. These three obtained good function after the operation of prosthesis revision. Postoperative MSTS score were as follows: the score of 5 cases with the whole tumor resection outside the joint and artificial elbow joint replacement was 25 points on average,the mean score of 18 cases with tumor resection inside the joint and artificial elbow joint replacement was 25. 9 points. The operation effects of 18 cases were satisfactory( 18 /23,78. 3%) and 5 cases were acceptable( 5 /23,21. 7%). The average MEPS score of all the patients was 80 points. The mean flexion range of elbow was improved from 29 ° to 73 °( range,55 °-105 °). Discussion Excisional arthroplasty or arthrodesis of the elbow always leads to poor function and is difficult for patients with bone loss. The options for reconstruction after excision of the tumor around the elbow are technically difficult and limited. This study presented our results of limb salvage surgery using custom-made prostheses for reconstruction of the elbow after tumor excision,and discussed the oncologic results,complications,and functional outcome.( 1) The requirements of prosthesis and the patient in total elbow arthroplasty. The means of limb salvage and application of elbow prosthesis after the tumor resection have rarely been reported before. For total elbow arthroplasty for reconstruction of the elbow,prosthesis and the patient must meet certain requirements. Prosthesis should allow the steady activity of the forearm and hand,its length can make up the bone defects,and its mechanical strength can withstand everyday use. In addition,the prosthesis must be technically easy to install,and ensure stable fixation. In terms of the choice of cases,total elbow arthroplasty can be only applied to the patients with the functional neurovascular bundle,forearm and hand. The total elbow arthroplasty can not be used for the patients,who can be curative after tumor resection,but need to sacrifice margin to secure the implant. The treatment of patients with extensive tumor metastasis and poor prognosis,such as tumor resection,implant replacement surgery,chemotherapy or radiotherapy,need to be performed based on their own conditions. Furthermore,in such case,amputation should be avoided to retain the function of their hand and forearm.( 2) Elbow reconstruction after tumor resection. Not many reconstruction methods are reported to rebuild a stable elbow after tumor resection. Arthrodesis or resection arthroplasty is often used for smaller bone defects. Arthrodesis results in limited postoperative elbow movement, and resection arthroplasty leads to postoperative joint instability. The allogeneic elbow transplantation has been applied for the larger defects. Semi-allogeneic transplant articular can make soft tissue attachment to retain muscle function and maintain joint stability,but the rate of postoperative complications can be as high as 70%. Infection,joint instability and dislocation often occur after surgery. Despite the solid internal fixation exists,postoperative bone nonunion occurred frequently( about 15%). The other patients may had allogeneic bone resorption. The results of this study showed that the implementation of the whole elbow after tumor resection arthroplasty could significantly reduce the pain and improve the function. Patients with metastases may be treated by this surgical method,especially for whose symptoms can not be relieved by other methods. There is no better method than the artificial elbow replacement for the functional reconstruction after resection of the tumor around the elbow joint. And the incidence of complications after elbow arthroplasty is acceptable.( 3) Ensure the success of total elbow arthroplasty: Following points should be noted: ① The principles of malignancy wide excision should be followed,otherwise local tumor recurrence might easily appear. ②Soft tissue coverage should be sufficient to avoid incision problems,which could lead to failure of the prosthesis replacement surgery. ③Patients with the tumor of distal humerus should be treated,after removal of the tumor,by the repair of the forearm flexion and extension as well as pronation after spin muscle group start and end points. If possible,partial medial and lateral condyle of humerus should be maintained as far as possible. ④Due to the smaller ulnar canal and less bone cement poured,the intramedullary prosthesis should be designed as the coarse thread type,which helps to cement to prevent the prosthesis rotation and loosening. ⑤For the smaller diameter of ulnar canal and curved shape,the ulnar prosthetic handle must not be too long,with 5-7 cm advisable,otherwise it will be easy to wear a bone cortex; ⑥The medial and lateral condyle of humerus should be kept for patients with the tumor of proximal ulna. And the humerus part of prosthesis between fossa intercondyloidea should be embedded.( 4) Function evaluation: All the three groups of patients started functional exercise after the postoperative 3 weeks. After 8 weeks,70% of patients had a " near normal"-like appearance with the elbow flexion range between 50 degrees to 90 degrees,5% of patients with an arc of motion of less than 50 degrees,25% of patients with an elbow flexion range of greater than 90 degrees. 90% of the patients could make movements of their elbows without pain; 80% of patients retained the function of the forearm rotation. Conclusions In conclusion,local tumor resection together with prosthetic reconstruction of the elbow can provide good surgical outcomes and less complication with oncologic safety for the appropriate patients.