Abstract:Extensive uncertainty can affect the efficiency and fairness of consensus in the consensus reaching process (CRP), but few scholars have studied consensus modeling that focuses on fairness and efficiency in uncertain environments. Additionally, the weight of the decision maker (DM) in the CRP is influenced by multiple factors. Therefore, this paper proposes robust consensus models (EFCMs) focusing on fairness and efficiency under uncertain costs to address these issues. Firstly, this paper constructs multiple uncertainty sets to describe the uncertainty of the unit adjustment cost. Secondly, the fair utility level and opinion adjustment distance are used to measure the fairness and efficiency of reaching consensus, respectively. Furthermore, this paper uses a data-driven method based on the KDE method combined with trust propagation in social networks to determine the DMs' weights jointly. Finally, this paper also applies the proposed models to the carbon emission reduction negotiation process between the government and enterprises. The experimental results and sensitivity analysis show that the consensus cost budget and the DMs' jealous preference behavior particularly affects the efficiency of reaching consensus, which provides a theoretical basis for solving practical decision making problems.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily aims to address the issues of efficiency and fairness in the Consensus Reaching Process (CRP) during group decision-making, especially in the presence of uncertain costs. Specifically, the main contributions and objectives of the study can be summarized as follows: 1. **Proposing a Robust Consensus Model**: To address the lack of research on consensus fairness and efficiency under uncertain environments, the paper proposes a robust consensus model (EFCM) that considers both fairness and efficiency to cope with the uncertainty of unit adjustment costs. 2. **Uncertainty Modeling**: To accurately describe the uncertainty of unit adjustment costs, various uncertainty sets are constructed and used to characterize the cost uncertainty. 3. **Fairness and Efficiency Measurement**: Fairness in compensation distribution is measured by the level of fair utility; efficiency in the consensus reaching process is measured by the distance of opinion adjustment. 4. **Weight Determination Method**: A combination of data-driven methods and trust propagation algorithms in social networks is used to jointly determine the weights of decision-makers. This includes a data-driven method to determine the intrinsic influence of decision-makers from historical data and a trust propagation method to reflect the extrinsic influence of trust relationships in social networks. 5. **Application Case Analysis**: The proposed model is applied to the carbon emission reduction negotiations between the government and enterprises, analyzing the impact of uncertain parameter levels and decision-makers' fairness concern behaviors on consensus fairness and efficiency. In summary, this study aims to solve the issues of consensus fairness and efficiency in group decision-making by proposing a new robust consensus model, particularly in the context of uncertain costs. The model not only considers the fairness requirements in the decision-making process but also improves the efficiency of consensus reaching and better adapts to the complexity and uncertainty in real decision-making scenarios.

Robust Consensus Modeling: Concerning Consensus Fairness and Efficiency with Uncertain Costs

Robust minimum cost consensus modeling with consensus principle and tolerance level for group decision making

The Robust Cost Consensus Model with Interval-Valued Opinion and Uncertain Cost in Group Decision-Making

Consensus Reaching in Group Decision Making With Linear Uncertain Preferences and Asymmetric Costs

A robust minimum cost consensus model based on social networks considering conflict constraints

A two-stage distributionally robust maximum expert consensus model with asymmetric costs and risk aversion

A Minimum-Cost Consensus Model in Social Networks Derived From Uncertain Preferences

A two-stage consensus model for large-scale group decision-making considering dynamic social networks

Reliability-based ordinal consensus adjustment model for large scale group decision making

A Feedback Mechanism With Unknown Bounded Confidence-Based Optimization Model for Consensus Reaching in Social Network Group Decision Making

The bi-level consensus model with dual social networks for group decision making

A Cost Consensus Metric for Consensus Reaching Processes based on a comprehensive minimum cost model

A Consensus Model for Intuitionistic Fuzzy Group Decision-Making Problems Based on the Construction and Propagation of Trust/Distrust Relationships in Social Networks

Managing non-cooperative behaviors in large-scale group decision making based on trust relationships and confidence levels of decision makers

Opinion Dynamics and Minimum Adjustment-Driven Consensus Model for Multi-Criteria Large-Scale Group Decision Making Under a Novel Social Trust Propagation Mechanism

Consensus reaching for prospect cross-efficiency in data envelopment analysis with minimum adjustments

Grey multi-criteria group consensus decision-making based on cobweb model

Facilitating large-scale group decision-making in social networks: A bi-level consensus model with social influence

A Consensus Model with Non-Cooperative Behavior Adaptive Management Based on Cognitive Psychological State Computation in Large-Scale Group Decision

Consensus Reaching in Multiple Attribute Group Decision Making: A Multi-Stage Optimization Feedback Mechanism with Individual Bounded Confidences

A multi-objective grey hierarchical group consensus model and its application