Assistierte und konventionelle Suizide in München – ein Gruppenvergleich

S. Gleich,J. Schienhammer,O. Peschel,M. Graw,B. Schäffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00194-024-00701-z

2024-06-15

Rechtsmedizin

Abstract:Der assistierte Suizid (AS) ist in Deutschland seit dem Jahr 2020 bei freiverantwortlichen Personen zulässig. Mit dieser Studie wird untersucht, ob sich AS-Fälle von konventionellen Suiziden (KS) unterscheiden.

medicine, legal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Assistierte Suizide in München: angewendete Arzneistoffe und dokumentierte Komplikationen

S. Gleich,J. Schienhammer,O. Peschel,M. Graw,B. Schäffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00194-024-00725-5

2024-11-10

Rechtsmedizin

Abstract:Mit dieser Studie wurde untersucht, welche Arzneistoffe für assistierte Suizide (AS) eingesetzt, und wie häufig Komplikationen dokumentiert wurden.

medicine, legal
Umgang mit assistiertem Suizid – Kenntnisse, Einstellungen und Erfahrungen von Mitgliedern der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin

Jacqueline Schwartz,Yann-Nicolas Batzler,Manuela Schallenburger,Alexandra Scherg,Jonas Jansen,Stefan Meier,Remo Küppers,Heiner Melching,Ulrich Grabenhorst,Wiebke Nehls,Claudia Bausewein,Martin Neukirchen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00103-024-03960-z

2024-10-09

Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz

Abstract:Im Februar 2020 erklärte das Bundesverfassungsgericht § 217 StGB für nichtig. Seitdem ist die geschäftsmäßige Förderung der Selbsttötung straffrei. Ziel dieser Studie ist die Beschreibung von Kenntnissen, Einstellungen und Erfahrungen von Mitgliedern der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin (DGP) im Umgang mit Todes- und Suizidwünschen.

public, environmental & occupational health
Der assistierte Suizid in der Schweiz, ein Modell in der internationalen Diskussion zum Thema "Assisted dying"

Uwe Güth,Ralf J. Jox,Karim Abawi,Rolf Weitkunat,Andres R. Schneeberger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/a-2370-0016

2024-09-25

DMW - Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift

Abstract:Im Beobachtungszeitraum zwischen 1999 und 2022 hat das Schweizerische Bundesamt für Statistik 14 170 assistierte Suizide dokumentiert. In diesem 24-Jahres-Zeitraum haben die jährlichen Fallzahlen markant zugenommen: Während im Jahr 1999 lediglich 63 Fälle verzeichnet wurden, betrug die Anzahl der Fälle im Jahr 2022 nahezu 1600; dies entspricht 2,1 % aller Todesfälle in der Schweiz. Die häufigste, den assistierten Suiziden zugrunde liegende Erkrankungsgruppe bildeten mit 40 % der Fälle Krebserkrankungen. Die mehrheitlich von Frauen gewählte Sterbehilfe (über die Zeit unverändert 58 % der Fälle) ist vor allem ein Altersphänomen: Im Jahr 2022 betrug das mediane Alter derjenigen, die sich für den assistierten Suizid entschieden haben, 81 Jahre; bei der Gruppe derjenigen, die den assistierten Suizid wegen einer Krebserkrankung gewählt haben, betrug das mediane Alter zuletzt 77 Jahre, bei den nicht krebsbedingten Sterbehilfefällen lag es bei 84 Jahren. In the observation period between 1999 and 2022, the Swiss Federal Statistical Office recorded 14 170 assisted suicide (AS) cases. During this 24-year period, the annual number of cases increased significantly: While only 63 cases were observed in 1999, the number of cases in 2022 amounted to almost 1600, corresponding to 2.1 % of all deaths in Switzerland. The most common underlying disease group for AS was cancer, accounting for 40 % of cases. AS is mainly chosen by women (unchanged over time at 58 % of cases) and is primarily a geriatric phenomenon: In 2022, the median age of those who opted for assisted dying was 81 years; the median age of those who chose AS due to cancer was 77 years, while the median age of those who died with non-cancer-related AS was 84 years. Article published online: 23 September 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

medicine, general & internal
Sichtweisen einer Stichprobe überwiegend jüngerer Ärztinnen und Ärzte zum ärztlich-assistierten Suizid

Remo Küppers,Stefan Meier,Yann-Nicolas Batzler,Manuela Schallenburger,Dietmar Wetzchewald,Sven Dreyer,Jaqueline Schwartz,Martin Neukirchen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00103-024-03833-5

2024-01-24

Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz

Abstract:Am 26.02.2020 hat das Bundesverfassungsgericht den § 217 StGB, der die geschäftsmäßige Förderung der Selbsttötung unter Strafe stellte, für nichtig erklärt. Seitdem wird eine mögliche gesetzliche Neuregelung diskutiert. Ziel dieser Studie war es, Wissen, Erfahrungen und Einstellungen jüngerer Ärztinnen und Ärzte zur Suizidassistenz zu untersuchen.

public, environmental & occupational health
[Dealing with assisted suicide-knowledge, attitudes and experiences of members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine]

Jacqueline Schwartz,Yann-Nicolas Batzler,Manuela Schallenburger,Alexandra Scherg,Jonas Jansen,Stefan Meier,Remo Küppers,Heiner Melching,Ulrich Grabenhorst,Wiebke Nehls,Claudia Bausewein,Martin Neukirchen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00103-024-03960-z

2024-10-07

Abstract:Background: In February 2020, the Federal Constitutional Court declared § 217 of the German Criminal Code void. Ever since, assisted suicide services have been legal in Germany. This study aims to describe the knowledge, attitudes and experiences of members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine (DGP) regarding assisted suicide. Methods: Online survey with members of the DGP from July to September 2023 using Qualtrics®. The study group developed the questionnaire based on current literature; it was adapted following an initial application among young physicians and an interprofessional panel of experts with consensus voting. Data was analysed using descriptive and explorative statistics. Results: 991 DGP-members (18%) participated, of which physicians made up 57.0% (n = 545/957) and nurses 23.4% (n = 224/957). Of the participants, 197/851 (23.1%) incorrectly stated that assisted suicide is prohibited by professional code, 430/914 (47.1%) rejected a restriction of palliative care teams to suicide prevention measures, and 766/930 (82.4%) rejected personal involvement in assisted suicide regardless of a patient's health status. For patients in palliative situations, 473/926 (51.1%) could imagine participating in assisted suicide, and 71% wanted new legislation regulating assisted suicide. Conclusion: There are gaps in the knowledge of the participating members of the DGP regarding the legal and professional status of assisted suicide. Further educational work is needed in this regard. The participants can more easily imagine assisted suicide for people in palliative disease trajectories. As in surveys of members of other medical societies, the attitudes of more experienced staff are reflected. Compared to younger healthcare professionals, they have a more restrictive attitude towards the concept of assisted suicide.
Inanspruchnahme psychosozialer Hilfen bei jungen Erwachsenen mit suizidalem Erleben und Verhalten

Maren Weiss,Anja Hildebrand,Mark Stemmler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/a-2398-6074

2024-09-22

PPmP - Psychotherapie · Psychosomatik · Medizinische Psychologie

Abstract:Die Studie untersucht die Inanspruchnahme von psychosozialen Diensten bei jungen Menschen, die unter suizidalem Erleben und Verhalten leiden. Dadurch werden Versorgungslücken deutlich gemacht und besondere Zielgruppen herausgearbeitet. Die Daten stammen aus der Baselinebefragung des Forschungsprojekts "Outcome Evaluation [U25]". Die Stichprobe umfasst n=888 Personen im jungen Erwachsenenalter, die unter suizidalem Erleben und Verhalten leiden. Unter den Teilnehmenden griffen 55% auf mindestens ein psychosoziales Hilfsangebot zu. Heilkundliche Angebote wurden am häufigsten genutzt (54%), gefolgt von weiteren professionellen Beratungsangeboten (34%) und nichtprofessionellen Selbsthilfeangeboten (22%). Männer nahmen seltener Hilfe in Anspruch als Frauen und Personen diversen Geschlechts. Teilnehmende in Beziehungen suchten seltener Hilfe als Singles. Der Migrationshintergrund zeigte keinen konsistenten Zusammenhang mit der Inanspruchnahme von psychosozialen Diensten. Psychische Belastungen und "suicide literacy" hingen mit einer erhöhten Inanspruchnahme zusammen. Geschlecht und Beziehungsstatus waren auch dann signifikante Prädiktoren für die Inanspruchnahme von psychosozialen Angeboten, wenn psychische Belastungen, suizidales Erleben und Verhalten sowie "suicide literacy" berücksichtigt wurden. The study explores the utilization of psychosocial support by young adults facing suicidal ideation or impulses, considering a comprehensive spectrum of psychosocial services. The study sheds light on help utilization and gaps in service use among different groups. The data is derived from the baseline assessment of the research project "Outcome Evaluation [U25]". The sample includes 888 young adults who reported suicidal thoughts and behaviors. Among the participants, 55% accessed at least one psychosocial service. Medical/psychotherapy services were the most utilized (54%), followed by professional counseling (34%) and non-professional self-help services (22%). Gender differences were observed, with males using help less frequently than females and individuals with diverse gender identities. Participants in relationships were less likely to seek help than singles. A migrant background showed no consistent impact on service utilization. Psychological distress and suicide literacy were associated with increased service utilization. Regression analysis revealed that gender and relationship status remained predictors of service utilization even when considering mental distress, suicidal thoughts and behaviors, and suicide literacy. Received: 20 June 2024 Accepted: 20 August 2024 Article published online: 20 September 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

psychology, clinical
Der Assistierte Suizid – ein wichtiges Thema für Neurologie und Psychiatrie

Thomas Pollmächer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/a-2267-6124

2024-05-18

Fortschritte der Neurologie · Psychiatrie

Abstract:Schon seit mehreren Jahrzehnten wird in der Gesamtgesellschaft und in der Fachwelt immer wieder und meist kontrovers über die Unterstützung beim Suizid diskutiert. Lange lag dabei der Fokus auf Menschen mit schweren und schwersten Erkrankungen, meist kurz vor dem Ende ihres Lebens, die um Hilfe bei der Selbsttötung oder gar um eine aktive Tötung durch einen Arzt gebeten haben. Article published online: 16 May 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

psychiatry,clinical neurology
What do suicide loss survivors think of physician-assisted suicide: a comparative analysis of suicide loss survivors and the general population in Germany

Laura Hofmann,Louisa Spieß,Birgit Wagner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12910-024-01099-9

2024-09-19

Abstract:Background: Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) and voluntary euthanasia remain highly debated topics in society, drawing attention due to their ethical, legal, and emotional complexities. Within this debate, the loss of a loved one through suicide may shape the attitudes of survivors, resulting in more or less favorable attitudes towards this topic. Aims: This study aims to explore and compare the attitudes towards PAS and voluntary euthanasia in a population of suicide loss survivors and the general population, while also considering socio-demographic factors. Methods: A total of 529 participants, 168 of whom were survivors of suicide loss, completed an online questionnaire on their attitudes (NOBAS) and opinions (open response format) towards PAS and voluntary euthanasia, as well as regarding their legalization in Germany. The analysis consisted of both quantitative and qualitative components. Results: The entire sample showed positive attitudes towards PAS and voluntary euthanasia in terminally ill persons. Participants were more divided in their attitudes towards PAS in the case of a mental health disorder. Individuals without experienced suicide loss were more liberal regarding legalization in Germany and were more likely to understand the wish for PAS. Survivors of suicide loss were mainly concerned about the consequences for relatives. However, differences between both groups are small. Discussion: The experience of a loss by suicide influences attitudes towards PAS and voluntary euthanasia. Both groups showed an accepting attitude towards PAS and voluntary euthanasia, but also expressed concerns and fears regarding easy accessibility and consequences for grieving relatives.
[Announced assisted suicide in Switzerland: a case report]

Benjamin Vyssoki,Michaela Stich,Elisabeth Eder-Pissarek,Ingrid Jez,Stefan Dobias,Annemarie Unger,Alexander Kautzky,Georg Psota

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40211-021-00398-6

Abstract:Assisted suicide is currently still prohibited in Austria. However, following a finding of the Austrian Constitutional Court it would be completely legal from 2022. A statutory regulation defining the limits between legal ways of assistance and the conditions therefor on the one hand and, on the other hand, assistive actions that shall remain prohibited is currently not in sight. However, a suicidal action performed upon the request of the person willing to die solely by someone else will remain illegal; this also applies if the person willing to commit suicide is physically unable to participate in her or his killing. In several European countries euthanasia and/or assisted suicide has already been legalized and in some countries, Switzerland for example, assisted suicide is a legal option even for patients without suffering from a life-limiting disease, unbearable suffering and insufficient treatment options are the only criteria. In this case report the clinical case of an Austrian patient will be presented, suffering from a personality disorder, who planed an assisted suicide in Switzerland. Ethic and legal backgrounds are discussed.The possibility of assisted suicide bears the danger that people suffering from psychiatric disorders, especially current major depressive episode, could refuse treatment options and choose suicide trough a commercial provider of assisted suicide.In particular it must be considered that currently severely depressed people usually suffer from limited insight and judgement as well as from limited freedom of choice.
[Physician-assisted suicide - two perspectives]

Martin Scherer,Urban Wiesing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s15006-024-4062-5

Abstract:In February 2020, the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany issued a landmark judgement on assisted suicide. It rejected as unconstitutional a law from 2015 that prohibited "assisted suicide services". It emphasized the freedom of people to shape their own lives and deaths and to seek help in doing so. In contrast, other practical problems arise when a doctor is confronted with a request for assisted suicide at the bedside in the current situation. The different perspectives and their tensions are contrasted.
Comparison of two suicide screening instruments for identifying high-risk individuals in prison

Joscha Hausam,Daniela Calvano,Annette Opitz-Welke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1362928

IF: 4.7

2024-06-27

Frontiers in Psychiatry

Abstract:Increased suicide rates in prison are a serious concern. Early identification of inmates at risk is a component of effective suicide prevention. The present study examined two suicide screening instruments in a sample of men in the Berlin, Germany, prison system (n = 289). The Screening for Initial Risk Assessment (SIRAS) identified significantly more high-risk inmates than the Vienna Instrument for Suicidality in Correctional Institutions (VISCI) (66 vs. 24). The results further show that the agreement in the classification was evident only in inmates with suicidal ideation, but was otherwise quite low. This can be explained by the fact that the instruments differ in terms of the risk factors taken into account. Finally, it was found that inmates classified as high risk received more monitoring and psychiatric or psychological support, which supports the construct validity of the instruments. As there were no deaths by suicide in the sample, no statistical information on the predictive validity of the instruments could be provided. Although research in this area is challenging, methodologically sound studies are needed to inform practice.

psychiatry
Assisted suicide in persons with mental disorders: a review of clinical-ethical arguments and recommendations

Georg Marckmann,Thomas Pollmächer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21037/apm-23-472

2024-04-12

Annals of Palliative Medicine

Abstract:Persons with mental disorders have the same right to self-determination as patients with somatic diseases, also regarding death and dying. However, there are several challenges that render persons with mental disorders especially vulnerable to inappropriate conduct of assisted suicide: their wish to die may be a symptom of their mental disease and not an autonomous choice, decision-making competence may be compromised by their illness and more difficult to assess, the severity of suffering may be more difficult to evaluate from an external perspective, the wish to die may be more variable over time and the prognostic uncertainty in mental illness makes it more difficult to determine whether the severe suffering is, in fact, treatment-resistant. After reviewing the clinical and ethical background of assisted suicide in persons with mental disorders, we assess each of these challenges to a medically and ethically justified practice of assisted suicide in mentally ill persons, based on relevant clinical and ethical literature. We conclude that the only ethically valid argument to exclude persons with mental disorders from suicide assistance is their potential inability to make a free, autonomous decision. However, the mentioned challenges should be taken into account in evaluating a person's request for assisted suicide and for promoting her well-informed and deliberated decision-making. In addition to assessing the person's decision-making capacity, the evaluation process should be guided by the goal to empower the person to make an autonomous choice between the available options. We conclude the paper with perspectives for a clinically and ethically justified practice of evaluating requests for assisted suicide in persons with mental disorders.

health care sciences & services
SELF-ADMINISTRATION OR PRACTITIONER ADMINISTRATION? THE SCOPE OF FUTURE GERMAN ASSISTED DYING LEGISLATION

Kerstin Braun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/medlaw/fwac034

2023-02-27

Abstract:In 2020, the German Federal Constitutional Court declared unconstitutional and void a 2015 criminal law penalising suicide assistance in a recurring fashion and called into existence a right to a self-determined death, including the use of suicide services, where available. Due to subsequent legislative inaction, no holistic assisted dying legislation offering protection for vulnerable individuals is currently in place in Germany. Calls have been made for law reform in this area. This article contemplates the possible scope of a future assisted dying framework in Germany. It does so by focusing on the method of administration and analyses whether such a framework should be limited to allowing eligible persons to self-administer relevant lethal medications, which have been prescribed to them by a medical practitioner or whether, and to what extent, practitioners should be able to administer relevant lethal substances to patients. This is comparatively analysed while also keeping in mind any stipulations made by the German Constitutional Court in its 2020 judgment on the requirements of future assisted dying legislation. The article concludes that an assisted dying framework allowing a free choice between self and practitioner administration in Germany best complies with the guidance provided by the Constitutional Court.
Suizidalität – ein psychiatrischer Notfall in der Praxis

Blumenthal,Sandra

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/a-2229-8130

2024-02-14

DMW - Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift

Abstract:Unter Suizidalität versteht man alle Gedanken, Gefühle und Handlungen, die auf eine selbst herbeigeführte Beendigung des Lebens ausgerichtet sind [1]. HausärztInnen sollten diese bei ihren PatientInnen erkennen und ansprechen, denn sie können intervenieren bzw. die Weiterbehandlung koordinieren. Doch nicht jeder Patient und nicht jede Patientin offenbart sich – und nicht immer gelingt es den Suizid zu verhindern. Suicidal tendencies are all thoughts, feelings and actions that are aimed at ending one's own life. GPs should recognize and address this in their patients, as they can intervene and coordinate further treatment. However, not every patient discloses – and it is not always possible to prevent suicide. In der Sprechstunde sollten Sie Suizidalität bei Risikokonstellationen und Bauchgefühl immer ansprechen. Männer sind in der Gruppe der SuizidentInnen mit 76% deutlich überrepräsentiert. Depressive Störungen erfordern besondere Aufmerksamkeit hinsichtlich der Entwicklung von Suizidgedanken. Beziehungs- und Gesprächsangebote sowie ein stufengerechtes und individuell-angepasstes Angebot sind wichtige Schritte, um Suizide zu verhindern. Suizide sollte man in der Praxis, im Team und auch im Qualitätszirkel nachbesprechen und ggf. aufarbeiten. Article published online: 13 February 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

medicine, general & internal
Comparative study of related factors and clinical features of attempted suicide

WANG Jun,ZHANG Hong-mei,YI Mao-sen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-7201.2006.04.006

2006-01-01

Abstract:Objective To study the related factors and clinical features of attempted suicide.Methods A total of 70 persons with attempted suicide and 70 healthy adults as the normal control group were investigated with psychological scales and FES(Family Environment Scale).Results Among those attempted suicides,female was more than male.The most common way was taking overdose or poisoning themselves.The results also showed that persons with history of attempted suicide had more problems in family enviroment and relationship with others.They had some traits including anxiety,psychopathy deviation,sensitivity.Conclusion The critical factors related to attempted suicide are individual factors.
Euthanasia and assisted suicide in psychiatric patients: A systematic review of the literature

Raffaella Calati,Emilie Olié,Déborah Dassa,Carla Gramaglia,Sébastien Guillaume,Fabio Madeddu,Philippe Courtet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.12.006

Abstract:The number of psychiatric patients requesting Euthanasia or Assisted Suicide (EAS) continues to increase. The aims of this systematic review were to: 1) describe the available data related to psychiatric patients having received or requesting EAS (pEAS) for each country in which is allowed; 2) and describe the ethically salient points that arise. PubMed, PsycINFO, and Scopus databases were searched to identify articles published up to September 2020. Among the retrieved publications, only studies on pEAS cases (pEAS-C), pEAS requests, or physician reports/attitude towards pEAS reporting some quantitative data on patients having received or requesting pEAS were retained. Among the 24 included studies, thirteen (54%) were about pEAS in the Netherlands, four (17%) in Belgium, and seven (29%) in Switzerland. Results were different across different countries. In the Netherlands, pEAS-C were mostly women (70-77%) and often had at least two psychiatric disorders (56-97%). Mood disorders were mainly represented (55-70%) together with personality disorders (52-54%). History of suicide attempts was present in 34-52%. Moreover, 37-62% of them had at least one comorbid medical condition. In Belgium pEAS-C were mostly women (75%), but the majority (71%) had a single diagnosis, mood disorder. In Switzerland available data were less detailed. As pEAS-C seem to be very similar to 'traditional suicides', pEAS procedures should be carefully revised to establish specific criteria of access and guidelines of evaluation of the request. A deeper focus on unbearable suffering, decision capacity and possibilities of improvements is warranted as well as the involvement of mental health professionals.
[A comparison of homicide-suicide and domestic homicide in the region of basle, Switzerland]

Andreas Frei,Lydia Schönmeier,Marc Graf,Birgit Völlm

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0030-1266127

Abstract:Background: Homicide-suicide and domestic homicide without consecutive suicide might be regarded as an extreme form of domestic violence. According to the national crime-register, however, there might be some relevant differences between the perpetrators of the two. Method: The files of all cases of homicide-suicide (n = 24) and of all cases of domestic homicide without suicide (n = 21), which had been examined at the Institute of forensic medicine in Basle between 1987 und 2006, were compared. Results: Perpetrators of domestic homicide without suicide were significantly younger, had a poorer educational background and were rather foreigners. About two thirds of the perpetrators of homicide-suicide used a gun compared with only one third of those committing domestic homicide. Discussion: Measures as they are known from suicide prevention programmes like limiting the access to lethal instruments like guns might be useful in the case of homicide-suicide, measures for the prevention of domestic homicide should aim at better integration and education of the perpetrators and their family.
Sozialpsychiatrische Konzepte in der BRD und der DDR – Ein Vergleich der theoretischen Ansätze von Karl Peter Kisker sowie Klaus Weise und Achim Thom

Johann Buttler,Holger Steinberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/a-2295-8000

2024-04-27

Psychiatrische Praxis

Abstract:Die Studie zeigt in den Grundvorstellungen des Psychiaters Karl Peter Kisker sowie des Psychiaters Klaus Weise und Philosophen Achim Thom das gemeinsame Anliegen ab den 1960ern, psychisch Kranken zu mehr Selbstbestimmung und gesellschaftlicher Teilhabe zu verhelfen und die Psychiatrieversorgung zu humanisieren. Aus der Gesamtschau wird zunächst die theoretische Konzeption von Kisker dargestellt, der ein Vertreter der westdeutschen Sozialpsychiatriebewegung war und eine phänomenologisch-anthropologische Prägung aufwies. In Gegenüberstellung wird der ostdeutsche Ansatz von Weise und Thom erläutert, der an die phänomenologisch-anthropologische Subjektorientiertheit anknüpfte, aber mit der Einbeziehung einer marxistischen Auffassung eine sozialistische Sozialpsychiatrie begründete. Im Vergleich werden trotz vieler Übereinstimmungen die unterschiedlichen Gewichtungen der beiden Ansätze deutlich, die soziale Dimension des psychischen Krankseins zu verstehen. The study explores the common effort of social psychiatrists in Eastern and Western Germany to help people suffering from mental health issues to gain more self-determination and social participation and to make mental health care more humane from the 1960s onwards. At the same time, it provides a contrastive analysis of the social psychiatric concepts developed by the psychiatrists Karl Peter Kisker, Klaus Weise and the philosopher Achim Thom. A thorough analysis of literature reveals differences in the theoretical approaches in the East and West. Kisker, who was a representative of the West German social psychiatric movement, had a phenomenological-anthropological background. By contrast, Weise and Thom even though following the same subject orientation, established a socialist social psychiatry clearly integrating Marxist views into their concept. This contrastive also elaborates common viewpoints in understanding the social dimensions of mental health conditions in the two concepts. Received: 11 January 2024 Accepted: 26 March 2024 Article published online: 26 April 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

psychiatry
[Suicide in the Ravensburg/Oberschwaben area. Results of a study of 508 suicides based on criminal police records]

M Wolfersdorf,V Faust,R Hölzer

Abstract:On the basis of criminal police files we studied 508 suicides which happened between 1970 up to 1981 in the Ravensburg area in southern Germany. The police files also included medical records about in- or outpatient psychiatric treatment and also data about former violent behaviour. Mental disease as follows were most frequent: Depression 66% (diagnoses were made according to IDC-0 by two doctors under supervision of two senior psychiatrists; ICD-9: 300.4, 309.0 and 309.1 22%, ICD-9 296.1, 296.3 7.1% of the entire suicide group); neuroses and personality disorders 19%, addition, especially alcoholism, 28%. No psychiatric diagnosis could be made retrospectively in 10.6% (54 suicides). Sign in the presuicidal development like depressive symptoms, hopelessness and feelings of having no future, sleeping disturbances, feelings of guilt and anxiety, inner restlessness, but also changes in the direction of serenity and relaxation, treats of suicidal behaviour and reactions of the family and environment were reported showing a broad span of reactions from lack of perception to wrong interpretation. 15% of the suicides had also criminal activities in their former history. From a psychiatric point of view, improved diagnostic and therapeutic procedures in the treatment of the mentally ill, especially in the field of outpatient medical care of depressive and addictive patients, and better information of the relatives is to be demanded in order to prevent suicides.
Reasoning for autonomous suicide? A qualitative approach to pre-suicidal decision-making

Hannah Mrozynski,Eva Kuhn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2022.114764

Abstract:The article presents empirical data concerning the meaning of freedom and autonomy in the emotional-cognitive processes that govern pre-suicidal decision-making. The data is derived from a qualitative interview study conducted between December 2012 and July 2014 on an intensive care unit in Germany. Twelve patients (three male, nine female; seven with pre-diagnosed mental illness) who had attempted suicide by intoxication were included. The narrative biographical approach chosen allows to capture the individuals' experiences preceding their decisions for suicide and provides insights into the biographical contexts of their decisions. Most strikingly, the narratives underline the essential importance of interpersonal relationships as well as an ambivalent reciprocity of cognitive and emotional processes in pre-suicidal reasoning, while ideas of autonomy and decision-making capacity traditionally address rational deliberation. This divergence between patients' subjective perceptions and scholarly conceptualisations of autonomous suicide is in line with increasing criticism of conventional approaches, given that they ignore essential elements of human existence, such as values, emotions, and social interdependence. The empirical findings suggest moving beyond the idea of autonomous decision-making for suicide as a rational procedure and instead conceptualise the pre-suicidal decision-making process as a highly emotional phenomenon within a relational context. Acknowledging that suicidality is not only linked to cognitive considerations but also intertwined with or predominantly controlled by emotional dimensions, such as despair, crisis, and marginalisation, we argue that further evaluation tools are required to address suicidality in all its facets. In moving beyond the mere consideration of cognitive functions, this approach is particularly suitable for representing the reality of persons with mental illness. This provides urgently needed guidance for clinical practice, considering that the latest German jurisdiction on physician-assisted suicide holds that the right to a self-determined death cannot be refused unless an acute psychiatric condition directly caused the suicide wish.

Assistierte und konventionelle Suizide in München – ein Gruppenvergleich

Assistierte Suizide in München: angewendete Arzneistoffe und dokumentierte Komplikationen

Umgang mit assistiertem Suizid – Kenntnisse, Einstellungen und Erfahrungen von Mitgliedern der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin

Der assistierte Suizid in der Schweiz, ein Modell in der internationalen Diskussion zum Thema "Assisted dying"

Sichtweisen einer Stichprobe überwiegend jüngerer Ärztinnen und Ärzte zum ärztlich-assistierten Suizid

[Dealing with assisted suicide-knowledge, attitudes and experiences of members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine]

Inanspruchnahme psychosozialer Hilfen bei jungen Erwachsenen mit suizidalem Erleben und Verhalten

Der Assistierte Suizid – ein wichtiges Thema für Neurologie und Psychiatrie

What do suicide loss survivors think of physician-assisted suicide: a comparative analysis of suicide loss survivors and the general population in Germany

[Announced assisted suicide in Switzerland: a case report]

[Physician-assisted suicide - two perspectives]

Comparison of two suicide screening instruments for identifying high-risk individuals in prison

Assisted suicide in persons with mental disorders: a review of clinical-ethical arguments and recommendations

SELF-ADMINISTRATION OR PRACTITIONER ADMINISTRATION? THE SCOPE OF FUTURE GERMAN ASSISTED DYING LEGISLATION

Suizidalität – ein psychiatrischer Notfall in der Praxis

Comparative study of related factors and clinical features of attempted suicide

Euthanasia and assisted suicide in psychiatric patients: A systematic review of the literature

[A comparison of homicide-suicide and domestic homicide in the region of basle, Switzerland]

Sozialpsychiatrische Konzepte in der BRD und der DDR – Ein Vergleich der theoretischen Ansätze von Karl Peter Kisker sowie Klaus Weise und Achim Thom

[Suicide in the Ravensburg/Oberschwaben area. Results of a study of 508 suicides based on criminal police records]

Reasoning for autonomous suicide? A qualitative approach to pre-suicidal decision-making