Advances in the Evaluation of Selenium Bioavailabilityin Soil-Plant System
Fei Zhou,Qin Peng,Min Wan,Mingyue Xue,Hui Zhai,Nana Liu,Mengke Wang,Mingxing Qi,Dongli Liang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/tb-2020-1268
2021-01-01
Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)
Abstract:Selenium (Se) is an essential micronutrient for mammals, but its safe intake level is within a relatively narrow range. Dietary Se is the fundamental Se source for humans and primarily originates from soil. While, the content of bioavailable Se in soil is the key factor affecting the determination of its mobility and toxicity. Therefore, the bioavailability of Se in soil needs to be accurately determined and evaluated for the biofortification of Se and its pollution remediation. Due to the considerable differences in soil properties among different soil types and the soil-system complexity, no universal applicable method can be used to measure and evaluate Se bioavailability in soil. Chemical extraction methods (including single extraction and sequential extraction methods) and diffusive gradients in thin-film technique (DGT method) are commonly used to determine bioavailable Se in soil. Chemical extraction method is easy to operate and low cost, but its extractant lacks universal applicability, resulting in incomparable results among different chemical extraction methods. Selenium could also be re-adsorbed and redistributed during chemical extraction, which may lead to certain errors for the extraction results. DGT can simulate the dynamic absorption process of elements by plant roots, but its adsorption film is ion selective and costly, which affects its practical application. Obviously, different bioavailable Se-determination methods have various application scopes and significance, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. After comprehensively comparing different methods, the single-extraction method with 0.1 mol/L KH2PO4-K2HPO4 solution is recommended as the optimum method to determine bioavailable Se in soil. Furthermore, chemical-extraction result, parameter-evaluation method (relative binding intensity and mobility factor value) and plant-indicator method are confirmed to quantitatively characterize Se bioavailability in soil-plant system to a certain extent. However, similar to the determination methods of bioavailable Se in soil, each evaluation method of soil Se bioavailability has its own limitations. In other words, the parameter-evaluation method needs to consider the five fractions of Se, thus it is cumbersome to operate. Meanwhile, the plant-indicator method is limited by the species, varieties, and even the growth conditions of the indicator plants, leading to poor comparability among different results. Consequently, a universal approach for evaluating Se bioavailability in soil-plant system is also lacking. The feasibility of using the above indicators to evaluate Se bioavailability in soil was discussed in this article to provide a basis for screening an effective and unified method of evaluating soil Se bioavailability.