Abstract:Stimulated by informal conversations at the XVII International Small Angle Scattering (SAS) conference (Traverse City, 2017), an international team of experts undertook a round-robin exercise to produce a large dataset from proteins under standard solution conditions. These data were used to generate consensus SAS profiles for xylose isomerase, urate oxidase, xylanase, lysozyme and ribonuclease A. Here, we apply a new protocol using maximum likelihood with a larger number of the contributed datasets to generate improved consensus profiles. We investigate the fits of these profiles to predicted profiles from atomic coordinates that incorporate different models to account for the contribution to the scattering of water molecules of hydration surrounding proteins in solution. Programs using an implicit, shell-type hydration layer generally optimize fits to experimental data with the aid of two parameters that adjust the volume of the bulk solvent excluded by the protein and the contrast of the hydration layer. For these models, we found the error-weighted residual differences between the model and the experiment generally reflected the subsidiary maxima and minima in the consensus profiles that are determined by the size of the protein plus the hydration layer. By comparison, all-atom solute and solvent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are without the benefit of adjustable parameters and, nonetheless, they yielded at least equally good fits with residual differences that are less reflective of the structure in the consensus profile. Further, where MD simulations accounted for the precise solvent composition of the experiment, specifically the inclusion of ions, the modelled radius of gyration values were significantly closer to the experiment. The power of adjustable parameters to mask real differences between a model and the structure present in solution is demonstrated by the results for the conformationally dynamic ribonuclease A and calculations with pseudo-experimental data. This study shows that, while methods invoking an implicit hydration layer have the unequivocal advantage of speed, care is needed to understand the influence of the adjustable parameters. All-atom solute and solvent MD simulations are slower but are less susceptible to false positives, and can account for thermal fluctuations in atomic positions, and more accurately represent the water molecules of hydration that contribute to the scattering profile.

Coordinate‐based simulation of pair distance distribution functions for small and large molecular assemblies: implementation and applications

Computational Analysis of SAXS Data Acquisition.

"Ultima Ratio": Simulating wide-range X-ray scattering and diffraction

A Computational Model for Data Acquisition in SAXS

Conformational Distribution of a Multidomain Protein Measured by Single-Pair Small-Angle X-ray Scattering

Unraveling Low-Resolution Structural Data Of Large Biomolecules By Constructing Atomic Models With Experiment-Targeted Parallel Cascade Selection Simulations

Combining molecular dynamics simulations with small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering data to study multi-domain proteins in solution.

Benchmarking predictive methods for small-angle X-ray scattering from atomic coordinates of proteins using maximum likelihood consensus data

Computational Approaches to Model X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy from Molecular Dynamics

Super-Scalable Molecular Dynamics Algorithm

Frontiers in High-Performance, Large-Scale Molecular Dynamics. 35 Years of Molecular-Dynamics Simulations of Biological Systems

Structure and ensemble refinement against SAXS data: combining MD simulations with Bayesian inference or with the maximum entropy principle

New ways to boost molecular dynamics simulations

Small-angle X-ray scattering simulations on a single Pt nanoparticle system: An analysis of structural characteristics

Towards scanning nanostructure X‐ray microscopy

Integrating an Enhanced Sampling Method and Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering to Study Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Integrating machine learning with -SAS for enhanced structural analysis in small-angle scattering: applications in biological and artificial macromolecular complexes

Dissipative Particle Dynamics Simulation of Protein Folding in Explicit and Implicit Solvents: Coarse-Grained Model for Atomic Resolution

Scattering From Melts Of Combs And Bottlebrushes: Molecular Dynamics Simulations And Theoretical Study

Small angle x-ray scattering studies on colloid dispersive systems and organized molecular assemblies

Folding Simulations for Proteins with Diverse Topologies Are Accessible in Days with A Physics-Based Force Field and Implicit Solvent