Upstream-gating merge-control for maximising network capacity: With an application to urban traffic management

Michael J. Smith,Francesco Viti,Wei Huang,Richard Mounce
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trc.2023.104287
2023-08-24
Abstract:This paper considers a simple network with a merge and a downstream bottleneck, which corresponds to a very congested part of the City of York road network - Gillygate. We focus on "upstream-gating" control strategies which hold traffic back at traffic signals just ahead of the merge to prevent the formation of a queue at a downstream bottleneck; and we also consider different ways of further, additionally, controlling the two inflows to the merge. We show, by considering the simple network, that if the added upstream merge-control uses only flows to control the two approaches to the merge then equilibrium may not exist. For example, with the "zipper" rule (which equalises the two inflows at the merge) an equilibrium cannot exist for certain feasible demands on this network. On the other hand, we show that adding upstream merge-control which equalises the two delays felt at the merge allows an equilibrium for all feasible demands on this network, and so maximises the network capacity, notwithstanding the upstream gating. This suggests that, in general, delays should probably be used to control merges and downstream queues, rather than only flows, if network capacity is to be maximised. This observation may help the design of good control strategies, using both flows and delays, for upstream-gating designed to remove or reduce queues at specific downstream locations. The equilibrium analysis in our example is supported by (i) a dynamic analysis allowing for the dynamic growth of queues in the example network and (ii) real-life results of upstream-gating applied to Gillygate in York (UK) which provided motivation for this paper. The analysis here makes reasonable allowance for the spatial extent of queues but does not consider within-cycle or cycle-to-cycle queueing dynamics.
transportation science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?