RELATIVE SOLUBILITY OF C O R U N D U M , GIBBSITE, BOEHMITE, A N D DIASPORE AT S T A N D A R D STATE CONDITIONS 1
J. A. Kittrick,F. J. Peryea
Abstract:-The solubilities of HCl-treated samples of corundum, gibbsite, boehmite, and diaspore in aqueous solutions at 298 K and one atmosphere pressure were determined from undersaturated and supersaturated initial conditions. Solution characteristics at apparent equilibrium were measured and used to calculate equilibrium constants (K~) for mineral dissolution reactions: A1203 (corundum) + 3 H + = A13+ + 1.5 H20, AI(OH)3 (gibbsite) + 3 H + = AI 3§ + 3 H20, and AlOOH (boehmite or diaspore) + 3 H § = AP + + 2 HzO. Assuming solid phase and water activities of unity, log K~ = 3pH pAP + for all three equations. The calculated log I~ values were: 9.01 + 0.05 (corundum), 7.76 + 0.14 (gibbsite), 7.49 + 0.09 (boehmite), and 6.75 + 0.24 (diaspore), indicating that the relative thermodynamic stabilities under the experimental conditions were: corundum < gibbsite < boehmite < diaspore. The gibbsite value agreed well with that determined independently by another research group using acid-treated subsamples of the same source mineral (7.70 ___ 0.02). The calculated Gibbs free energies of formation (kJ/mole) were: -1587.4 --2.1 (corundum),-1156.7 + 1.6 (gibbsite),-921.0 + 1.5 (boehmite), and-925.1 _ 2.0 (diaspore). The AG~ values of the acid-treated minerals were 1.8 to 12.4 kJ/mole more negative than values recently compiled for untreated mineral samples. This result is attributed to the removal of reactive surface coatings that isolated the bulk mineral phases from the solution phase. Key Words--Acid solubility, Aluminum, Boehmite, Corundum, Diaspore, Gibbsite. I N T R O D U C T I O N The presence of gibbsi te [AI(OH)3], boehmi te (A1OOH), diaspore (A1OOH), and corundum (A1203) in lateritic soils and near-surface bauxites suggests the absence of thermodynamic equilibrium. Hemingway (1982) suggested that diaspore is the stable phase under surface weathering conditions and that gibbsite and boehmite are metastable phases whose presences are in large part due to slow rates of transformation. Direct precipitation of diaspore from A1 solutions has rarely been observed (Chesworth, 1978), although Wefers and Bell (1972) indicated that the presence of goethite (FeOOH) induced the precipitation of its isomorph diaspore at temperatures <298 K. Keller (1978) reported evidence for the recrystallization of diaspore in a clay deposit under surface weathering conditions. Gibbsite and its AI(OH)3 polymorphs readily precipitate under a wide variety of experimental conditions (Hemingway, 1982). Certain inorganic and organic ligands appear to be necessary to promote the precipitation ofboehmite over other AI hydroxides and to ensure its stability after precipitation (Violante and 1 scientific Paper 7888, Project 0747, College of Agriculture and Home Economics Research Center, Washington State University, Pullman, Washington 99164. 2 Present address: Washington State University, Tree Fruit Research Center, 1100 North Western Avenue, Wenatchee, Washington 98801. Copyright 9 1988, The Clay Minerals Society Huang, 1984). Hemingway (1982) concluded that in natural waters the rapid polymerization of dissolved hydroxyaluminum ions favors the metastable precipitation of AI(OH)3 at the expense of A1OOH phases. Gibbsite should therefore be more likely to form than boehmite and diaspore in lateritic soils and bauxites. Once formed, gibbsite, boehmite, and diaspore show little propensity to alter to other minerals within the timescale of most laboratory experiments. The chemical activity of water appears to be a major factor driving the progressive dehydration of the minerals at 298 K (Troland and Tardy, 1987); however, water activity is rarely controlled at less than unity in laboratory experiments. The slow kinetics of transformation have prompted numerous attempts to establish the relative stabilities of the minerals on the basis of thermochemical data; however, the large errors associated with the Gibbs free energies of forrnation (AG~) of the minerals do not permit unambiguous determination of the directions of the gibbsite-boehmite, gibbsite-diaspore, and boehmite-diaspore reactions (Hsu, 1977). The present study was undertaken to determine by solubility methods the relative thermodynamic stabilities of corundum, gibbsite, boehmite, and diaspore at 298 K, one atmosphere pressure, and water activity of unity. Calculated values of the equilibrium constants for the respective dissolution reactions were used to quantify the stability relations. This procedure avoided the cumulative errors introduced in calculating AG~
Chemistry