State-of-the-Art Low-Cost Air Quality Sensors, Assemblies, Calibration and Evaluation for Respiration-Associated Diseases: A Systematic Review

Hasan Tariq,Farid Touati,Damiano Crescini,Adel Ben Mnaouer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos15040471
IF: 3.11
2024-04-11
Atmosphere
Abstract:Indoor air quality and respiratory health have always been an area of prime interest across the globe. The significance of low-cost air quality sensing and indoor public health practices spiked during the pandemic when indoor air pollution became a threat to living beings, especially human beings. Problem Definition: Indoor respiration-associated diseases are hard to diagnose if they are due to indoor environmental conditions. A major challenge was observed in establishing a baseline between indoor air quality sensors and associated respiratory diseases. Methods: In this work, 10,000+ articles from top literature databases were reviewed using six bibliometric analysis methods (Lorenz Curve of Citations, Hirch's H-Index, Kosmulski's H2-Index, Harzing's Hl-Norm-Index, Sidoropolous's HC-Index, and Schrieber's HM-index) to formulate indoor air quality sensor and disease correlation publication rubrics to critically review 482 articles. Results: A set of 152 articles was found based on systematic review parameters in six bibliometric indices for publications that used WHO, NIH, US EPA, CDC, and FDA-defined principles. Five major respiratory diseases were found to be causing major death toll (up to 32%) due to five key pollutants, measured by 30+ low-cost sensors and further optimized by seven calibration systems for seven practical parameters tailored to respiratory disease baselines evaluated through 10 cost parameters. Impact: This review was conducted to assist end-users, public health facilities, state agencies, researchers, scientists, and air quality protection agencies.
environmental sciences,meteorology & atmospheric sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: it is difficult to diagnose indoor respiration - related diseases, especially when these diseases are caused by indoor environmental conditions. Specifically, a major challenge was found in the study, that is, to establish a baseline relationship between indoor air quality sensors and related respiratory diseases. Through systematic review and bibliometric analysis methods, the authors aim to evaluate and calibrate low - cost air quality sensors to better monitor and manage indoor air pollution, thereby reducing the morbidity and mortality of respiratory diseases. ### Problem Definition - **Problem Background**: Indoor air quality (IAQ) and respiratory health have always been the focus of global attention. Especially during the epidemic, indoor air pollution has become a serious problem threatening human health. - **Specific Problem**: It is difficult to diagnose indoor respiration - related diseases, especially when these diseases are caused by indoor environmental conditions. A major challenge is to establish a baseline relationship between indoor air quality sensors and related respiratory diseases. ### Methods - **Literature Review**: The authors reviewed more than 10,000 articles from top - tier literature databases and used six bibliometric analysis methods (Lorenz Citation Curve, H - Index, H2 - Index, Hl - Norm - Index, HC - Index, HM - Index) to develop publication criteria for the correlation between indoor air quality sensors and diseases. - **Systematic Review**: Based on the six bibliometric indices, 482 articles were finally determined for detailed review. ### Results - **Key Findings**: According to the systematic review parameters, among the six bibliometric indices, 152 articles were found. These articles used the principles defined by WHO, NIH, US EPA, CDC and FDA. The study found that five major respiratory diseases (asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, ischemic heart disease, stroke, pneumonia and lower respiratory tract infections) led to a mortality rate of up to 32%. These diseases are related to five key pollutants. These pollutants are measured by more than 30 low - cost sensors and optimized by seven calibration systems to adapt to seven practical parameters, which are evaluated against the baseline of respiratory diseases. ### Impact - **Application Value**: This review aims to assist end - users, public health facilities, national institutions, researchers, scientists and air quality protection agencies to improve their awareness and ability in indoor air quality monitoring and respiratory disease management. ### Key Terms - **IAQ**: Indoor Air Quality - **AQA**: Air Quality Assessment - **AQMap**: Air Quality Map - **AQMP**: Air Quality Management Plan - **API**: Air Pollution Index - **AQ - GS**: Air Quality - Gas Sensor - **OGS**: Optical Gas Sensor - **ECS**: Electrochemical Gas Sensor - **AGS**: Acoustic Gas Sensor - **CGS**: Capacitive Gas Sensor ### Main Contributions 1. **Bibliometric Analysis**: Bibliometric analysis of the correlation between IAQ and indoor epidemiology. 2. **Air Quality Assessment Framework**: Propose an air quality assessment framework. 3. **Sensor Types and Technologies**: Introduce the types and technologies of air quality sensors. 4. **Sensor Configuration and Topology**: Discuss the configuration and topology of sensors. 5. **Sensor Calibration and Test Systems**: Introduce sensor calibration and test systems. 6. **Air Quality Measurement Systems**: Explore air quality measurement systems. 7. **Indoor Epidemiology and Diseases**: Analyze indoor epidemiology and related diseases. 8. **Practical Application Considerations**: Discuss the deployment and application of low - cost air quality sensors in the real world. 9. **Future Research Directions**: Propose future research suggestions and directions. Through these methods and results, the paper aims to provide scientific basis and technical support for improving indoor air quality monitoring and respiratory disease management.