Abstract:Big data, high-performance computing, and (deep) machine learning are increasingly becoming key to precision medicine—from identifying disease risks and taking preventive measures, to making diagnoses and personalizing treatment for individuals. Precision medicine, however, is not only about predicting risks and outcomes, but also about weighing interventions. Interventional clinical predictive models require the correct specification of cause and effect, and the calculation of so-called counterfactuals, that is, alternative scenarios. In biomedical research, observational studies are commonly affected by confounding and selection bias. Without robust assumptions, often requiring a priori domain knowledge, causal inference is not feasible. Data-driven prediction models are often mistakenly used to draw causal effects, but neither their parameters nor their predictions necessarily have a causal interpretation. Therefore, the premise that data-driven prediction models lead to trustable decisions/interventions for precision medicine is questionable. When pursuing intervention modelling, the bio-health informatics community needs to employ causal approaches and learn causal structures. Here we discuss how target trials (algorithmic emulation of randomized studies), transportability (the licence to transfer causal effects from one population to another) and prediction invariance (where a true causal model is contained in the set of all prediction models whose accuracy does not vary across different settings) are linchpins to developing and testing intervention models.

Counterfactual simulation in causal cognition

Simulation Experiments as a Causal Problem

Looking at Mental Images: Eye‐Tracking Mental Simulation During Retrospective Causal Judgment

Simulation-Based Counterfactual Causal Discovery on Real World Driver Behaviour

Story understanding and counterfactual reasoning.

Neural Causal Models for Counterfactual Identification and Estimation

The Causal Topography of Cognition

Counterfactual thoughts in complex causal domain: content, benefits, and implications for their function

Cognitive neuroscience of human counterfactual reasoning

Causal Inference and Counterfactual Prediction in Machine Learning for Actionable Healthcare

A Quantum Probability Model of Causal Reasoning

Causal intuition in the indefinite world: Meta-analysis and simulations

Causality in Cognitive Neuroscience: Concepts, Challenges, and Distributional Robustness

Causal Modeling Semantics for Counterfactuals with Disjunctive Antecedents

The Sin of Prediction: When Mentally Simulated Alternatives Compete With Reality

Computer Simulations of Causal Sets

Counterfactual Causality from First Principles?

Predicting responsibility judgments from dispositional inferences and causal attributions

An improved probabilistic account of counterfactual reasoning.

Causal Imputation for Counterfactual SCMs: Bridging Graphs and Latent Factor Models