Abstract:We resolve the nature of the quantum phase transition between a Néel antiferromagnet and a valence-bond solid in two-dimensional spin-1/2 magnets. We study a class of $J$-$Q$ models, in which Heisenberg exchange $J$ competes with interactions $Q_n$ formed by products of $n$ singlet projectors on adjacent parallel lattice links. QMC simulations provide unambiguous evidence for first-order transitions, with the discontinuities increasing with $n$. For $n=2$ and $n=3$ models, the first-order signatures are very weak. On intermediate length scales, we extract well-defined scaling dimensions (critical exponents) that are common to the models with small $n$, indicating proximity to a quantum critical point. By combining two $Q$ terms, the transition can be tuned from weak to more strongly first-order. The two coexisting orders on the first-order line scale with a large exponent $\beta \approx 0.85$. This exponent and others are close to bounds for an SO($5$) symmetric CFT with a relevant SO($5$) singlet. We characterize the emergent SO($5$) symmetry by the scaling dimensions of its leading irrelevant perturbations. The large $\beta$ value and a large correlation length exponent, $\nu \approx 1.4$, partially explain why the transition remains near-critical even quite far away from the critical point and in many different models without fine-tuning. In addition, we find that few-spin lattice operators are dominated by the SO($5$) violating field (the traceless symmetric tensor), and interactions involving many spins are required to observe strong effects of the relevant SO($5$) singlet. The exponent that had previously been identified with the divergent correlation length when crossing between the two phases does not have a corresponding CFT operator. We explain this emergent pseudocritical scale by a mechanism relying on a dangerously irrelevant SO($5$) perturbation.

Comment on ``Bicritical and Tetracritical Phenomena and Scaling Properties of the SO(5) Theory,'' [X. Hu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 057004 (2001)]

The SO(5) Theory as a Critical Dynamical Symmetry

Thermodynamic properties of the SO(5) theory for the antiferromagnetism and d-wave superconductivity: a Monte Carlo study

SO(5) multicriticality in two-dimensional quantum magnets

Superconducting symmetry of three-dimensional $t$-$J$ model on simple cubic lattice

Emergent Quantum Criticality from Fractionalizing One-Dimensional So(5) Symmetric Valence-Bond Solid States

$SO(8)$ unification and the large-N theory of superconductor-insulator transition of two-dimensional Dirac fermions

Comments on Global Symmetries and Anomalies of $5d$ SCFTs

Emergent O(N) Symmetry in A Series of Three-Dimensional Potts Models

SO(5) Deconfined Phase Transition under the Fuzzy-Sphere Microscope: Approximate Conformal Symmetry, Pseudo-Criticality, and Operator Spectrum

Comments on Global Symmetries and Anomalies of 5d SCFTs

Constrains on s and d components of electron boson coupling constants in one band d wave Eliashberg theory for high Tc superconductors

Quantum Phase Transitions Beyond the Landau Paradigm in a Sp(4) Spin System

Deconfined Quantum Criticality and Emergent SO(5) Symmetry in Fermionic Systems

Comments on flavor symmetry breaking and three-dimensional superconformal index

Phases of SO(5) Nonlinear Sigma Model with a Topological Term on a Sphere: Multicritical Point and Disorder Phase

Stability against contact interactions of a topological superconductor in two-dimensional space protected by time-reversal and reflection symmetries

Time-Reversal Symmetry Breaking: Evidence for Spin Pairing in High-{ T C } Superconductors

Robustness of s-wave pairing symmetry in iron-based superconductors and its implications to fundamentals on magnetically-driven high temperature superconductivity

Quantum Criticality of Spinons

Symplectic Ferromagnetism and Phase Transitions in Multi-Component Fermionic Systems