SO(5) multicriticality in two-dimensional quantum magnets

Jun Takahashi,Hui Shao,Bowen Zhao,Wenan Guo,Anders W. Sandvik

2024-05-11

Abstract:We resolve the nature of the quantum phase transition between a Néel antiferromagnet and a valence-bond solid in two-dimensional spin-1/2 magnets. We study a class of $J$-$Q$ models, in which Heisenberg exchange $J$ competes with interactions $Q_n$ formed by products of $n$ singlet projectors on adjacent parallel lattice links. QMC simulations provide unambiguous evidence for first-order transitions, with the discontinuities increasing with $n$. For $n=2$ and $n=3$ models, the first-order signatures are very weak. On intermediate length scales, we extract well-defined scaling dimensions (critical exponents) that are common to the models with small $n$, indicating proximity to a quantum critical point. By combining two $Q$ terms, the transition can be tuned from weak to more strongly first-order. The two coexisting orders on the first-order line scale with a large exponent $\beta \approx 0.85$. This exponent and others are close to bounds for an SO($5$) symmetric CFT with a relevant SO($5$) singlet. We characterize the emergent SO($5$) symmetry by the scaling dimensions of its leading irrelevant perturbations. The large $\beta$ value and a large correlation length exponent, $\nu \approx 1.4$, partially explain why the transition remains near-critical even quite far away from the critical point and in many different models without fine-tuning. In addition, we find that few-spin lattice operators are dominated by the SO($5$) violating field (the traceless symmetric tensor), and interactions involving many spins are required to observe strong effects of the relevant SO($5$) singlet. The exponent that had previously been identified with the divergent correlation length when crossing between the two phases does not have a corresponding CFT operator. We explain this emergent pseudocritical scale by a mechanism relying on a dangerously irrelevant SO($5$) perturbation.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,High Energy Physics - Lattice

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the nature of the quantum phase transition between the Néel antiferromagnet state and the spontaneously dimerized valence-bond solid (VBS) state in 2D quantum magnets. Specifically, the researchers explore a class of J-Q models, in which the standard Heisenberg exchange interaction J competes with multi-spin interactions Qn, the latter formed by the product of singlet projection operators on adjacent parallel links. Through large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculations, the researchers provide clear evidence of first-order transitions in these models, and the strength of the discontinuity increases with the value of n.

In the extensively studied n=2 and n=3 models, although the characteristics of the first-order transition are very weak, they can still be observed in the correlation functions on large lattices. On intermediate length scales (depending on the observable, up to several hundred lattice constants), the researchers can extract well-defined scaling dimensions (critical exponents) from models with small n values, indicating that these models are close to a universal quantum critical point. By combining two different Q terms, specifically the J-Q2-Q6 model, the transition can be continuously tuned from weak first-order to stronger first-order. In the (Q2, Q6) plane, when J=1-Q2, the scaling exponents of the two coexisting order parameters on the first-order line are anomalously large, approximately β≈0.85. This exponent matches well with other known strict boundaries corresponding to SO(5) symmetric conformal field theory (CFT), but contrary to mainstream views, the dominant SO(5) singlet operator is relevant and leads to the first-order transition ending at a finely tuned multicritical point.

Additionally, the study finds that few-spin lattice operators are primarily governed by their SO(5) breaking field (trace-symmetric tensor) content, while observing strong SO(5) singlet effects requires involving interactions of multiple spins. The researchers also explain the emergence mechanism of a new "pseudocritical" length scale, which depends on the dangerously irrelevant perturbations of the SO(5) symmetry and the repulsive interactions between the two order parameters. This length scale is reflected in the crossing behavior of observable physical quantities when traversing the weak first-order line. The results of the paper not only establish a first-order transition line terminating at an SO(5) multicritical point but also provide new insights into the nature of weak first-order transitions, including why many models seem to naturally include such transitions without fine-tuning.