Evaluation of the Microbiome Identification of Forensically Relevant Biological Fluids: A Pilot Study

Audrey Gouello,Laura Henry,Djamel Chadli-Benhemani,Florian Salipante,Joséphine Gibert,Adeline Boutet-Dubois,Jean-Philippe Lavigne

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics14020187

IF: 3.6

2024-01-16

Diagnostics

Abstract:In forensic sciences, body fluids, or biological traces, are a major source of information, and their identification can play a decisive role in criminal investigations. Currently, the nature of biological fluids is assessed using immunological, physico-chemical, mRNA and epigenetic methods, but these have limits in terms of sensitivity and specificity. The emergence of next-generation sequencing technologies offers new opportunities to identify the nature of body fluids by determining bacterial communities. The aim of this pilot study was to assess whether analysis of the bacterial communities in isolated and mixed biological fluids could reflect the situation observed in real forensics labs. Several samples commonly encountered in forensic sciences were tested from healthy volunteers: saliva, vaginal fluid, blood, semen and skin swabs. These samples were analyzed alone or in combination in a ratio of 1:1. Sequencing was performed on the Ion Gene StudioTM S5 automated sequencer. Fluids tested alone revealed a typical bacterial signature with specific bacterial orders, enabling formal identification of the fluid of interest, despite inter-individual variations. However, in biological fluid mixtures, the predominance of some bacterial microbiomes inhibited interpretation. Oral and vaginal microbiomes were clearly preponderant, and the relative abundance of their bacterial communities and/or the presence of common species between samples made it impossible to detect bacterial orders or genera from other fluids, although they were distinguishable from one another. However, using the beta diversity, salivary fluids were identified and could be distinguished from fluids in combination. While this method of fluid identification is promising, further analyses are required to consolidate the protocol and ensure reliability.

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is in forensic science, to identify different biological fluids (such as saliva, vaginal secretions, blood, semen and skin swabs) by analyzing microbial communities, as well as the identification problem of these fluids in the case of mixing. Currently, the nature assessment of biological fluids mainly depends on immunological, physical - chemical, mRNA and epigenetic methods, but these methods have limitations in terms of sensitivity and specificity. The emergence of next - generation sequencing technology has provided new opportunities for identifying body fluids by determining bacterial communities. Therefore, this preliminary study aims to evaluate whether the analysis of bacterial communities in single and mixed biological fluids can reflect the situation in actual forensic laboratories and explore its application potential in forensic identification.

Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Identification of single biological fluids**: By analyzing separately collected biological fluid samples, verify whether different fluids have unique bacterial characteristics, so as to be able to formally identify specific fluids.
2. **Identification of mixed biological fluids**: Study the changes in bacterial communities after different biological fluids are mixed, especially the influence of the dominance of oral and vaginal microbiota on the identification of other fluids.
3. **Reliability and stability of the method**: Evaluate the feasibility and reliability of this method in actual forensic applications, including the ability to detect low - amount bacterial communities, the detection of mixed microbiota and the differences in microbiota between individuals.

The paper shows through experimental data that although single biological fluids can be identified by their unique bacterial communities, in mixed fluids, the dominance of certain microbiota will inhibit the detection of other microorganisms, especially the oral and vaginal microbiota. Nevertheless, using β - diversity analysis, saliva samples can be identified in mixed samples. However, in order to ensure the reliability and stability of the method, further research and analysis are still required.