Abstract:A delicate tension complicates the relationship between the topological magnetoelectric effect (TME) in three-dimensional (3D) $\mathbb{Z}_2$ topological insulators (TIs) and time-reversal symmetry (TRS). TRS underlies a particular $\mathbb{Z}_2$ topological classification of the electronic ground state of crystalline band insulators and the associated quantization of the magnetoelectric response coefficient calculated using bulk linear response theory but, according to standard symmetry arguments, simultaneously forbids a nonzero magnetoelectric coefficient in any physical finite-size system. This contrast between theories of magnetoelectric response in formal bulk models and in real finite-sized materials originates from the distinct approaches required to introduce notions of (electronic) polarization and orbital magnetization in these fundamentally different environments. In this work we argue for a modified interpretation of the bulk linear response calculations in non-magnetic $\mathbb{Z}_2$ TIs that is more plainly consistent with TRS, and use this interpretation to discuss the effect's observation - still absent over a decade after its prediction. Motivated by analytical results, we conjecture a type of microscopic bulk-boundary correspondence: a bulk insulator with (generalized) TRS supports a magnetoelectric coefficient that is purely itinerant (which is generically related to the geometry of the ground state) if and only if magnetic surface dopants are required for the TME to manifest in finite samples thereof. We conclude that in non-magnetic $\mathbb{Z}_2$ TIs the TME is activated by magnetic surface dopants, that the charge density response to a uniform dc magnetic field is localized at the surface and specified by the configuration of those dopants, and that the TME is qualitatively less robust against disorder than the integer quantum Hall effect.

The topological Faraday effect cannot be observed in a realistic sample

Symmetry, topology, and geometry: The many faces of the topological magnetoelectric effect

Topological Effects on the Magnetoconductivity in Topological Insulators

Determination of the Quantized Topological Magneto-Electric Effect in Topological Insulators from Rayleigh Scattering

Generalized Quantization Condition for Topological Insulators

Magnetic proximity effect in the 3D topological insulator/ferromagnetic insulator heterostructure

Topological Transitions Induced by Antiferromagnetism in a Thin-Film Topological Insulator

Magneto-optical effects of an artificially-layered ferromagnetic topological insulator with T$_C$ of 160 K

Magneto-optical Effects of an Artificially Layered Ferromagnetic Topological Insulator with a TC of 160 K

Proximity-induced anisotropic magnetoresistance in magnetized topological insulators

Anisotropic Topological Magnetoelectric Effect in Axion Insulators

Electric response of a composite of topological insulator nanoparticles

Kerr, Faraday, and Magnetoelectric Effects in MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ Thin Films

Magnetoconductance, Quantum Hall Effect, and Coulomb Blockade in Topological Insulator Nanocones

Magnetic-Field Induced Semimetal in Topological Crystalline Insulator Thin Films

Unusual Electromagnetic Scattering by Cylinders of Topological Insulator

Thermoelectric Effects and Topological Insulators

Capacitive detection of the topological magnetoelectric effect

J ul 2 01 6 Thermoelectric Effects and Topological Insulators ∗

Effect of Dilute Magnetism in a Topological Insulator

Bulk versus surface: Nonuniversal partitioning of the topological magnetoelectric effect