PLUTARCH'S GREEK LIVES
Lucy E. Fletcher
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X13002485
2014-03-20
The Classical Review
Abstract:Setting out ‘to serve the needs of readers exploring ancient history through primary sources’ (p. viii), this volume provides excerpts from fifteen (of the extant twenty-three) of Plutarch’s Greek Lives: Theseus, Lycurgus, Solon, Themistocles, Aristides, Cimon, Pericles, Nicias, Alcibiades, Lysander, Agesilaus, Pelopidas, Demosthenes, Alexander and Phocion. Excluded from the volume are: Pyrrhus, Eumenes, Dion, Timoleon, Agis and Cleomenes, Demetrius and Philopoemen. As R. explains, the Dion and the Timoleon are excluded on account of their dealing principally with Greek Sicily, the others because they ‘take place largely or entirely in the Hellenistic age’ (p. viii). This volume follows in the footsteps of R.’s Herodotus. On the War for Greek Freedom. Selections from the Histories, also published by Hackett (2003), with translations by S. Shirley. In the same style as the earlier volume, R. excerpts material aimed at constructing a linear narrative of Greek history, excising material considered to be extraneous or tangential to the main storyline. The volume begins with a brief, four-page introduction to the Parallel Lives, providing some general remarks on Plutarch’s literary style and his approach to history. Mention is made of the paired structure of the Parallel Lives, their concern with questions of what makes a good leader and their moral agenda (p. vi). These are important issues for understanding the Lives, and the discussion might profitably have been extended in the context of this volume to discuss the ways in which these factors influenced Plutarch’s representation of the past. The paired structure of the Parallel Lives, for instance, and their comparative approach to history, significantly affects Plutarch’s representation of the past and the ways in which he shapes his material in each of the paired biographies. In this connection, it might also have been helpful to mention the Roman pair to each of the Greek Lives excerpted. The introductorymaterial includes a table showing the life spans ofmost of the subjects of the Lives included in the volume, alongside three maps: the Greek World, the Persian invasions and the route of Alexander’s campaigns in the Persian Empire. A helpful bibliography is also provided, which cites the most important works of scholarship on Plutarch’s Parallel Lives. Some recent works, which will have appeared too late to have beenmentioned here but which may be of interest to readers, include: N. Humble (ed.), Parallelism in Plutarch’s Lives: Parallelism and Purpose (2010) and T.E. Duff’s exhaustive study, ‘The Structure of the Plutarchan Book’, Classical Antiquity 30.2 [2011], 213–78). Each excerpt begins with a brief (between ten and twenty lines) historical introduction to the subject of the Life, usually with some discussion of the relationship of the Life to the other main sources (e.g. Herodotus and Thucydides for Themistocles), and with other Lives THE CLASSICAL REVIEW 93
History