Passive Removal of Mn from Mine Water Using Oxic Aggregate Beds: Results of Two Pilot Systems

Robert S. Hedin,Neil Wolfe,Benjamin Hedin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10230-024-00990-6

2024-06-25

Mine Water and the Environment

Abstract:In the U.S., the state of Pennsylvania has proposed lowering its Mn criterion from 1.0 to 0.3 mg/L. An investigation of the feasibility of meeting this standard with passive treatment was conducted. Existing data from 19 full-scale oxic limestone beds were compiled from literature reports to determine current Mn removal effectiveness and rates. The median system decreased Mn from 20 to 1.7 mg/L at a theoretical retention time of 37 h. Only two passive treatment systems produced effluents with < 0.3 mg/L Mn. In order to explore the capabilities of oxic limestone beds to remove Mn, two experimental oxic aggregate beds were installed at conventional AMD treatment plants and used to experimentally treat a portion of each plant's final effluent. The Hollywood unit was marginally effective, decreasing Mn on average from 0.584 to 0.281 mg/L with a theoretical retention time (TRT) of 3.7 h. The Brandy Camp unit was highly effective, decreasing Mn from 5.85 to 0.095 mg/L when operated at a TRT of 2.3 h. Effective removal of Mn by the Brandy Camp unit required 7 weeks of aggregate ripening. Average Mn removal rates for the Brandy Camp unit were 22.7 g/d/m 2 , 15.7 g/d/mt, and 2.5 mg/L/hr of theoretical retention time. The half-time of Mn removal was 25 min. After one year of operation, hydraulic problems associated with the accumulation of iron solids on the surface of the aggregate forced termination of the Brandy Camp unit. The results indicate that the 0.3 mg/L effluent criterion can be achieved with oxic aggregate beds at very short retention times, as long as aggregate permeability is maintained.

water resources