Abstract:Every computer system -- from schedulers in clouds (e.g. Amazon) to computer networks to operating systems -- performs resource allocation across system users. The defacto allocation policies are max-min fairness (MMF) for single resources and dominant resource fairness (DRF) for multiple resources which guarantee properties like incentive compatibility, envy-freeness, and Pareto efficiency, assuming user demands are static (time-independent). However, in real-world systems, user demands are dynamic, i.e. time-dependant. As a result, there is now a fundamental mismatch between the goals of computer systems and the properties enabled by classic resource allocation policies. We aim to bridge this mismatch. When demands are dynamic, instant-by-instant MMF can be extremely unfair over longer periods of time, i.e. lead to unbalanced user allocations as previous allocations have no effect in the present. We consider a natural generalization of MMF and DRF for multiple resources and users with dynamic demands: this algorithm ensures that user allocations are as max-min fair as possible up to any time instant, given past allocations. This dynamic mechanism remains Pareto optimal and envy-free, but not incentive compatible. However, our results show that the possible increase in utility by misreporting is bounded and, since this can lead to significant decrease in overall useful allocation, this suggests that it is not a useful strategy. Our main result is to show that our dynamic DRF algorithm is $(1+\rho)$-incentive compatible, where $\rho$ quantifies the relative importance of a resource for different users; we show that this factor is tight even with only two resources. We also present a $3/2$ upper bound and a $\sqrt 2$ lower bound for incentive compatibility when there is only one resource. We also offer extensions for the case when users are weighted to prioritize them differently.

Maximum incremental (minimum decremental) ratio and one-sided RTS in FDH production technologies

Non-radial two-stage network DEA model to estimate returns to scale

Measurement of returns to scale using a non-radial DEA model: A range-adjusted measure approach

Efficiency Decomposition in Two-Stage Network in Data Envelopment Analysis with Undesirable Intermediate Measures and Fuzzy Input and Output

Estimating the return to scale of an integer-valued data envelopment analysis model: efficiency assessment of a higher education institution

Estimation of congestion in free disposal hull models using data envelopment analysis

Measurement of returns to scale in DEA using the CCR model

Evaluation of Multi-stage Fuzzy Networks in DEA and DEA-R Based on Liquidity Ratios with Undesirable Outputs

Classifying flexible measures in two-stage network DEA and DEA-RA using novel slacks-based models

Characterizing and finding full dimensional efficient facets in DEA: a variable returns to scale specification

On the Estimation of Directional Returns to Scale via DEA models

An Inequality Evaluation Approach With Nonincreasing Returns To Scale

A slacks-based measure approach for efficiency decomposition in multi-period two-stage systems

Development of a Bounded Two-Stage Data Envelopment Analysis Model in the Intuitionistic Fuzzy Environment

Relationship between DEA models without explicit inputs and DEA-R models

Performance Ranking Method Based on Superefficiency with Directional Distance Function in DEA

A new robust DEA model and super-efficiency measure

Cone Ratio Models with Shared Resources and Nontransparent Allocation Parameters in Network DEA

A Novel Approach for Efficiency Evaluation in Data Envelopment Analysis Framework with Fuzzy Stochastic Variables

An inverse data envelopment analysis model to consider ratio data and preferences of decision-makers

Incentives in Dominant Resource Fair Allocation under Dynamic Demands