Abstract:In the literature, there is widespread consensus that methods in plastic research need improvement. Current limitations in quality assurance and harmonization prevent progress in our understanding of the true effects of microplastic in the environment. Following the recent development of quality assessment methods for studies reporting concentrations in biota and water samples, we propose a method to assess the quality of microplastic effect studies. We reviewed 105 microplastic effect studies with aquatic biota, provided a systematic overview of their characteristics, developed 20 quality criteria in four main criteria categories (particle characterization, experimental design, applicability in risk assessment, and ecological relevance), propose a protocol for future effect studies with particles, and, finally, used all the information to define the weight of evidence with respect to demonstrated effect mechanisms. On average, studies scored 44.6% (range 20–77.5%) of the maximum score. No study scored positively on all criteria, reconfirming the urgent need for better quality assurance. Most urgent recommendations for improvement relate to avoiding and verifying background contamination, and to improving the environmental relevance of exposure conditions. The majority of the studies (86.7%) evaluated on particle characteristics properly, nonetheless it should be underlined that by failing to provide characteristics of the particles, an entire experiment can become irreproducible. Studies addressed environmentally realistic polymer types fairly well; however, there was a mismatch between sizes tested and those targeted when analyzing microplastic in environmental samples. In far too many instances, studies suggest and speculate mechanisms that are poorly supported by the design and reporting of data in the study. This represents a problem for decision-makers and needs to be minimized in future research. In their papers, authors frame 10 effects mechanisms as "suggested", whereas 7 of them are framed as "demonstrated". When accounting for the quality of the studies according to our assessment, three of these mechanisms remained. These are inhibition of food assimilation and/or decreased nutritional value of food, internal physical damage, and external physical damage. We recommend that risk assessment addresses these mechanisms with higher priority.This article has not yet been cited by other publications.

Source-specific probabilistic risk assessment of microplastics in soils applying quality criteria and data alignment methods

Microplastics in Soil Aggregates: Analytical Methods, Occurrence Patterns, Impact Analyses and Removal Approaches

Risk assessment of microplastics in freshwater sediments guided by strict quality criteria and data alignment methods

Microplastics in soils: A review of methods, occurrence, fate, transport, ecological and environmental risks

Strategy towards producing relevant and reliable data for the hazard assessment of micro- and nanoplastics in agricultural soils

Microplastics pollution in soil and the potential ecological health risks

Insights into Microplastics in the Soil Environment: Migration, Biodegradation, Toxicity and Risk Assessment

A comprehensive risk assessment of microplastics in soil, water, and atmosphere: Implications for human health and environmental safety

Distribution characteristics and integrated ecological risks evaluation modelling of microplastics and heavy metals in geological high background soil

Assessing the role of polyethylene microplastics as a vector for organic pollutants in soil: Ecotoxicological and molecular approaches

Risk assessment of microplastic particles

Microplastics in cultivated soil environment: Construction of toxicity grading evaluation system, development of priority control checklist, and toxicity mechanism analysis

Considering microplastic characteristics in ecological risk assessment: A case study for China

Occurrence and risk associated with urban road-deposited microplastics

Microplastics in Soils: Analytical Methods, Pollution Characteristics and Ecological Risks

Soil microplastic analysis: a harmonized methodology

Errors and recommended practices that should be identified to reduce suspected concentrations of microplastics in soil and groundwater: A review

Data quality assessment for studies investigating microplastics and nanoplastics in food products: Are current data reliable?

Microplastics in Soils: an Environmental Geotechnics Perspective

Critical reassessment of microplastic abundances in the marine environment

Quality Criteria for Microplastic Effect Studies in the Context of Risk Assessment: A Critical Review