Abstract:Background: Shear wave elastography (SWE) is mainly used for stiffness estimation of large, homogeneous tissues, such as the liver and breasts. However, little is known about its accuracy and applicability in thin (∼0.5-2 mm) vessel walls. To identify possible performance differences among vendors, we quantified differences in measured wave velocities obtained by commercial SWE implementations of various vendors over different imaging depths in a vessel-mimicking phantom. For reference, we measured SWE values in the cylindrical inclusions and homogeneous background of a commercial SWE phantom. Additionally, we compared the accuracy between a research implementation and the commercially available clinical SWE on an Aixplorer ultrasound system in phantoms and in vivo in patients. Methods: SWE measurements were performed over varying depths (0-35 mm) using three ultrasound machines with four ultrasound probes in the homogeneous 20 kPa background and cylindrical targets of 10, 40, and 60 kPa of a multi-purpose phantom (CIRS-040GSE) and in the anterior and posterior wall of a homogeneous polyvinyl alcohol vessel-mimicking phantom. These phantom data, along with in vivo SWE data of carotid arteries in 23 patients with a (prior) head and neck neoplasm, were also acquired in the research and clinical mode of the Aixplorer ultrasound machine. Machine-specific estimated phantom stiffness values (CIRS phantom) or wave velocities (vessel phantom) over all depths were visualized, and the relative error to the reference values and inter-frame variability (interquartile range/median) were calculated. Correlations between SWE values and target/vessel wall depth were explored in phantoms and in vivo using Spearman's correlations. Differences in wave velocities between the anterior and posterior arterial wall were assessed with Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. Intra-class correlation coefficients were calculated for a sample of ten patients as a measure of intra- and interobserver reproducibility of SWE analyses in research and clinical mode. Results: There was a high variability in obtained SWE values among ultrasound machines, probes, and, in some cases, with depth. Compared to the homogeneous CIRS-background, this variation was more pronounced for the inclusions and the vessel-mimicking phantom. Furthermore, higher stiffnesses were generally underestimated. In the vessel-mimicking phantom, anterior wave velocities were (incorrectly) higher than posterior wave velocities (3.4-5.6 m/s versus 2.9-5.9 m/s, p ≤ 0.005 for 3/4 probes) and remarkably correlated with measurement depth for most machines (Spearman's ρ = -0.873-0.969, p < 0.001 for 3/4 probes). In the Aixplorer's research mode, this difference was smaller (3.3-3.9 m/s versus 3.2-3.6 m/s, p = 0.005) and values did not correlate with measurement depth (Spearman's ρ = 0.039-0.659, p ≥ 0.002). In vivo, wave velocities were higher in the posterior than the anterior vessel wall in research (left p = 0.001, right p < 0.001) but not in clinical mode (left: p = 0.114, right: p = 0.483). Yet, wave velocities correlated with vessel wall depth in clinical (Spearman's ρ = 0.574-0.698, p < 0.001) but not in research mode (Spearman's ρ = -0.080-0.466, p ≥ 0.003). Conclusions: We observed more variation in SWE values among ultrasound machines and probes in tissue with high stiffness and thin-walled geometry than in low stiffness, homogeneous tissue. Together with a depth-correlation in some machines, where carotid arteries have a fixed location, this calls for caution in interpreting SWE results in clinical practice for vascular applications.

Estimating Thrombus Elasticity by Shear Wave Elastography to Evaluate Ultrasound Thrombolysis for Thrombus With Different Stiffness

Effect of pathological heterogeneity on shear wave elasticity imaging in the staging of deep venous thrombosis

Application value of real-time shear wave elastography in the diagnosis and efficacy evaluation of venous thrombosis

Shear wave elastography values of thrombus in patients with lower extremity deep vein thrombosis for pulmonary embolism detection: the ROC analysis

Effect of rt‐PA on Shear Wave Mechanical Assessment and Quantitative Ultrasound Properties of Blood Clot Kinetics In Vitro

Performance evaluation of commercial and non-commercial shear wave elastography implementations for vascular applications

Shear wave elastography for lower extremity deep vein thrombosis

Role of real-time elastography in assessing the stage of thrombus.

Evaluating the stage of deep vein thrombosis: the diagnostic accuracy of shear wave elastography and super-microvascular imaging

A Whole Blood Thrombus Mimic: Constitutive Behavior Under Simple Shear

Assessment of Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography: an Animal Ex-Vivo Study

Effect of Ultrasound on Thrombus debris during Sonothrombolysis in a Microfluidic device

Probing Tissue Viscoelasticity With STL Ultrasound Shearwave Spectroscopy Using Cole-Cole Diagrams

Optimized acoustic streaming generated at oblique incident angles to improve ultrasound thrombolysis effect

Ultrasound elastography predicts anticoagulation in lower extremity deep vein thrombosis

The influence of blood composition and loading frequency on the behavior of embolus analogs

A hyper-viscoelastic uniaxial characterization of collagenous embolus analogs in acute ischemic stroke

A Non-invasive Method to Estimate the Stress-Strain Curve of Soft Tissue Using Ultrasound Elastography

Ultrasound Elastography to Assess Age of Deep Vein Thrombosis: A Systematic Review

Arterial stiffness probed by dynamic ultrasound elastography characterizes waveform of blood pressure

Anthropomorphic Carotid Artery Phantom for Ultrasound Flow and Vessel Wall Elastography Imaging