Abstract:Background: The prehospital care of asthma, bronchiolitis and croup is directed by evidence-based Emergency Medical Services (EMS) protocols. Determining the appropriate intervention for these conditions requires Emergency Medical Technicians-Paramedics (EMT-Ps) to correctly differentiate asthma/bronchospasm, bronchiolitis, and croup. The diagnostic accuracy of EMT-Ps for these pediatric respiratory distress conditions is unknown. Objective: We hypothesized increasing provider age, years of provider experience, higher volume of pediatric cases, self-reported comfort with pediatric patients, and having children of one's own would be associated with increased accuracy in diagnosis on a validated multimedia questionnaire. Methods: This is a cross-sectional study of paramedics from a single EMS agency who completed a validated, case-based questionnaire between July and September 2018. The multimedia questionnaire consisted of four cases, each of which included patient videos and lung sound recordings. Paramedics were asked to assess the severity of distress and ascribe the correct diagnosis and prehospital intervention for each case. Each paramedic completed the questionnaire independently. We defined high questionnaire performance a priori as correctly identifying the diagnosis for ≥75% of cases and used multivariate regression to assess factors associated with high questionnaire performance. Provider age and EMS experience were reported in years and analyzed as continuous variables. Volume of pediatric cases was dichotomized to <1 and ≥1 case per shift and having children was dichotomized to either having children or not having children. Results: Of 514 paramedics, 420 (82%) completed the questionnaire. Overall, paramedics correctly assessed the severity of respiratory distress 92% of the time. However, they only ascribed the correct diagnosis 50% and selected the correct intervention(s) 38% of the time. Increasing age, years of experience, higher volume of pediatric cases, self-reported comfort with pediatric patients, and having children of their own were not associated with questionnaire performance. Conclusion: Paramedics accurately assessed severity of distress in multimedia cases of asthma/bronchospasm, bronchiolitis and croup in children, but showed significant room for improvement in correctly identifying the diagnosis and in selecting appropriate intervention(s). Age, years of EMS experience, higher volume of clinical pediatric cases, self-reported comfort with pediatric patients, and having children of their own were not associated with questionnaire performance.

Clinical Judgment Item Development for Emergency Medical Service Clinicians

Evaluating the Application of an EMS Clinical Judgment Theoretical Framework

Determining Clinical Judgment Among Emergency Nurses During a Complex Simulation

Examining the Reliability and Validity of the ALS Certification Examinations with the Inclusion of Clinical Judgment: An Update on the ALS Examination Redesign

Clinical judgment in new nurse graduates: identifying the gaps

Faculty Development on the Use of a Clinical Judgment Model in the Pre-licensure Nursing Curriculum

Reflective Clinical Judgment Questions to Educate the Next Generation of Nurses

Consensus Standard for Evidence Integration into EMS Education and High-Stakes Testing

Development of a simulation-based curriculum for Pediatric prehospital skills: a mixed-methods needs assessment

Current practices for assessing clinical judgment in nursing students and new graduates: A scoping review

Challenges, opportunities, and priorities for tier-1 emergency medical services (EMS) development in low- and middle-income countries: A modified Delphi-based consensus study among the global prehospital consortium

The Emergency Medicine Group Standardized Letter of Evaluation as a Workplace-based Assessment: The Validity Is in the Detail

[Development of Nursing Clinical Judgment Scale]

Barriers and Facilitators Experienced by Undergraduate Nursing Faculty Teaching Clinical Judgment: A Qualitative Study

Using Simulation to Develop Clinical Judgment in Undergraduate Nursing Students

Creation of a standardized pediatric emergency medicine simulation curriculum for emergency medicine residents

An Historical Examination of the Development of Emergency Medical Services Education in the US through Key Reports (1966-2014)

Developing a Situational Judgement Test to Assess Clinical Judgement in Fourth-Year Medical Students: A Pilot Study

Multimedia Evaluation of EMT-Paramedic Assessment and Management of Pediatric Respiratory Distress

Observed Use of Clinical Judgment Among New Graduate Nurses

A Qualitative Analysis of Barriers to Evidence-Based Care in the Prehospital Management of Patients with Suspected Acute Coronary Syndrome