Abstract:High-dimensional phenotypes hold promise for richer findings in association studies, but testing of several phenotype traits aggravates the grand challenge of association studies, that of multiple testing. Several methods have recently been proposed for testing jointly all traits in a high-dimensional vector of phenotypes, with prospect of increased power to detect small effects that would be missed if tested individually. However, the methods have rarely been compared to the extent of enabling assessment of their relative merits and setting up guidelines on which method to use, and how to use it. We compare the methods on simulated data and with a real metabolomics data set comprising 137 highly correlated variables and approximately 550,000 SNPs. Applying the methods to genome-wide data with hundreds of thousands of markers inevitably requires division of the problem into manageable parts facilitating parallel processing, parts corresponding to individual genetic variants, pathways, or genes, for example. Here we utilize a straightforward formulation according to which the genome is divided into blocks of nearby correlated genetic markers, tested jointly for association with the phenotypes. This formulation is computationally feasible, reduces the number of tests, and lets the methods take advantage of combining information over several correlated variables not only on the phenotype side, but also on the genotype side. Our experiments show that canonical correlation analysis has higher power than alternative methods, while remaining computationally tractable for routine use in the GWAS setting, provided the number of samples is sufficient compared to the numbers of phenotype and genotype variables tested. Sparse canonical correlation analysis and regression models with latent confounding factors show promising performance when the number of samples is small.

Multiple testing in genome-wide association studies via hierarchical hidden Markov models

Large-scale dependent multiple testing via higher-order hidden Markov models

Regression-based Approach for Testing the Association Between Multi-Region Haplotype Configuration and Complex Trait

A multiple testing correction method for genetic association studies using correlated single nucleotide polymorphisms

Bayesian Hierarchical Hypothesis Testing in Large-Scale Genome-Wide Association Analysis

Association Test Between Haplotypes and Longitudinal Traits in Complex Pedigrees.

A high-dimensional omnibus test for set-based association analysis

Multiple-trait Adaptive Fisher's Method for Genome-wide Association Studies

A Non-Parametric Method for Building Predictive Genetic Tests on High-Dimensional Data

Searching Genome-Wide Multi-Locus Associations for Multiple Diseases Based on Bayesian Inference.

A Minimax Optimal Ridge-Type Set Test for Global Hypothesis With Applications in Whole Genome Sequencing Association Studies

Fast and accurate haplotype inference with hidden markov model

Genome-wide association studies with high-dimensional phenotypes

Efficient variant set mixed model association tests for continuous and binary traits in large-scale whole genome sequencing studies

Hierarchical Generalized Linear Mixed Model for Genome-wide Association Analysis

Alternative Methods for H1 Simulations in Genome Wide Association Studies

The eigen higher criticism and eigen Berk-Jones tests for multiple trait association studies based on GWAS summary statistics.

Multiple Testing of Submatrices of a Precision Matrix with Applications to Identification of Between Pathway Interactions

DAM: A Bayesian Method for Detecting Genome-wide Associations on Multiple Diseases.

Multiple Testing in Nonparametric Hidden Markov Models: An Empirical Bayes Approach

Statistical Testing of Shared Genetic Control for Potentially Related Traits