Abstract:Objective: The present clear aligner therapy (CAT) research focuses on isolating and reporting the biomechanical performance for three separate teeth, three translational movements and two flat trimlines at different heights. By identifying key patterns, the research seeks to inform the development of improved aligner designs, ultimately enhancing the effectiveness of clinical orthodontic treatments. Materials and methods: In an in vitro setting using the Orthodontic Force Simulator (OFS), the biomechanical response of 30 aligners was investigated on three different teeth of a straight symmetric maxillary dentition (central incisor, canine and first molar). Each tooth was tested under two flat trimline conditions (trimmed at gingival margin, TL0; extended 2.0 mm below, TL2) and for three types of translational movements (palatal translation, mesial translation and intrusion). Forces and moments were reported at the centre of resistance for each displaced tooth as well as the two neighbouring teeth, evaluating a total of 18 distinct scenarios. Results: Findings indicate significant variability in the biomechanical responses based on tooth location in the arch, trimline height and movement performed. For palatal translations, the palatal force required to perform the movement was observed highest in molar cases, followed by canine and incisor cases, with a notable difference in the distribution of side effects, indicating a strong influence of tooth anatomy and position in the arch. Similarly, in mesial translations and intrusions molars experienced greater forces and moments than the corresponding movements applied on canines and incisors, but uniquely dispersed for each configuration tested. Regarding the shape of the aligner, TL2 consistently showed improved control over orthodontic movements compared to TL0. Neighbouring teeth frequently displayed compensatory reactions up to about half of the intensity observed on the tooth being moved, with notable variations from case to case. Conclusions: This research supports fundamental factors impacting CAT: Characteristic patterns in the direction and intensity of forces and moments are associated with each of the three translational movements tested. Tooth anatomy and arch location significantly influence the biomechanical performance of aligners, with an observed trend for molars to display higher forces and moments over canines and incisors, but distributed differently. The height of a flat trimline, specifically TL2, shows enhanced control over orthodontic movements. Additional findings revealed a compensatory activity of neighbouring teeth, which varies based on tooth region and movement type. It potentially could influence CAT outcomes negatively and merits attention in future investigations. These results support a tailored CAT method that improves aligner design for better force application. This method needs to be used alongside, and confirmed by, clinical knowledge. Future research should extend these findings to a wider range of clinical conditions for greater applicability in the day-to-day orthodontic practice.

In Vitro Comparison of Direct Attachment Shape and Size on the Orthodontic Forces and Moments Generated by Thermoplastic Aligners During Expansion

In Vitro Comparison of Different Invisalign® and 3Shape® Attachment Shapes to Control Premolar Rotation

The mechanical effect of geometric design of attachments in invisible orthodontics

Effect of attachment configuration and trim line design on the force system of orthodontic aligners: A finite element study on the upper central incisor

Experimental Verification of Finite Element Analysis for a Thermoplastic Orthodontic Aligner

Impact of various aligner auxiliaries on orthodontic activity: A systematic review and network meta-analysis

Effects of different tooth movement patterns and aligner thicknesses on maxillary arch expansion with clear aligners: a three-dimensional finite element study

The Effects of Different Attachment Types and Positions on Rotation Movement in Clear Aligner Treatments: A Finite Element Analysis

Force system of 3D-printed orthodontic aligners made of shape memory polymers: an in vitro study

Comparative Experimental Evaluation of Orthodontic Appliances for Maxillary Arch Expansion

Validation of finite-element-simulated orthodontic forces produced by thermoplastic aligners: Effect of aligner geometry and creep

Effect of trimming line design and edge extension of orthodontic aligners on force transmission: An in vitro study

In vitro biomechanics of divot use, and their placement, in orthodontic aligner therapy

Changes in Force Associated with the Amount of Aligner Activation and Lingual Bodily Movement of the Maxillary Central Incisor

Biomechanics of clear aligner therapy: Assessing the influence of tooth position and flat trimline height in translational movements

Effects of Variable Composite Attachment Shapes in Controlling Upper Molar Distalization with Aligners: A Nonlinear Finite Element Study

Force Changes Associated with Different Intrusion Strategies for Deep-Bite Correction by Clear Aligners.

A method for evaluation of the effects of attachments in aligner-type orthodontic appliance: Three-dimensional finite element analysis

In Vitro Investigation Using a New Biomechanical Force–Torque Analysis System: Comparison of Conventional and CAD/CAM-Fixed Orthodontic Retainers

[Measurement of Orthodontic Forces Exerted on the Upper Right Central Incisor with the Increase of the Distance of Tooth Movement and Thickness of the Aligner].

Force Changes Associated with Differential Activation of En-Masse Retraction And/or Intrusion with Clear Aligners