Abstract:In recent years, there has been a surge of interest in community detection algorithms for complex networks. A variety of computational heuristics, some with a long history, have been proposed for the identification of communities or, alternatively, of good graph partitions. In most cases, the algorithms maximize a particular objective function, thereby finding the `right' split into communities. Although a thorough comparison of algorithms is still lacking, there has been an effort to design benchmarks, i.e., random graph models with known community structure against which algorithms can be evaluated. However, popular community detection methods and benchmarks normally assume an implicit notion of community based on clique-like subgraphs, a form of community structure that is not always characteristic of real networks. Specifically, networks that emerge from geometric constraints can have natural non clique-like substructures with large effective diameters, which can be interpreted as long-range communities. In this work, we show that long-range communities escape detection by popular methods, which are blinded by a restricted `field-of-view' limit, an intrinsic upper scale on the communities they can detect. The field-of-view limit means that long-range communities tend to be overpartitioned. We show how by adopting a dynamical perspective towards community detection (Delvenne et al. (2010) PNAS:107: 12755-12760; Lambiotte et al. (2008) <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="0812.1770" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/0812.1770">arXiv:0812.1770</a>), in which the evolution of a Markov process on the graph is used as a zooming lens over the structure of the network at all scales, one can detect both clique- or non clique-like communities without imposing an upper scale to the detection. Consequently, the performance of algorithms on inherently low-diameter, clique-like benchmarks may not always be indicative of equally good results in real networks with local, sparser connectivity.

An upper bound on community size in scalable community detection

Resolution limit in community detection

Community Detection via Maximization of Modularity and Its Variants

Automatic detection of multilevel communities: scalable and resolution-limit-free

Multiple Resolution Community Structure Analysis

Uncovering the Effective Interval of Resolution Parameter Across Multiple Community Optimization Measures

Limitation of multi-resolution methods in community detection

Markov dynamics as a zooming lens for multiscale community detection: non clique-like communities and the field-of-view limit

Scalable Community Discovery of Large Networks

A Sparse Completely Positive Relaxation of the Modularity Maximization for Community Detection.

Think Locally, Act Locally: The Detection of Small, Medium-Sized, and Large Communities in Large Networks

Community detection in complex networks using extremal optimization modularity density

Fast multi-scale detection of overlapping communities using local criteria

Module Detection in Complex Networks Using Integer Optimisation

A compression optimization algorithm for community detection

Scalable detection of statistically significant communities and hierarchies, using message-passing for modularity

Searching Graph Communities by Modularity Maximization Via Convex Optimization.

Seeding the Kernels in Graphs: Toward Multi-Resolution Community Analysis

Community Detection Based On Minimum-Cut Graph Partitioning

Global vs local modularity for network community detection

Maximal size constraint community search over bipartite graphs