Abstract:We compare three available models of graphene conductivity: a non-local Kubo model, a local model derived by Falkovsky, and finally a non-local Quantum Field Theory based (QFT-b) model. The first two models are extensively used in the nanophotonic community. All these models are not ab-initio since they contain phenomenological parameters (like Fermi velocity, chemical potential and/or mass gap parameters that depend on the chosen material and possibly on external perturbations), and are supposed to provide coherent results since they are derived from the same starting Hamiltonian. While we confirm that the local model is a proper limit of the non-local Kubo model, we find some inconsistencies in the QFT-b model as derived and used in the literature. In particular, differently from the Kubo model, the QFT-b model shows a plasma-like behavior for the interband transversal conductivity at low frequencies instead of the expected behavior (an almost constant conductivity as a function of frequency $\omega$ with a gap for frequencies $\hbar\omega < \sqrt{(\hbar v_{F}q)^{2} + 4m^{2}}$). We show how to correctly regularize the QFT-b model in order to satisfy the gauge invariance and, once also losses are correctly included, we show that the Kubo and QFT-b model exactly coincide. Our finding can be of relevant interest for both theory, predictions and experimental tests in both the nanophotonic and Casimir effect communities.

On the universal ac optical background in graphene

Quantum Hall Effect in Ac Driven Graphene: from the Half-Integer to the Integer Case

Theoretical Analysis Of The Density Of States Of Graphene At High Magnetic Fields Using Haldane Pseudopotentials

Transport of Dirac quasiparticles in graphene: Hall and optical conductivities

Universal conductivity of graphene in the ultrarelativistic regime

Dynamic Conductivity of Graphene in a Terahertz AC Electric Field

High-energy optical conductivity of graphene determined by reflection contrast spectroscopy

Resonant scattering by realistic impurities in graphene.

Universal Thermoelectric Effect Of Dirac Fermions In Graphene

Kramers-Kronig Relation of Graphene Conductivity

Optical conductivity in graphene: hydrodynamic regime

Vertical absorption edge and universal onset conductance in semi-hydrogenated graphene

Phonon Thermal Conduction in Graphene

Drude Conductivity of Dirac Fermions in Graphene

Ultrabroadband THz Conductivity of Gated Graphene In- and Out-of-equilibrium

Conformity Experiment on Inelastic Scattering Exponent of Electrons in Two Dimensions

Graphene conductivity: Kubo model versus QFT-based model

AC Conductance Through a Vibrating Molecular Dot in Kondo Regime

Optoelectronic Properties of Graphene in the Presence of Optical Phonon Scattering

Investigation of transport properties of graphene Dirac fluid by holographic two-current axion coupling model

Optical Conductivity Spectrum in a Conventional Two-Dimensional Electron Gas and Graphene