Abstract:Classical design procedures are less advantageous than performance-based seismic design (PBSD) of buildings, which is included in existing standards such as ASCE 41-23 for new buildings or retrofitting. PBSD requires accurate assessment of building seismic responses. Such assessments can be done using either faster nonlinear static procedures (NSPs) or more time-intensive nonlinear time-history analyses (NTHAs). However, the reliability of NSPs can be questionable, as shown by previous research. Practitioners need to conduct further investigations to determine safety margins and the applicability scope of these methods. This is especially important for irregular buildings and near-fault zones. This problem is investigated in this paper by first using 1250 single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) systems to evaluate the ASCE 41-23’s coefficient method and performing 25000 NTHAs for near- and far-fault records. Second, the responses obtained from two alternative approaches, the modal pushover analysis (MPA) and FEMA 440’s capacity spectrum method (CSM), are compared with NTHA responses for buildings with significant higher-mode effects. American standards are used to design 96 3D symmetric and asymmetric steel moment-resisting frame (MRF) buildings with different characteristics such as lateral, lateral-torsional, and torsional modes of vibration dominance as well as different stability conditions, which are considered in this paper. The MPA and CSM are compared with NTHAs in this paper. The results show that the ASCE 41-23’s coefficient method is unreliable for near-fault zones and that the MPA and CSM are unreliable for seismic evaluation of buildings with dominant lateral-torsional modes of vibration or significant P-Δ effects. The results also revealed that MPA is a conservative approach for seismic evaluation of torsionally dominant buildings while CSM is not.

Performance evaluation of existing building structure with pushover analysis

Research on the Guarantee Rate and Suitability of Pushover Analysis Method for Reinforced Concrete Frame Structure

Performance Assessment of Multi-story Building

Pushover Analysis of Multi-Story Reinforced Concrete Frame Structure

Non-Linear Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Frame Structure with Vertical Irregularities

Performance Structural Analysis of U2C Building with the Kobe Earthquake Spectrum

Performance based study on the seismic safety of buildings

Numerical Simulation and Analysis of a Pushover of a Full-Scale Two-Story Model

Review on Recent developments in the performance-based seismic design of reinforced concrete structures

Seismic assessment and strengthening of a RC building using pushover analysis

Bidirectional Pushover Analysis of Irregular Structures

Pushover Analysis of Underground Structures: Method and Application

Evaluation of Modal and Traditional Pushover Analyses in Frame-Shear-Wall Structures

Nonlinear analysis of reinforced concrete buildings with different heights and floor systems

Preliminary Seismic Performance-based Evaluation of Academic Reinforced Concrete Building in Yogyakarta based on Displacement Parameter

Modal Pushover Analysis for Seismic Performance Assessment of Underground Structures

Performance-Based Optimization of 2D Reinforced Concrete Moment Frames through Pushover Analysis and ABC Optimization Algorithm

A Critical Evaluation of the Coefficient Method, Capacity Spectrum Method and Modal Pushover Analysis for Irregular Steel Buildings in Seismic Zones

Pushover analysis on a typical steel industrial plant

A methodological approach for seismic performance of existing single-storey industrial RC precast facilities

A pushover seismic analysis method for asymmetric and tall buildings