Comparison of BioFire FilmArray gastrointestinal panel versus Luminex xTAG Gastrointestinal Pathogen Panel (xTAG GPP) for diarrheal pathogen detection in China

Zhifei Zhan,Jiayin Guo,Yong Xiao,Zixiang He,Xin Xia,Zheng Huang,Hongxia Guan,Xia Ling,Jie Li,Baowei Diao,Hongqun Zhao,Biao Kan,Jingyun Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijid.2020.08.020
IF: 12.073
2020-10-01
International Journal of Infectious Diseases
Abstract:<h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Objectives</h3><p>To compare the performance of two syndromic panels, one is Luminex xTAG Gastrointestinal Pathogen Panel (GPP) and the other is FilmArray Gastrointestinal (GI) Panel.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Methods</h3><p>243 diarrhea specimens were detected by two panels in parallel, and the inconsistent results were analyzed by real-time PCR or reverse transcription PCR (RT-PCR). We examined the target concentration in specimens by comparing the crossing point (Cp) values of FilmArray, the median fluorescence intensity (MFI) of xTAG, and the cycle threshold (Ct) values in the discrepant analysis.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Results</h3><p>For pathogens detected by both panels, the positive rates of FilmArray GI and xTAG GPP were 65.0% and 48.6%, respectively. The two panels showed high consistency (<em>kappa</em>≥0.74) in detecting norovirus, rotavirus, and <em>Campylobacter</em>, while low consistency (<em>kappa</em>≤0.40) in detecting <em>Cryptosporidium</em>, <em>Salmonella</em>, Shiga toxin-producing <em>Escherichia coli</em> (STEC) and enterotoxigenic <em>E. coli</em> (ETEC). Samples with low concentration targets were more often detected by FilmArray than with xTAG GPP. The xTAG GPP was more likely to be affected by amplification inhibitors. Also, several defects of xTAG GPP were found in detecting ETEC.</p><h3 class="u-h4 u-margin-m-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Conclusions</h3><p>FilmArray was more sensitive; and for specimens with low target concentrations or specimens containing ETEC-ST, the false negatives of xTAG GPP need to be concerned.</p>
infectious diseases
What problem does this paper attempt to address?