Abstract:Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate and compare the accuracy and inter-operator reliability of a low-cost red -green-blue-depth (RGB-D) camera-based facial scanner (Bellus3D Arc7) with a stereophotogrammetry facial scanner (3dMD) and to explore the possibility of the former as a clinical substitute for the latter.Methods: A mannequin head was selected as the research object. In the RGB-D camera-based facial scanner group, the head was continuously scanned five times using an RGB-D camera-based facial scanner (Bellus3D Arc7), and the outcome data of each scan was then imported into CAD software (MeshLab) to reconstruct three-dimensional (3D) facial photographs. In the stereophotogrammetry facial scanner group, the mannequin head was scanned with a stereophotogrammetry facial scanner (3dMD). Selected parameters were directly measured on the reconstructed 3D virtual faces using a CAD software. The same parameters were then measured directly on the mannequin head using the direct anthropometry (DA) method as the gold standard for later comparison. The accuracy of the facial scanners was evaluated in terms of trueness and precision. Trueness was evaluated by comparing the measurement results of the two groups with each other and with that of DA using equivalence tests and average absolute deviations, while precision and inter-operator reliability were assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). A 3D facial mesh deviation between the two groups was also calculated for further reference using a 3D metrology software (GOM inspect pro).Results: In terms of trueness, the average absolute deviations between RGB-D camera-based and stereo-photogrammetry facial scanners, between RGB-D camera-based facial scanner and DA, and between stereo-photogrammetry facial scanner and DA were statistically equivalent at 0.50 +/- 0.27 mm, 0.61 +/- 0.42 mm, and 0.28 +/- 0.14 mm, respectively. Equivalence test results confirmed that their equivalence was within clinical re-quirements (<1 mm). The ICC for each parameter was approximately 0.999 in terms of precision and inter -operator reliability. A 3D facial mesh analysis suggested that the deviation between the two groups was 0.37 +/- 0.01 mm.Conclusions: For facial scanners, an accuracy of <1 mm is commonly considered clinically acceptable. Both the RGB-D camera-based and stereophotogrammetry facial scanners in this study showed acceptable trueness, high precision, and inter-operator reliability. A low-cost RGB-D camera-based facial scanner could be an eligible clinical substitute for traditional stereophotogrammetry.Clinical Significance: The low-cost RGB-D camera-based facial scanner showed clinically acceptable trueness, high precision, and inter-operator reliability; thus, it could be an eligible clinical substitute for traditional stereophotogrammetry.

The Precision, Inter-Rater Reliability, and Accuracy of a Handheld Scanner Equipped with a Light Detection and Ranging Sensor in Measuring Parts of the Body—A Preliminary Validation Study

Feasibility of Using Laser Imaging Detection and Ranging Technology for Contactless 3D Body Scanning and Anthropometric Assessment of Athletes

Accuracy, Repeatability, and Reproducibility of a Hand-Held Structured-Light 3D Scanner across Multi-Site Settings in Lower Limb Prosthetics

The Introduction of a New Diagnostic Tool in Forensic Pathology: LiDAR Sensor for 3D Autopsy Documentation

Virtual anthropology? Reliability of three-dimensional photogrammetry as a forensic anthropology measurement and documentation technique

A detailed study on human height estimation model that combines video surveillance systems with 3D laser scanning

Translating digital anthropometry measurements obtained from different 3D body image scanners

Accuracy of Three-dimensional Scan Technology and Its Possible Function in the Field of Hand Surgery

Accuracy of RGB-D Camera-Based and Stereophotogrammetric Facial Scanners: a Comparative Study.

Photogrammetry vs CT Scan: Evaluation of Accuracy of a Low-Cost Three-Dimensional Acquisition Method for Forensic Facial Approximation

Reliability and validity of handheld structured light scanners and a static stereophotogrammetry system in facial three-dimensional surface imaging

Refraction Effect Analysis of Using A Hand-Held Laser Scanner with Glass Support for 3d Anthropometric Measurement of the Hand: A Theoretical Study

Mobile phone applications for 3-dimensional scanning and digital anthropometry: a precision comparison with traditional scanners

Trueness of One Stationary and Two Mobile Systems for Three-Dimensional Facial Scanning

Comparison of two 3D scanning software to identify facial features: a prospective instrument to predict difficult airway

Intra-rater and inter-rater reliability of 3D facial measurements

Accuracy of a Hand-Held 3D Imaging System for Child Anthropometric Measurements in Population-Based Household Surveys and Surveillance Platforms: an Effectiveness Validation Study in Guatemala, Kenya, and China.

Shapeshift 3D Repair TM – A fully Automated and Unsupervised Cloud API for the Reliable Reconstruction of Raw 3D Surface Scans Data

The accuracy (trueness and precision) of Bellus3DARC-7 and an in-vivo analysis of intra and inter-examiner reliability of digital and manual anthropometry

Initial validation of point cloud data from a 3D body scanner

The Validity of a Smartphone-Based Method for Acquiring 3D Images of the Face