Abstract:Deviations between batteries in series appear gradually and increase with the number of cycles. This inconsistency reduces the lifetime of battery packs, increases the cost of using them, and may lead to security issues. Equalization is an important means of reducing battery differences. The relevant research has focused on the design of equalization circuits and the improvement of equalizer efficiency while neglecting a comparative analysis of methods of equalization on the performance of battery packs, which hinders technicians from making the correct choice during application. A quantitative analysis is provided in this paper to compare the effects of methods of equalization on reducing the differences among batteries. Multiple parameters are introduced to describe differences among equalization methods, and the results indicated that equalization worked only at appropriate current rates and failed at large ones. With the same current rate in charging and discharging, the relative equalization time of active equalization was shorter than that of hybrid equalization. Active equalization was better than passive equalization in reducing battery capacity differences. The maximum difference in state of charges among batteries with active equalization at a current rate of 0.25 C decreased from 10% to 9.207% in discharging, while that with passive equalization dropped from 10% to 9.492%. Therefore, active equalization was suitable for short period charge and discharge. Moreover, the values of the equalization current of the equalization methods were similar, but the effect of hybrid equalization on reducing the differences among batteries was more significant. The average hybrid equalization current was 0.073 A larger than the average active equalization current. However, the capacity of the battery pack with hybrid equalization was 0.369 Ah higher than that with active equalization. Hybrid equalization was more conducive to the regular maintenance of the battery pack. In the life cycle of the battery pack, an equalization management mode of "single-cycle active equalization + hybrid equalization regular maintenance" could be introduced. On this basis, fast equalization within a single cycle could be achieved and consistency among cells during long-term cycling could be guaranteed. This study provides a scientific basis for engineering practice and helps choose an appropriate method of equalization.

Equalization method of ‘LiCoxNiyMn1-x-yO2 - LiFePO4’ hybrid battery pack based on charging electric quantity estimation

Equalisation Strategy for Serially Connected LiFePO 4 Battery Cells

Performance and Comparison of Equalization Methods for Lithium Ion Batteries in Series

Active Equalization Strategy for Lithium-Ion Battery Packs Based on Multilayer Dual Interleaved Inductor Circuits in Electric Vehicles

Hybrid equalization scheme for a lithium‐ion battery pack based on a three‐winding transformer

On-line Equalization for Lithium-Ion Battery Packs Based on Charging Cell Voltages: Part 1. Equalization Based on Remaining Charging Capacity Estimation

Multiple time scale state-of-charge and capacity-based equalisation strategy for lithium-ion battery pack with passive equaliser

Equalization Control Strategy and SOC Estimation for LiFePO4 Battery Pack

A Novel Active Equalization Method for Lithium-Ion Batteries in Electric Vehicles

Development of an Optimized Algorithm for Bidirectional Equalization in Lithium-Ion Batteries

Active Equalization for Lithium Batteries Combined Cell Voltage with State of Charge

Lithium-ion Battery Pack Equalization Based on Charging Voltage Curves

On‐line Equalization for Lithium Iron Phosphate Battery Packs Based on Voltage Threshold Integral

On-line equalization for lithium-ion battery packs based on charging cell voltages: Part 2. Fuzzy logic equalization

Equalization Design of Series Connected Li-ion Battery Pack Based on Microcontroller

Fuzzy Logic Control-Based Charge/Discharge Equalization Method for Lithium-Ion Batteries

An any-cell(s)-to-cell(s) equalization method with a single magnetic component for Lithium-ion battery pack

Effects analysis on active equalization control of lithium-ion batteries based on intelligent estimation of the state-of-charge

Module-Based Active Equalization for Battery Packs: A Two-Layer Model Predictive Control Strategy

High-performance lithium-ion battery equalization strategy for energy storage system

A novel double-layer active equalization scheme for lithium-ion batteries combining wireless power transfer