Energy Efficiency at a Small Wastewater Treatment Plant: Use of Variable Frequency Drives to Control Aeration Blowers
M. Springman,Dan Marsch
2013-12-01
Abstract:This fact sheet identifi es the energy savings realized at a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) in Pana, Illinois. The Pana WWTP went on line in 1986 to process sanitary wastewater from its 5,500 residents. Its design capacity is 3.3 million gallons per day (MGD) with a daily operating load of 1.7 MGD. Wanting to cut operating costs, the plant supervisor requested ISTC’s assistance in identifying energy effi ciency opportunities that would not interfere with the waste treatment process. Signifi cant energy savings were identifi ed by the installation of variable frequency drives (VFDs) on three 75 horsepower Hoffmann Blowers. Project Overview ISTC made a presentation on the Illinois Conservation of Resources and Energy (ICORE) program to pollution control operators at a meeting of the Mid-Central Water Pollution Control Operators Association (MCWPCO). After the meeting, Kent Taylor, the Pana WWTP operator, asked to have an assessment of his facility to identify opportunities to reduce the electricity consumption within his plant. Previously, the city had installed VFDs on the main pumps of the water treatment plant and on the infl uent pumps at the wastewater treatment plant. Mike Springman of ISTC, and Tom Ellegood, of Illinois Electric Works (IEW), an ICORE vendor-stakeholder, conducted an assessment of the facility and presented to the city the recommendation to install VFDs on the blowers at the WWTP. Variable frequency drives were installed on the three 75 HP Hoffmann centrifugal blowers which fed into a common header. A load balancer was also installed to control the blowers enabling them to work in harmony, saving additional energy. Operations ̶ Before the VFD Installation The plant operated two of the three 75 HP Hoffman blowers simultaneously, 24 hours, 7 days per week. The blowers operated at 100% speed while the air fl ow was reduced by a mechanical valve set at 80% fl ow in order to achieve the desired level of dissolved oxygen within the oxidation ditch. These blowers consumed 850,423 kilowatt hours (kWh) of electricity in a nine-month period (A ninemonth period was used to coincide with the nine-month period after installation). Figure 1: Hoffmann Blowers at Pana WWTP Operations ̶ Aft er the VFD Installation Th e 75 HP Hoff man blowers are still operated two at a time 24/7 and still maintain the same dissolved oxygen levels within the oxidation ditch. Th e diff erence is that the mechanical valve is now fully open and a VFD controls motor speeds and air fl ow. Th e blower motors now run at 80 percent speed to produce the same volume of air. Th is speed reduction results in the blowers operating slower with no impediment (valve) in the distribution system. Th e blower motors operate at cooler temperatures that will extend the life of the motors. Motor startup will be slower and smoother, eliminating higher amperage inrush and will reduce motor and starter wear and tear. Aft er the VFD installation, these blowers consumed 708,505 kWh in a similar nine-month period. Results Th e Hoff mann blowers operate two at a time, 24/7, with the VFD controlling them at 80 percent capacity. Nine months have passed since the VFD installation. Th e electric use for a nine month period prior to the VFD installation was compared to the corresponding ninemonth period aft er the VFD installation. A comparison of the before and aft er nine-month scenarios identifi ed a reduction of 141, 918 kWh, or 16.7 percent in electricity. Figure 2: VFD Control Panel showing electricity consumption and performance after installation Supplemental Materials The Theory behind VFDs and Load Balancing Affi nity Laws and Variable Frequency Drives Fan, pump and blower power consumption is equal to the cube of the speed. Two times the speed will consume eight times (23) the power. Speed is expensive. Th e penalty for running a motor faster than necessary is severe. Conversely, one-half the speed requires one-eighth (0.53) the power to drive a fan, pump or blower (see Table 1). Th is means signifi cant energy savings are available by reducing motor speed. A variable frequency drive (VFD), also known as an adjustable speed drive (ASD), is a system that controls the rotational speed of an alternating current (AC) electric motor by controlling the frequency of the electrical power supplied to the motor (Figure 3). It converts incoming 60Hz AC power into other desired frequencies, which allows for AC motor speed control. VFDs enhance process control and provide energy savings by matching motor speed with load requirements. Pump, fan and blower applications at water and wastewater facilities are excellent candidates for retrofi ts because VFDs match motor speeds to fl uctuating loads at these facilities, which is more economical than running motors at a constant speed. Figure 3: Variable Frequency Drive TN13-105
Environmental Science,Engineering