Abstract:Within the framework of modified gravity (MG), the quasi-static (QS) and sub-horizon (SH) approximations are widely used in analyses aiming to identify departures from the concordance model at late-times. In general, it is assumed that time derivatives are subdominant with respect to spatial derivatives given that the relevant physical modes are those well inside the Hubble radius. In practice, the perturbation equations under these approximations are reduced to a tractable algebraic system in terms of the gravitational potentials and the perturbations of involved matter fields. Here, in the framework of $f(R)$ theories, we revisit standard results when these approximations are invoked using a new parameterization scheme that allows us to track the relevance of each time-derivative term in the perturbation equations. This new approach unveils terms which are neglected in the standard procedure. We assess the relevance of these differences by comparing results from both approaches against full numerical solutions for two well-known toy-models: the designer $f(R)$ model and the Hu-Sawicki model. We find that: i) the SH approximation can be safely applied to linear perturbation equations for scales $0.06 h/$Mpc $\lesssim k \lesssim 0.2 h/$Mpc, ii) in this "safety region", the QS approximation provides a very accurate description of the late-time cosmological dynamics even when dark energy significantly contribute to the cosmic budget, and iii) our new methodology performs better than the standard procedure, even for several orders of magnitude in some cases. Although, the impact of this major improvement on the linear observables is minimal for the studied cases, this does not represent an invalidation for our approach. Instead, our findings indicate that the perturbation expressions derived under these approximations in more general MG theories, such as Horndeski, should be also revisited.

Non-Linear Approximations to Gravitational Instability: A Comparison in Second-Order Perturbation Theory

Beyond Zel'dovich-Type Approximations in Gravitational Instability Theory --- Padé Prescription in Spheroidal Collapse ---

Fully nonlinear gravitational instabilities for expanding Newtonian universes with inhomogeneous pressure and entropy: Beyond the Tolman's solution

Fully nonlinear gravitational instabilities for expanding spherical symmetric Newtonian universes with inhomogeneous density and pressure

Theoretical Accuracy in Cosmological Growth Estimation

Nonperturbative collapse models for collisionless self-gravitating flows

Zeldovich flow on cosmic vacuum background: new exact nonlinear analytical solution

Second-order perturbation theory: Problems on large scales

Gravitational instability of the inner static region of a Reissner-Nordstrom black hole

Second-order perturbations of the Schwarzschild spacetime: practical, covariant and gauge-invariant formalisms

Tracking the validity of the quasi-static and sub-horizon approximations in modified gravity

The Post-Quasi-Static Approximation: An Analytical Approach to Gravitational Collapse

Second-order perturbations of the Schwarzschild spacetime: Practical, covariant, and gauge-invariant formalisms

Nonlinear Structure Formation, Backreaction and Weak Gravitational Fields

Nonlinear Evolution of Quadratic Gravity in 3+1 Dimensions

More Nonlinearities? II. A Short Guide of First- and Second-Order Electromagnetic Perturbations in the Schwarzschild Background

Nonlinear studies of modifications to general relativity: Comparing different approaches

Past instability of FLRW solutions of the Einstein-Euler-scalar field equations for linear equations of state with

Past instability of FLRW solutions of the Einstein-Euler-scalar field equations for linear equations of state $p=Kρ$ with $0 \leq K<1/3$

Coarse-Grained Cosmological Perturbation Theory