Abstract:The 2015 Paris Agreement is falling short of its aspirations, as signatory countries are struggling to implement the policies required to meet the targets. The global scenario framework formed by the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs) and the Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) places little emphasis on the dynamics of climate policy implementation. Social science approaches to understanding these dynamics are not well-integrated into climate scenario research. We apply an implementation research approach to analyse the transition to clean energy in the US and China, as well as two examples from Europe – Germany and Spain – which have shown markedly diverging implementation trajectories. We propose four implementation scenarios (ISs) for clean energy worldwide which relate to different configurations of actors in the policy system. These are: (1) Civil Society Takes Control (IS1) – where ideologically opposed governments are marginalised by citizens and forward-thinking investors; (2) Strong-arm Transition (IS2) – where a single party state drives the transition without the involvement of civil society; (3) Systemic Limits (IS3) – which highlights the need to focus on the whole energy system, not just renewables; and (4) Renewable Austerity (IS4) – where an economic downturn offers powerful anti-transition actors the opportunity to advocate removal of support for climate mitigation, as they did after the 2007–2008 financial crisis. This scenario could be repeated as countries seek to recover from the Covid-19 pandemic. Our study offers a framework for structured analysis of real-world constraints faced by implementing actors, which we argue is urgently needed to help national and international policy makers achieve climate goals. Key policy insights The world is struggling to implement the Paris Agreement, partly because the complex dynamics of climate policy implementation are poorly understood.Social science approaches to understanding these dynamics are not well-integrated into climate scenario research.Implementation research focussing on the actors and context provides a useful framework for analysis of implementation efforts from major global carbon emitters.The approach offers new and distinctive scenario narratives that go beyond Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) and Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs).These new scenarios can help policy makers evaluate likely outcomes of climate policy implementation based on information about actors and context.

Aligning integrated assessment modelling with socio-technical transition insights: An application to low-carbon energy scenario analysis in Europe

Greenhouse Gas Abatement in EUROPE—A Scenario-Based, Bottom-Up Analysis Showing the Effect of Deep Emission Mitigation on the European Energy System

Modeling the transition of the multimodal pan-European energy system including an integrated analysis of electricity and gas transport

Integrating modelling-based and stakeholder-focused scenario approaches to close the planning gap and accelerate low-carbon transitions

The many faces of heating transitions. Deeper understandings of future systems in Sweden and beyond

Why energy models should integrate social and environmental factors: Assessing user needs, omission impacts, and real-word accuracy in the European Union

Scenario Analysis for Net Zero: The Applicability of Climate Neutrality Studies for Transitioning Firms in the German Building Sector and Energy-Intensive Industry

Building the Bridge: How System Dynamics Models Operationalise Energy Transitions and Contribute towards Creating an Energy Policy Toolbox

Beyond shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs) and representative concentration pathways (RCPs): climate policy implementation scenarios for Europe, the US and China

Is Europe prepared to live without emissions? A dynamic analysis of the energy transition in economic sectors

Technology availability, sector policies and behavioral change are complementary strategies for achieving net-zero emissions

Creating Agent-Based Energy Transition Management Models That Can Uncover Profitable Pathways to Climate Change Mitigation

Trends in tools and approaches for modelling the energy transition

A review of socio-technical energy transition (STET) models

Comparing energy system optimization models and integrated assessment models: Relevance for energy policy advice

Reducing energy demand through low carbon innovation: A sociotechnical transitions perspective and thirteen research debates

Combining the multi-level perspective framework with participatory scenario development to explore the many facets of food system transitions in Germany

Explaining energy transition: A systemic social mechanisms approach illustrated with the examples of Germany and Poland

A Combined Multi-Level Perspective and Agent-Based Modeling in Low-Carbon Transition Analysis

Multi-Objective Optimization Model EPLANopt for Energy Transition Analysis and Comparison with Climate-Change Scenarios

What's worse, communism or carbon? Using the Transitions Delphi approach to identify viable interventions for the Estonian energy transition