Spatial and Ontogenetic Trophic Dynamics of Co-occurring Predatory Fishes in a Northern Gulf of Mexico Estuary

Livernois, Mariah C.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12237-024-01361-8

2024-04-25

Estuaries and Coasts

Abstract:Co-occurring predators often exhibit ecological niche partitioning, resulting from competition over evolutionary time. However, in productive estuarine ecosystems with high resource availability, predators may occupy similar niches without conflict. Determining the degree of niche partitioning and overlap among co-occurring predators can provide insights into a food web's function and its potential resiliency to perturbations. This study used stable isotope analysis to assess the trophic ecology of four predators in Galveston Bay, Texas, USA: spotted seatrout, black drum, bull shark, and alligator gar. Spatially distinct primary producer isotopic ratios emerged for both δ 13 C and δ 15 N following salinity regimes, which translated to similar patterns in predator tissue. The volume and overlap among species' trophic niches also varied spatially, with species-specific expansion and contraction of niches across the freshwater-marine continuum. The observed niche patterns were likely related to movements, with implications for trophic coupling across the estuarine landscape. Using regional delineations for baseline values yielded trophic position estimates that were validated by compound-specific stable isotopes and were similar (3.77 to 3.96) for all species but black drum (3.25). Trophic position increased with body length for all species but black drum, and these relationships differed when using estuary-wide versus regionally distinct baselines. Alligator gar gut contents were examined, which primarily aligned with piscivory but also included previously unreported taxa (insect, mammal). Collectively, these results provide evidence for spatial and ontogenetic shifts in trophic ecology within this predator assemblage and highlight the importance of spatial scale when using stable isotopes to examine estuarine food webs.

environmental sciences,marine & freshwater biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: the spatial and ontogenetic - stage trophic - ecological dynamics of four co - existing predatory fish species (spotted sea bass, black drum, bull shark and alligator gar) in the Galveston Bay ecosystem in the northern Gulf of Mexico. Specifically, the study uses stable isotope analysis methods to evaluate the degree of niche separation and overlap among these predators, as well as their changes with spatial location and ontogenetic stage. The study aims to reveal the functions of these predators in the food web and their potential resilience to environmental perturbations.

### Research Background
- **Ecosystem Characteristics**: Estuaries are one of the most productive ecosystems on Earth, and their complex trophic networks are driven by nutrient inputs from natural and anthropogenic sources.
- **Predator Co - existence**: Many predator species share habitats and food resources in the same estuary. In order to reduce competition pressure, different species may develop a certain degree of niche separation during the evolution process.
- **Resource Richness**: In the resource - rich estuary ecosystem, predators may occupy similar niches without conflict.
- **Niche Separation and Overlap**: Determining the degree of niche separation and overlap among co - existing predators can provide insights into the function of the food web and its potential resilience to perturbations.

### Research Objectives
1. **Spatial Pattern**: Use stable isotope analysis to evaluate the spatial patterns of baseline and predator isotope ratios of the four predators in Galveston Bay.
2. **Niche Area and Overlap**: Use Bayesian mixing models to estimate source contributions and describe the trophic niche areas and overlap degrees among different species.
3. **Trophic Level Estimation**: Use stable isotope analysis and compound - specific stable isotope analysis (CSIA - AA) to estimate the trophic level of each species.
4. **Ontogenetic - stage Changes**: Examine potential ontogenetic - stage trophic - level changes.

### Methods
- **Sample Collection**: Collected 30 individual samples of each predator from the fall of 2020 and the spring of 2021.
- **Stable Isotope Analysis**: Conduct carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) stable isotope analysis on muscle tissues.
- **Compound - Specific Stable Isotope Analysis**: Conduct amino - acid - specific stable isotope analysis on some samples.
- **Statistical Analysis**: Use ANOVA and Tukey's post hoc test to analyze the spatial and seasonal differences in isotope ratios. Use Bayesian mixing models to estimate the contribution proportion of basal resources and calculate the trophic level.

### Key Formulas
- **Stable Isotope Ratio**:
\[
\delta X=\left(\frac{R_{\text{sample}}}{R_{\text{standard}}}-1\right)\times1000
\]
where \(R_{\text{sample}}\) is the ratio of heavy isotopes to light isotopes in the sample, and \(R_{\text{standard}}\) is the ratio in the international standard.

- **Trophic Level Estimation (CSIA - AA)**:
\[
\text{TP} = 1+\frac{\delta^{15}N_{\text{ind}}-\sum(\delta^{15}N_{\text{source}}\times\text{mean \% cont}_{\text{source}})}{\Delta\delta^{15}N}
\]
where \(\Delta\delta^{15}N = 3.3\) ‰, \(\delta^{15}N_{\text{ind}}\) is the nitrogen isotope value of an individual consumer, \(\delta^{15}N_{\text{source}}\) is the nitrogen isotope value of each basal resource group, and \(\text{mean \% cont}_{\text{source}}\) is the average contribution proportion of each basal resource group to the consumer's diet.

- **Trophic Level Estimation (SIA)**:
\[
\text{TP}=\lambda+\frac{\delta^