Abstract:It is well known that big fish eat small fish, but how does it change that relationship in 3D environments (the sea) versus 2D (bottom of the sea) environments is not clear. The role of dimensionality of predator search space and feeding strategies (crabs vs. snails) are critical. Disentangling the determinants of trophic structure is central to ecology. The capacity to capture subjugate and consume a prey (i.e. gape limitation) is a relevant limitation to acquire energy for most organisms, especially those in smaller size ranges. This generates a size hierarchy of trophic positions in which large organisms consume small ones. Body size is tightly correlated to gape limitation and explains a large fraction of variance in the body size‐trophic position relationship. However, a considerable fraction of variance still remains to be explained. Consumer search space dimensionality (2D or 3D) and feeding strategies, temperature and the size structure of primary producers can alter the trophic structure, but tests based on information from natural food webs are scarce. We generated specific predictions about the body size trophic position relationship and evaluated them using information from a subtropical South Atlantic coastal marine ecosystem: benthic realm (2D, rocky shore and sandy beach) and the pelagic realm (3D). We characterized this marine coastal food web based on stable isotopes of carbon and nitrogen from 256 samples from primary producers (macroalgae and phytoplankton) to large predators (sand shark) in summer and winter. Consumer body size encompassed six orders of magnitude in weight from 10−2 to 6 × 104 g. Isotopic signal corresponded to an integration of carbon sources from basal consumers to top predators. The body size‐trophic position relationship showed a linear positive association with different slopes for the benthic and pelagic environments. This implies a smaller predator prey size ratio for pelagic (3D) with respect to benthic consumers (2D) as theoretically expected. No seasonal differences were found in slopes and most of the overall variance in benthic environments was largely explained by feeding strategies of the different taxonomic groups. We provide an integrated evaluation on the role of body size, consumer search space and feeding strategy to understand the determinants of trophic position. Results demonstrate that integrating gape limitation hypothesis, the dimensionality of consumer search space and feeding strategies into a formal robust framework to understand trophic structure is feasible even in complex natural ecosystems. Resumen Identificar los determinantes de la estructura trófica es central en ecología. El presente trabajo brinda evidencia empírica sobre el rol del tamaño corporal, la dimensión del espacio de búsqueda de los depredadores y la estrategia de alimentación como determinantes de la posición trófica y su relación con el tamaño. La capacidad de capturar y consumir presas limitado por la apertura de boca es una restricción para la obtención de energía, especialmente en aquellos de pequeño tamaño. Este mecanismo genera una jerarquía de tamaños en la posición trófica de los organismos, donde los grandes consumen a los más pequeños, explicando así gran parte de la variación en la relación tamaño corporal‐posición trófica. Sin embargo, la dimensión espacial en la búsqueda de presas (2D, 3D), la temperatura, las estrategias alimentarias y la productividad primaria del sistema pueden modificar la relación esperada. Esto ha sido escasamente explorado in situ en tramas tróficas naturales. El presente trabajo estableció predicciones específicas en la relación tamaño corporal posición trófica y lo evaluó en diferentes módulos de un ecosistema subtropical marino‐costero de Sudamérica: el ambiente bentónico (2D, costa rocosa y playa arenosa) y pelágico (3D). La estructura trófica se caracterizó mediante isótopos estables de carbono y nitrógeno en 256 organismos, desde productores primarios (macroalgas y fitoplancton) hasta grandes depredadores (tiburón sarda) en verano e invierno. El rango de tamaños corporales abarcó 6 órdenes de magnitud en peso, desde 10−2 a 6 × 104 g. La señal isotópica indicó una integración de fuentes de carbono desde los consumidores primarios hasta los depredadores superiores. Se observó una relación lineal positiva entre el tamaño corporal y la posición trófica, con una pendiente menor para el ambiente pelágico (3D) con respecto al bentónico (2D), coincidente con las predicciones teóricas. No se observaron diferencias estacionales. La relación tamaño corporal y la posición trófica del ambiente bentónico presentó una gran variabilidad, con restricciones diferenciales entre grupos taxonómicos según sus hábitos alimentarios. Esta evaluación basada en el tamaño corporal, el espacio de búsqueda y la estrategia de alimentación permiten comprender los determinantes de la posici -Abstract Truncated-

Spatiotemporal patterns of trophic niche variation within and among species of tropical coastal fishes

Habitat dimensionality and feeding strategies but not temperature as determinants of body size‐trophic structure relationship in a marine food web

Hydro-morphological features and functional structure of fish assemblages mediate species isotopic niches in estuaries

Fish metacommunity structure in estuarine systems of the Honduran coast of the Mesoamerican barrier reef region

Marine community trophic structure of Malpelo Island, Colombia from stable isotopes approach

ENSO effect on trophic interactions of three top predators in adjacent waters to Cabo San Lucas, Baja California Sur

Trophic guilds and niche segregation among marine megafauna in the Bay of Biscay

Functional diversity of fish assemblages across a latitudinal gradient in coral ecosystems of the Mexican Tropical Pacific

Spatial factors overcome seasonality regulating the consumption of allochthonous food resources by fishes from tropical lotic ecosystems

Interpopulation trophic niches and ontogenetic shifts of a mangrove fish predator

Community connectivity and local heterogeneity explain animal species co‐occurrences within pond communities

Trophic niche partitioning among non-native fish species coexisting in a Colombian high Andean reservoir

Biological and environmental drivers of trophic ecology in marine fishes - a global perspective

Herbivorous Reef Fish Interaction with the Habitat and Physicochemical Variables in Coral Ecosystems in the Mexican Tropical Pacific

Implications of the environmental heterogeneity on the distribution of the fish functional diversity of the Campeche Bank, Gulf of Mexico

Fish Biomass in Tropical Estuaries: Substantial Variation in Food Web Structure, Sources of Nutrition and Ecosystem-Supporting Processes

Fish assemblages in an environmentally complex narrow coastal region in the Southwestern Atlantic Ocean: an alternative nursery habitat for fishery species

Temporal integration analysis of environmental behavior and fish abundance in selected coastal systems of the southern Gulf of Mexico

Cross-habitat utilization of fish in a tropical deltaic system as a function of climate variability and body size: Are mangroves fish nurseries in a tropical delta?

Spatial and Ontogenetic Trophic Dynamics of Co-occurring Predatory Fishes in a Northern Gulf of Mexico Estuary

Beyond ecological opportunity: Prey diversity rather than abundance shapes predator niche variation