Abstract:Tolling, or congestion pricing, offers a promising traffic management policy for regulating congestion, but has also attracted criticism for placing outsized financial burdens on low-income users. Credit-based congestion pricing (CBCP) and discount-based congestion pricing (DBCP) policies, which respectively provide travel credits and toll discounts to low-income users on tolled roads, have emerged as promising mechanisms for reducing traffic congestion without worsening societal inequities. However, the optimal design of CBCP and DBCP policies, as well as their relative advantages and disadvantages, remain poorly understood. To address this, we study the effects of implementing CBCP and DBCP policies to route users on a network of multi-lane highways with tolled express lanes. We formulate a non-atomic routing game framework in which a subset of eligible users is granted toll relief in the form of a fixed budget or toll discount, while the remaining ineligible users must pay out-of-pocket. We prove the existence of Nash equilibrium traffic flow patterns corresponding to any given CBCP or DBCP policy. Under the additional assumption that eligible users have time-invariant VoTs, we provide a convex program to efficiently compute these equilibria. For networks consisting of a single edge, we identify conditions under which CBCP policies outperform DBCP policies (and vice versa), in the sense of improving eligible users' access to the express lane. Finally, we present empirical results from a CBCP pilot study of the San Mateo 101 Express Lane Project in California. Our empirical results corroborate our theoretical analysis of the impact of deploying credit-based and discount-based policies, and lend insights into the sensitivity of their impact with respect to the travel demand and users' VoTs.

The Effectiveness of Subsidies and Tolls in Congestion Games

Carrots or Sticks? The Effectiveness of Subsidies and Tolls in Congestion Games

Can Taxes Improve Congestion on All Networks?

Surrogate‐Based Optimization of Expensive‐to‐Evaluate Objective for Optimal Highway Toll Charges in Transportation Network

Credit vs. Discount-Based Congestion Pricing: A Comparison Study

Utilizing Information Optimally to Influence Distributed Network Routing

Effects of congestion charging and subsidy policy on vehicle flow and revenue with user heterogeneity

Adaptive Constraint Satisfaction for Markov Decision Process Congestion Games: Application to Transportation Networks

Learning to accept welfare-enhancing policies: an experimental investigation of congestion pricing

Dynamic Tolling in Arc-based Traffic Assignment Models

In Congestion Games, Taxes Achieve Optimal Approximation

Avoiding Unintended Consequences: How Incentives Aid Information Provisioning in Bayesian Congestion Games

Demand-Independent Optimal Tolls

Optimal Road Pricing for Both Traffic Efficiency and Safety

Comparison and optimization of cordon and area pricings for managing travel demand

Uncertain Congestion Games with Assorted Human Agent Populations

Congestion Transportation Network and Optimal Environmental Link Tolls

Congestion Pricing for Efficiency and Equity: Theory and Applications to the San Francisco Bay Area

A Trial-and-Error Toll Design Method for Traffic Congestion Mitigation on Large River-Crossing Channels in a Megacity

Bridging the Gap Between Central and Local Decision-Making: The Efficacy of Collaborative Equilibria in Altruistic Congestion Games

High-Performance Optimal Incentive-Seeking in Transactive Control for Traffic Congestion