Optimal Road Pricing for Both Traffic Efficiency and Safety

Shaopeng Zhong,Lihui Zhang,Ying-En Ge
2014-01-01
Abstract:The impacts of road traffic congestion charge on traffic safety are often overlooked in evaluating the benefits of congestion charge and searching for traffic safety strategies. In fact, a desirable congestion pricing scheme should not only improve traffic efficiency but also enhance road safety. This paper aims to explore the impacts of road pricing on both efficiency and safety of traffic. We develop two bi-level programs for determining the optimal tolls that minimize the negative externalities of both traffic congestion and accidents. One of them produces a Pareto-optimal solution and the other offers a Nash bargaining solution. To obtain a Nash bargaining solution, this paper proposes a hybrid evolution algorithm for solving the newly-formulated bi-level program. A comparison of the total network travel time and loss due to traffic accidents between the no-toll and toll cases on an example road network shows that a Nash-bargaining-solution-based congestion charging scheme can save 12.2% of the total network travel time and reduce the average hourly number of traffic accidents per year by 62.1%. Furthermore, our results indicate that the traditional efficiency-oriented road pricing scheme, which did not consider its impacts on road traffic safety, has been implemented in a less beneficial manner. It is also numerically shown that a Pareto-optimal-solution-based congestion pricing scheme can reduce more than 7.7% of the average hourly number of accidents per year when it is compared to the traditional efficiency-oriented congestion charge scheme.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?