Abstract:Introduction: Advancements in DNA extraction and sequencing technologies have been fundamental in deciphering the significance of the microbiome related to human health and pathology. Whole metagenome shotgun sequencing (WMS) is gaining popularity in use compared to its predecessor (i.e., amplicon-based approaches). However, like amplicon-based approaches, WMS is subject to bias from DNA extraction methods that can compromise the integrity of sequencing and subsequent findings. The purpose of this study was to evaluate systematic differences among four commercially available DNA extraction kits frequently used for WMS analysis of the microbiome. Methods: Oral, vaginal, and rectal swabs were collected in replicates of four by a healthcare provider from five participants and randomized to one of four DNA extraction kits. Two extraction blanks and three replicate mock community samples were also extracted using each extraction kit. WMS was completed with NovaSeq 6000 for all samples. Sequencing and microbial communities were analyzed using nonmetric multidimensional scaling and compositional bias analysis. Results: Extraction kits differentially biased the percentage of reads attributed to microbial taxa across samples and body sites. The PowerSoil Pro kit performed best in approximating expected proportions of mock communities. While HostZero was biased against gram-negative bacteria, the kit outperformed other kits in extracting fungal DNA. In clinical samples, HostZERO yielded a smaller fraction of reads assigned to Homo sapiens across sites and had a higher fraction of reads assigned to bacterial taxa compared to other kits. However, HostZERO appears to bias representation of microbial communities and demonstrated the most dispersion by site, particularly for vaginal and rectal samples. Conclusions: Systematic differences exist among four frequently referenced DNA extraction kits when used for WMS analysis of the human microbiome. Consideration of such differences in study design and data interpretation is imperative to safeguard the integrity of microbiome research and reproducibility of results.

Metagenomic Sequencing for Microbial DNA in Human Samples: Emerging Technological Advances

Metagenome and detection of animal microbial pathogens

Unified metagenomic method for rapid detection of microorganisms in clinical samples

Host and Microbiome Multi-Omics Integration: Applications and Methodologies.

METAGENOMICS IN STUDYING THE HUMAN GUT MICROBIOME Metagenomics : Revealing the diversity of the human gut microbiome

Metagenomics: An Effective Approach for Exploring Microbial Diversity and Functions

Sample Collection, DNA Extraction, and Library Construction Protocols of the Human Microbiome Studies in the International Human Phenome Project

Comparison of commercial DNA extraction kits for whole metagenome sequencing of human oral, vaginal, and rectal microbiome samples

Application of Metagenomics in the Human Gut Microbiome

Unravelling the enigma of the human microbiome: Evolution and selection of sequencing technologies

Application of metagenomics in the human gut microbiome.

High Sensitivity of Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing in Colon Tissue Biopsy by Host DNA Depletion

Metagenomics and Single-Cell Omics Data Analysis for Human Microbiome Research

Unveiling microbial diversity: harnessing long-read sequencing technology

Metagenomics approaches for studying the human microbiome

Impact of Host DNA and Sequencing Depth on the Taxonomic Resolution of Whole Metagenome Sequencing for Microbiome Analysis

Tools for microbial single-cell genomics for obtaining uncultured microbial genomes

Metagenomics for taxonomy profiling: tools and approaches

High-Throughput Metagenomics for Identification of Pathogens in the Clinical Settings

Analysis of the microbiome: Advantages of whole genome shotgun versus 16S amplicon sequencing

Clinical applications of metagenomics next-generation sequencing in infectious diseases