Close But Not Too Close? Optimal Copycat Strategies in the Light of Negative Publicity by the Original Product

Joachim Grosser,Hendrik Sonnabend,Bastian Westbrock
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/bejeap-2022-0456
2024-01-19
The B E Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy
Abstract:This paper contributes to the understanding of how brand scandals related to a brand leader's product affect the follower firm's choice between copycatting and independent product development. In a model of vertical product differentiation, we show that it is optimal for the copycatter to follow a 'safe distance' strategy which guarantees a certain degree of protection against the negative spillovers associated with a brand scandal to the leader. Nevertheless, when the follower firm can choose between copycatting and decoupling, it chooses a higher quality for its copycat product because of the lower development costs. The decision for or against copycatting thus depends on a trade-off between development costs and the possibility of negative spillovers. Finally, we show that the threat of a scandal can lead to an additional indirect welfare cost because it diverts the follower's choice away from a welfare-maximizing copycat strategy.
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?