Sentencing and placement of offenders with dementia: a significant contemporary challenge for the criminal justice system

John Anderson Amee Baird a School of Law & Justice,College of Human & Social Futures,University of Newcastle,NSW,Australiab Clinical Neuropsychologist,Newcastle Neuropsychology,Newcastle,NSW,Australia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13218719.2024.2377583

2024-09-10

Psychiatry Psychology and Law

Abstract:Dementia in its various forms causes progressive cognitive decline and associated behavioural changes. If a person with dementia commits a criminal offence, complex challenges can occur at all stages of the criminal justice process, including assessment of fitness to stand trial, determination of criminal responsibility if found to be fit and appropriate sentencing and placement if convicted. The timing and accuracy of a dementia diagnosis can impact legal outcomes and potentially lead to miscarriages of justice. This article analyses the intersection between dementia and criminal law, with a focus on sentencing. It is well established that an offender's mental impairment or ill health may mitigate any sentence imposed, but dementia poses a significant dilemma for courts in determining moral culpability and appropriate sentencing options, particularly for serious crimes. The unique neurodegenerative nature of dementia makes it difficult to apply the traditional purposes of sentencing and raises the need for alternative solutions.

psychiatry,criminology & penology,law,psychology, multidisciplinary