Is Broader Health Insurance Coverage Always Better?

David A. Hyman,Sunjay Letchuman,Ge Bai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2023.7112

2024-03-05

JAMA Internal Medicine

Abstract:This Viewpoint discusses the traditional goals of health insurance and contrasts those with the current needs of insurance beneficiaries.

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Outcome-based Health Equity Across Different Social Health Insurance Schemes for the Elderly in China

Xiaoting Liu,Hung Wong,Kai Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-016-1261-5

2015-01-01

BMC Health Services Research

Abstract:Background: Against the achievement of nearly universal coverage for social health insurance for the elderly in China, a problem of inequity among different insurance schemes on health outcomes is still a big challenge for the health care system. Whether various health insurance schemes have divergent effects on health outcome is still a puzzle. Empirical evidence will be investigated in this study.Methods: This study employs a nationally representative survey database, the National Survey of the Aged Population in Urban/Rural China, to compare the changes of health outcomes among the elderly before and after the reform. A one-way ANOVA is utilized to detect disparities in health care expenditures and health status among different health insurance schemes. Multiple Linear Regression is applied later to examine the further effects of different insurance plans on health outcomes while controlling for other social determinants.Results: The one-way ANOVA result illustrates that although the gaps in insurance reimbursements between the Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance (UEBMI) and the other schemes, the New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme (NCMS) and Urban Residents Basic Medical Insurance (URBMI) decreased, out-of-pocket spending accounts for a larger proportion of total health care expenditures, and the disparities among different insurances enlarged. Results of the Multiple Linear Regression suggest that UEBMI participants have better self-reported health status, physical functions and psychological wellbeing than URBMI and NCMS participants, and those uninsured. URBMI participants report better self-reported health than NCMS ones and uninsured people, while having worse psychological wellbeing compared with their NCMS counterparts.Conclusions: This research contributes to a transformation in health insurance studies from an emphasis on the opportunity-oriented health equity measured by coverage and healthcare accessibility to concern with outcome-based equity composed of health expenditure and health status. The results indicate that fragmented health insurance schemes generate inequitable health care utilization and health outcomes for the elderly. This study re-emphasizes the importance of reforming health insurance systems based on their health outcome rather than entitlement, which will particularly benefit the most vulnerable older groups.
Variations in health insurance coverage: benefits vs. premiums

G R Wilensky,P J Farley,A K Taylor

Abstract:Renewed national interest in market forces to promote more efficient and cost-conscious behavior by patients and providers increasingly focuses on the structure of private health insurance benefits. Two features of procompetitive legislative proposals are considered: a ceiling on tax-free employer insurance premiums and offering greater choice of insurance plans. The interests of efficiency and equity invoke different kinds of risks and transfers; no single institutional approach is likely to yield the promised benefits.
A Restricted View on Medical Insurance System Reform and Development in the 21th Century

GUO Yong-song,LI Ping

2007-01-01

Abstract:The characteristics of medical insurance system reform and development in the 21th century are shown in several aspects.Theoretically,it emphasizes taking the right of accessing to medical care as a basic human right.The universality and fairness are the necessities for covering the objects of medical insurance. In the content of health care,the health prevention should be taken more concern on.The combination of government and market is the right way of implementing the health care system.In the respect of service mode,the multi-level and net work community health service system as well as the applying appropriate medical technique should be built actively.In financing form of health care,we should pay more attention to set up a multi-resource financing system which is mainly subsidized by the government.
More options, more problems? Lost in the health insurance maze

Christian Biener,Lan Zou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jori.12461

IF: 1.452

2024-02-15

Journal of Risk & Insurance

Abstract:While the opportunity to choose from a diverse range of options can be advantageous, consumers often struggle to make optimal decisions in the domain of health insurance. In this study, we examine the effects of decision aids on improving choice optimality in a health insurance setting that allows for variations in coverage but is standardized otherwise. While this relatively simplistic setting theoretically implies optimal conditions for observing large fractions of optimal choices, we observe widespread adoption of non‐welfare‐maximizing plans, with at least 36% of the population winding up with suboptimal insurance plans. In a hypothetical‐choice survey experimental setting, we estimate the treatment effects of increasing transparency through information provision and restricting choice on choice optimality. We find that decision quality cannot be improved meaningfully by our interventions and that nonoptimal choice is economically relevant, as it accounts for an increase of approximately 9.4% in total annual cost.

economics,business, finance
Is Universal and Uniform Health Insurance Better for China? Evidence from the Perspective of Supply-Induced Demand.

Jianxing Yu,Yue Qiu,Ziying He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1744133118000385

2018-01-01

Health Economics Policy and Law

Abstract:China has achieved nearly universal social health insurance (SHI) coverage by implementing three statutory schemes, but gaps and differences in benefit levels are apparent. There is wide agreement that China should merge the three schemes into a universal and uniform SHI. However, data on the medical expenses of all inpatients in 2014 at a public Tier-three hospital suggests that supply-induced demand (SID) is a serious concern and that, under the design of the current schemes, a higher benefit level has a greater impact on the total expenses of insured patients. Thus, if SID is not effectively controlled, a universal and uniform SHI may be more harmful than beneficial in China. Finally, we suggest that China should substitute the existing fee-for-service design with a suite of bundled provider payment methods; furthermore, China should replace its current system of pricing drugs that encourages hospitals and doctors to use costlier medications.
Health Insurance, Market Power, and Social Welfare

Run Liang,Hao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ijet.12137

2017-01-01

International Journal of Economic Theory

Abstract:This paper considers the welfare effects of health insurance. With a rather general model, we show that the presence of traditional health insurance makes consumers worse off when the marginal cost of health care is low enough, while always making the health care provider better off. The presence of traditional health insurance increases social welfare, but cannot achieve the socially optimal outcome. Furthermore, we consider a market structure called "integrated health insurance" and show that in a health care market where a firm provides not only health care but also health insurance, the socially optimal outcome can be achieved.
Health Insurance and Social Welfare

Hao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1755823

2010-01-01

Abstract:It is often suggested in the literature that consumers purchase too much health insurance. But Wigger and Anlauf (2007) find that consumers are actually under-insured against health expenses in market equilibrium from the perspective of social welfare. We generalize Wigger and Anlauf (2007)’s two-state model to one with a continuum of health states. We reaffirm their findings that health insurance may leave consumers worse off, but leave health care providers better off. The equilibrium insurance coverage is below the social optimal level. Furthermore, we find that the conventional health insurance leads to a second-best outcome that is better than that without health insurance.
Health Insurance Business in India: Progress, Issues and Way Forward

Suchismita Paul,Soumitra Sarkar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/09720634231215389

2023-12-22

Journal of Health Management

Abstract:Journal of Health Management, Ahead of Print. India's healthcare system is witnessing increased medical inflation, which is outpacing per capita Gross Domestic Product growth. With increased lifestyle diseases and, most recently, a pandemic caused by COVID-19, the cost of financing healthcare has become a huge issue, especially when government spending on healthcare is so low. In light of this, this article emphasises the significance of privately purchased, that is voluntary health insurance in addition to the government-sponsored health insurance programme for the vast uninsured population. Starting with the history of health insurance in India, this article examines premium growth, underwriting profit, investment income, net profit, incurred claims ratio and other metrics. Following that, the difficulties in the health insurance industry and their breadth are examined through a review of literature and recent newspaper reporting. The key issues resulting in negative underwriting experience are the inefficient risk pooling and unregulated private health care costs. A risk-sharing mechanism with an indemnification model must be implemented for better cost management to eliminate value fragmentation. Finally, ideas are given for resolving the challenges and increasing the market share of the health insurance company, with a focus on long-term business models such as managed care.
A Benefit Analysis and Policy Consideration of Basic Health Insurance System

李玲,崔玄,陈秋霖,王敏瑶,刘天然

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2010.04.005

2010-01-01

Abstract:One important objective of current health care reform is to expand the coverage,and to increase the participants' benefits of basic health insurance system(BHIS),then to construct an uniform health insurance according to China's characteristics.With data from our survey,this paper mainly analyzes management problems of BHIS.We compare the benefits participants separately getting from New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme,Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance and Urban Residents' Basic Medical Insurance,and we conclude that the current segmented system has caused high administration cost,inefficient fund management and the difficulty of health care cost control.Based on this research,we provide a policy recommendation to promote integration of the health insurance and health service delivery system.
Competitive markets for individual health insurance

Scott Harrington,Tom Miller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.w2.359

Abstract:A more dynamic individual insurance market could match benefits with individual preferences, provide more portable and permanent coverage, and stimulate consumer-focused service. Necessary reforms, such as tax parity and targeted assistance to high-risk pools, would enable individual coverage to expand efficiently. In contrast, requirements for guaranteed issue and community rating drive low-risk persons out of voluntary individual markets and raise overall premiums. Guaranteed renewability and switching costs would stabilize individual-market risk pools. As the individual market becomes more representative of the overall population, insurers' perceived needs to underwrite and market selectively will lessen, making administrative loading factors less significant.
The Welfare Effects of Health Insurance

Run Liang,Hao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6249.2010.06.001

2010-01-01

Abstract:This paper considers the social welfare effects of health insurance in a model with perfect information.The analyses suggest that the entry of health insurance may lead consumers to be strictly worse off,but always lead health care providers to be strictly better off.More importantly,it always improves the social welfare.Because the insurers do not concern about the profit of health care providers,the equilibrium level of health insurance is below the social optimal level.
Social Medical Insurance:Within Sight but Within Accessibility More

Wenjiong He,Yixin Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3830.2010.02.005

2010-01-01

Abstract:This paper states that we should make clear about the coverage objective,broaden responsibility properly,raise protection level,make administration revolutions and cut costs in order to provide the optimum disease risk protection service with the minimum social costs and assure the healthy operation of the social medical insurance considering.
Consumers' Perceptions And Choices Related To Three Value-Based Insurance Design Approaches

Susan L Perez,Melissa Gosdin,Jessie Kemmick Pintor,Patrick S Romano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05048

Abstract:The burden of rising health care costs is being shifted to consumers, and 30 percent of health care costs are attributed to wasteful spending on low- or no-value services. Value-based insurance design (VBID) is intended to encourage the use of high-value services or discourage the use of low-value services by aligning cost with quality. During the summer and fall of 2016, this mixed-methods study used focus groups and a quantitative analysis of survey data to explore consumer decision making in Northern California. When presented with three common VBID approaches, the focus groups favored value-based benefit design the most (41 percent), followed by reference pricing (28 percent) and narrow networks (21 percent). When presented with VBID scenarios, participants were skeptical of the value-based trade-offs and reported seeking information they wanted instead of relying on information that health plans provide. Engaging consumers to successfully reduce waste through VBID will require clarifying trade-offs to support consumers' processes for arriving at high-value decisions as well as reaching out to consumers through trusted sources and networks.
When Should There Be Vertical Choice in Health Insurance Markets?

Victoria R Marone,Adrienne Sabety,Victoria R. Marone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20201073

IF: 10.7

2022-01-01

American Economic Review

Abstract:We study the welfare effects of offering choice over coverage levels—“vertical choice”—in regulated health insurance markets. We emphasize that heterogeneity in efficient coverage level is not sufficient to motivate choice. When premiums cannot reflect individuals’ costs, it may not be in consumers’ best interest to select their efficient coverage level. We show that vertical choice is efficient only if consumers with higher willingness to pay have a higher efficient level of coverage. We investigate this condition empirically and find that as long as a minimum coverage level can be enforced, the welfare gains from vertical choice are either zero or economically small. (JEL D82, G22, H75, I13, I21)

economics
Book Review: The Effect of Health Insurance on Medical Care Utilization and Implications for Insurance Expansion: A Review of the Literature

Thomas C. Buchmueller,Kevin Grumbach,Richard Kronick,James G. Kahn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1077558704271718

2005-02-01

Medical Care Research and Review

Abstract:Both the costs and benefits associated with extending health insurance coverage depend on the extent and exact ways in which health insurance affects the utilization of medical care. We review the literature relating to such effects with the goal of informing researchers interested in simulating the impact of policy initiatives aimed at achieving universal coverage. Overall, this literature is quite consistent in finding significant effects of insurance on all types of utilization. Insurance coverage increases outpatient utilization by roughly 1 visit per year for children and between 1 and 2 visits for adults. For both children and adults, these visits are associated with an increased receipt of preventive care. Insurance coverage also increases inpatient utilization for children and adults; for children, there is some evidence that insurance coverage reduces ambulatory care sensitive hospital admissions.

health care sciences & services,health policy & services
Some Thoughts on the Construction of Health Insurance Law

Wei Zhen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.369/j.issn.1674-3830.2016.4.005

2016-01-01

Abstract:"Social Insurance Law" has played a positive role in promoting the construction of medical insurance laws. But with the development of economics and society and the deepening of system reform, the new situation and new issues have brought about new requirements for the construction of medical insurance laws. Combined with the "Social Insurance Law", this article discussed issues of the combination of the urban and rural residents' medical insurance, the urban and rural residents' critical illness insurance, the cumulative length of payment for the retired, the transfer of medical insurance relationship, and the pre-payment and repayment of medical insurance fund. Based on the discussions, some suggestions for law revision or policy support were made.
Effects of Commercial Health Insurance on Medical and Health Services

Qi Liu

2013-01-01

Abstract:The article describes the theoretical basis,effect and drawback on commercial health insurance to medical and health service.The author also proposes some suggestions on the function elaboration of commercial health insurance,so as to provide theoretical references for the development of commercial health insurance on improving medical and health service.
Are Invisible Hands Good Hands in Health Care Markets? Extension

Hao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/bejte-2015-0050

2017-01-01

Abstract:A previous study finds that increased competition in health care markets improves social welfare, although consumers use "too much" health care when they have health insurance. The analysis assumes that consumers have a constant Arrow-Pratt coefficient of absolute risk aversion. This note shows that this finding can be extended to the case where consumers are simply risk averse. Furthermore, if insurers offered insurance policies with slightly lower usage prices than the equilibrium level, social welfare would be improved.
For the Commercially Insured, Equitable Health Benefits Begin With Equitable Health Insurance Design

Bruce W. Sherman,Irene Dankwa-Mullan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/08901171211073408b

2022-04-14

American Journal of Health Promotion

Abstract:Equitable health benefit design is central to addressing the health inequities of individuals with commercial health insurance in the United States. To do so, employers and other plan sponsors must take action to identify and address unmet health and well-being priorities among racialized groups and low-income workers. These historically underrepresented subpopulations will also benefit from more equitable approaches to healthcare benefits design that recognize and meaningfully address access and affordability concerns. Targeted appropriately, these actions have the potential to foster greater employee engagement and productivity, leading to enhanced business performance.
Constructing health consumers: Private health insurance discourses in Australia and the United Kingdom

Kirsten Harley,Karen Willis,Jonathan Gabe,Stephanie Doris Short,Fran Collyer,Kristin Natalier,Michael Calnan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5172/hesr.2011.20.3.306

2011-09-01

Health Sociology Review

Abstract:Significant transformations of the health care services sector over the past three decades have seen an increasing reliance on the private provision of health care services mediated through private health insurance. In countries such as Australia and the UK, private health insurance is promoted as providing a greater choice for individuals and easing the burden on the public system. While these claims, the policy contexts and the decision-making processes of individual consumers have attracted some sociological attention, little has been said about the role of private insurers. In this article we present a comparative analysis of the websites of private health insurers in Australia and the UK. Our analysis highlights adoption by private health insurers of neoliberal discourses of choice and individual responsibility, partnership and healthy lifestyles. In these respects, similarities between the discourses over-ride national differences which might otherwise be expected given their contrasting health care traditions and contexts.

health policy & services,sociology

Is Broader Health Insurance Coverage Always Better?

Outcome-based Health Equity Across Different Social Health Insurance Schemes for the Elderly in China

Variations in health insurance coverage: benefits vs. premiums

A Restricted View on Medical Insurance System Reform and Development in the 21th Century

More options, more problems? Lost in the health insurance maze

Is Universal and Uniform Health Insurance Better for China? Evidence from the Perspective of Supply-Induced Demand.

Health Insurance, Market Power, and Social Welfare

Health Insurance and Social Welfare

Health Insurance Business in India: Progress, Issues and Way Forward

A Benefit Analysis and Policy Consideration of Basic Health Insurance System

Competitive markets for individual health insurance

The Welfare Effects of Health Insurance

Social Medical Insurance:Within Sight but Within Accessibility More

Consumers' Perceptions And Choices Related To Three Value-Based Insurance Design Approaches

When Should There Be Vertical Choice in Health Insurance Markets?

Book Review: The Effect of Health Insurance on Medical Care Utilization and Implications for Insurance Expansion: A Review of the Literature

Some Thoughts on the Construction of Health Insurance Law

Effects of Commercial Health Insurance on Medical and Health Services

Are Invisible Hands Good Hands in Health Care Markets? Extension

For the Commercially Insured, Equitable Health Benefits Begin With Equitable Health Insurance Design

Constructing health consumers: Private health insurance discourses in Australia and the United Kingdom